# 12.2 Protein- dependent inborn errors of metabolis

# 12.2 Protein- dependent inborn errors of metabolism 1942

ESSENTIALS
Protein-​dependent inborn errors of metabolism are caused by in-
herited enzyme defects of catabolic pathways or intracellular trans-
port of amino acids. Most result in an accumulation of metabolites 
upstream of the defective enzyme (amino acids and/​or ammonia), 
causing intoxication.
Protein-​dependent metabolic diseases usually have a low preva-
lence except for some high-​risk communities with high consan-
guinity rates. However, the cumulative prevalence of these disorders 
is considerable (i.e. at least >1:2000 newborns) and represents an 
important challenge for all public health systems.
Types of protein-​dependent inborn errors of metabolism
Amino acid disorders—​enzyme deficiencies in the proximal part of 
amino acid catabolism result in accumulation of precursor amino 
acids which are detectable by ninhydrin (a chemical used to detect 
ammonia or primary and secondary amines) and thus are called 
amino acid disorders. Phenylketonuria (PKU) is the most frequent 
such condition in white people.
Organic acid disorders—​distal enzyme defects of amino acid deg-
radation result in pathological accumulation of organic acids but not 
the precursor amino acid. These disorders became detectable after 
the introduction of gas chromatography–​mass spectrometry and are 
called organic acid disorders.
Urea cycle defects—​breakdown of amino acids results in the re-
lease of ammonia that is detoxified by the urea cycle, which is com-
posed of five catalytic enzymes, a cofactor producer, and at least two 
transport proteins. The biochemical hallmark of urea cycle defects is 
hyperammonaemia.
Understanding of the protein-​dependent inborn errors is based 
on the observation that some pathological metabolites impair key 
intracellular functions, such as energy metabolism, and thus when 
elevated may become toxic. These metabolites are excreted by urine 
or following conjugation to L-​carnitine or L-​glycine. However, in 
some diseases, such as disorders of tetrahydrobiopterin metabolism, 
clinical symptoms result from inadequate production of essential 
metabolites, such as the monoaminergic neurotransmitters.
Clinical presentation
Children with inherited disorders of amino acid, organic acid, or the 
urea cycle are usually born at term after an uneventful pregnancy and 
are initially asymptomatic. The onset of the first symptoms is varied, 
ranging from neonatal metabolic decompensation to onset of symp-
toms during adulthood. Irreversible organ damage and/​or early 
death often follow if the diagnosis is delayed or missed. Metabolic 
decompensations in childhood are triggered by excess intake of pro-
tein and—​most importantly—​secondary to breakdown of body pro-
tein during episodes that induce catabolism.
Family history—​if carefully taken, this may reveal important clues to 
the diagnosis of protein-​dependent inborn metabolic errors. Most 
disorders are inherited as autosomal recessive traits, which may 
be suspected if the parents are consanguineous or the family has 
a confined ethnic or geographic background. Carriers for particular 
disorders and affected children may be more frequent in certain 
communities (e.g. Amish), ethnic groups (e.g. Ashkenazi Jews, Arabic 
tribes), or countries that have seen little immigration over many cen-
turies (e.g. Finland). Specialist investigations are often started only 
after a second affected child is born into a family: older siblings may 
be found to suffer from a similar disorder as the index patient or have 
died from an acute unexplained disease.
Disease spectrum—​this is broad, but follows a distinct pattern in 
specific disorders, for instance: (1) untreated patients with classical 
PKU and cerebral organic acid disorders characteristically present 
with neurological symptoms. (2) Acute life-​threatening decompen-
sation is common in classical organic acid, urea cycle defects, and 
maple syrup urine disorder; the young infant vomits or refuses to feed 
and then deteriorates rapidly. (3) Asymptomatic protein-​dependent 
inborn metabolic errors are rare, but there are a few known enzyme 
defects, such as histidinaemia, which do not produce disease.
Investigation and management
Every infant presenting with symptoms of unexplained metabolic 
crisis, intoxication, or encephalopathy requires urgent evaluation 
of metabolic parameters, including analyses of arterial blood gases, 
serum glucose and lactate, plasma ammonia and amino acids, 
acylcarnitine profiling in dried blood spots, and organic acid analysis 
in urine.
Acute emergency therapy—​basic principles are to (1)  suppress 
muscle and liver protein catabolism and ensure a glucose supply 
above the basal metabolic demand; (2) treat any precipitating illness; 
(3) reduce increased production of toxic metabolites by reduction 
or omission of natural protein; (4) enhance detoxifying mechanisms 
12.2
Protein-​dependent inborn errors 
of metabolism
Georg F. Hoffmann and Stefan Kölker


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1943
and urinary excretion of pathological metabolites; (5)  aggressively 
treat dehydration and acidosis; (6) prevent secondary carnitine de-
pletion; and (7) provide alternative routes of ammonia disposal in 
hyperammonaemia.
Long-​term treatment—​this aims principally to mitigate the meta-
bolic consequences of enzyme deficiencies by compensating for 
them, including: (1) reduction of toxic metabolites by dietary restric-
tion of precursor amino acids, prevention of catabolism, stimulation 
of residual enzyme activity (e.g. with cofactors), and detoxification 
strategies; and (2)  substitution with depleted substrates, such as 
biotin, cobalamin, or L-​dopa. However, efficacy is often low in pa-
tients in whom diagnosis is made after the onset of symptoms, hence 
newborn screening programmes have been introduced in many 
countries, the criteria for implementation of which include: (1) reli-
able presymptomatic disease detection, (2) treatability of the disease, 
and (3) starting of treatment in presymptomatic children.
Successful treatment of affected individuals is often difficult to 
achieve. Careful supervision in metabolic centres involving an ex-
perienced multidisciplinary team is invaluable for the best outcome. 
Treatment is time-​ and cost-​intensive, often lifelong, and mostly per-
formed at home, hence regular training and support of patients and 
their families is essential to prevent irreversible complications. All 
patients should carry an emergency card that gives details of their 
condition and relevant contact numbers. Parent and patient organ-
izations can offer useful support.
Detailed description of individual disorders is to be found in the 
text of this chapter, and further information on diagnosis, genetic 
testing, treatment and follow-​up is available from several online 
databases (see ‘Further reading’).
Introduction
Humans depend on dietary protein as a source of amino acids; they 
are the metabolic basis of all functional and structural proteins in the 
body. Some amino acids—​termed essential—​cannot be synthesized 
by the human body, such l-​isoleucine and l-​phenylalanine. Renal 
conservation of amino acids is extremely effective, with clearance 
values mostly less than 1%. Stool nitrogen losses are about 1 g/​day 
and are mostly of bacterial origin.
In contrast to glucose and fatty acids, amino acids taken in excess 
of requirement cannot be stored but are used for energy. The initial 
step of degradation is the removal of the amino group. Ammonia 
enters the urea cycle for conversion to urea. The remaining carbon 
skeletons are degraded via multistep individual pathways to central 
metabolic intermediates such as acetyl coenzyme A (CoA) or tricarb-
oxylic acid cycle intermediates. Some enzymes require coenzymes, 
and inherited disease may be due to defects of the apoenzymes or 
their vitamin coenzymes, for example, biotin, pyridoxine (vitamin 
B6), or cobalamin (vitamin B12).
Amino acids can be specifically detected by the ninhydrin re-
action, which became available in the late 1940s, resulting in the 
identification of disorders such as phenylketonuria (PKU) or maple 
syrup urine disease. Breakdown of many amino acids occurs mostly 
intramitochondrially through degradation of CoA-​activated car-
bonic acids, the so-​called acyl-​CoA compounds. These nonamino 
organic acids are not detectable by amino acid analysis. Since defects 
of the latter phases of amino acid degradation induce accumulation 
of organic acids but not amino acid precursors, these disorders be-
came detectable after the introduction of gas chromatography, es-
pecially gas chromatography–​mass spectrometry (GC/​MS) in the 
1960s and 1970s and have been termed organic acid disorders. Thus 
the terminology amino acid and organic acid disorders is not based 
on pathophysiological differences but simply on the different analyt-
ical approaches.
In this chapter, amino acid disorders, urea cycle defects, and or-
ganic acid disorders are described; defects in mitochondrial me-
tabolism and amino acid transport in the kidney tubule and small 
intestine are not considered.
Historical perspective
In 1902, Archibald Garrod introduced the term ‘inborn errors of 
metabolism’. An extraordinary scientist and paediatrician, he used 
consanguinity and distribution of cases in families to introduce 
the hypothesis that autosomal recessive inheritance according to 
Mendel’s rediscovered laws would explain the occurrence of the 
alkaptonuria phenotype, a defect in tyrosine degradation. Soon 
afterwards he also recognized albinism, cystinuria, and pentosuria 
as inborn errors.
Metabolic medicine is closely linked with advances in laboratory 
techniques. The use of paper chromatography by Bickel and Dent 
and of automated column chromatography by Moore and Stein 
opened the field of amino acid disorders. In the late 1960s, Tanaka 
discovered isovaleric aciduria by GC/​MS, and this was followed 
by the identification of numerous organic acid disorders. More re-
cently, the rise of molecular biology has revolutionized the field, and 
now tandem mass spectroscopy and next-​generation sequencing 
are proving powerful tools in screening and diagnosis. Monogenic 
defects have been identified for almost every known enzymatic 
step of protein metabolism. Often it was the discovery of patients 
with enzyme defects which unravelled individual steps in human 
metabolism.
Until the early 1950s, no treatment of any genetic disorder ex-
isted; destiny would take its course, and genetic counselling about 
recurrence risks was all that could be offered. That changed when, 
in 1953, Bickel showed that PKU can be successfully treated and 
that early diagnosis and dietary treatment change the outcome 
from severe learning difficulties to normal psychosocial develop-
ment. Subsequently, many other metabolic diseases became man-
ageable in a similar way using the substrate deprivation strategy. 
Pharmacological doses of vitamins proved useful in defects of 
cobalamin and biotin metabolism, homocystinuria, and others. 
Simultaneously with the perception that identification of chil-
dren before the onset of clinical symptoms is indispensable to im-
prove the outcome, reliable and cheap screening methods have 
been developed. In the United States of America, Guthrie set the 
cornerstone for newborn screening by developing a bacterial in-
hibition assay to detect PKU. Despite early disagreement and re-
sistance by the medical profession, newborn screening has proven 
its worth over the years and the test is still called the ‘Guthrie test’ 
worldwide.
In 1999, the World Health Organization announced orphan dis-
eases as a major future health challenge. Among these diseases, 


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1944
disorders of amino acid and organic acid metabolism are especially 
important because of their cumulative prevalence (>1:2000 new-
borns) and because successful therapy is available for most of them. 
Inborn metabolic diseases have become a significant challenge for 
healthcare systems, particularly in countries where infectious dis-
eases and other perinatal problems are receding in importance.
Aetiology, genetics, pathogenesis, and pathology
The clinical manifestations of most protein-​dependent inborn 
errors are thought to result from toxicity of the accumulating key 
metabolites to specific organs inducing selective or multiple organ 
failure. This ‘toxic metabolite hypothesis’ has influenced research 
and allowed the development of effective treatment.
Despite increasing knowledge of pathophysiology, the most rele-
vant concepts are derived from clinical research. For example, de-
fects of all six enzymes in the degradation pathway of phenylalanine 
and tyrosine are known by now (see also ‘Defects of phenylalanine 
and tyrosine metabolism’). Defects in the first enzyme, phenyl-
alanine hydroxylase, cause PKU (learning difficulties, seizures, 
ataxia, paresis, behavioural problems) and deficiency of tyrosine 
aminotransferase, the next enzyme, induces tyrosinaemia type II 
(corneal erosions, painful hyperkeratotic lesions, behavioural prob-
lems). A  defect of 4-​hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase is the 
cause of tyrosinaemia type III which is possibly a nondisease, only 
a few patients develop neurological manifestations. A block in the 
next step of the pathway, 4-​hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase, 
results in alkaptonuria (ochronosis, arthritis, heart disease), 
whereas deficiency of the last enzyme, fumarylacetoacetase, pro-
duces a disease deadly in early childhood, tyrosinaemia type I, 
presenting with failure to thrive, liver failure, hepatosplenomegaly, 
hepatocarcinoma, and porphyria-​like crises. The distinct syndromes 
resulting from defective breakdown of aromatic amino acids could 
never have been inferred simply by biochemical exploration of the 
metabolic pathway.
Epidemiology
As a group, protein-​dependent disorders are by far the most 
common, acutely life-​threatening inborn errors of metabolism (esti-
mated prevalence >1:2000 newborns). However, reliable epidemio-
logical data are scarce as all reports suggest a significant portion of 
patients who evade diagnosis and are considered to have neonatal 
sepsis or sudden infant death syndrome. All disorders cannot be re-
liably ascertained clinically, and until recently population neonatal 
screening has only been implemented for PKU. Most epidemio-
logical data are available from European countries, Japan, and the 
United States of America, highlighting variations based on ethnic 
background, migrations, and/​or genetic isolation. In a few com-
munities, the prevalence of individual disorders may increase up 
to five times the cumulative prevalence of amino acid and organic 
acid disorders in European countries, Japan, and the United States of 
America. For example, glutaric aciduria type I is found in up to 1 in 
300 newborns in the Amish Community (United States of America) 
and the Oji-​Cree First Nations (Canada), and in Qatar the preva-
lence of classic homocystinuria is 1 in 600 newborns.
Prevention
With the first successful treatment of a young girl with PKU, the 
need for timely diagnosis and implementation of treatment became 
imperative. In most inborn errors, affected neonates are completely 
asymptomatic and onset of irreversible symptoms during infancy 
and childhood can often be prevented if treatment is started while 
the child is asymptomatic. Since inborn errors of metabolism are 
rare, only neonatal mass screening can guarantee timely detection. 
However, which diseases are the most appropriate for screening re-
mains debatable. The criteria of Wilson and Jungner (1968) for an 
implementation to newborn screening include: (1) reliable disease 
detection in a presymptomatic state of the disease, (2) treatability of 
the disease, and (3) the start of treatment in the presymptomatic chil-
dren. In the 1960s, these criteria were achieved for PKU screening, 
which developed into one of the most important programmes of 
preventive medicine. Additional inborn errors such as maple syrup 
urine disease, galactosaemia, congenital hypothyroidism, and 
biotinidase deficiency were incorporated into newborn screening 
programmes of some countries.
In the 1990s, a revolutionary technology, tandem mass spectros-
copy (MS/​MS), was adopted for newborn screening. The possi-
bilities of multianalyte detection by MS/​MS led to a change in the 
screening paradigm, that is, one test for many diseases (instead of 
one test for one disease). MS/​MS improved screening for diseases 
from the conventional screening panels and opened the chance for 
inclusion of many other inborn errors of metabolism. However, 
each novel candidate disease has to be evaluated with respect to 
whether this disease fulfils the criteria for a disease to be screened 
(see Chapters 2.12 and 12.1), taking into consideration differences 
in national healthcare systems. As a consequence, the number of 
screened inborn errors of metabolism varies considerably ranging 
from two disorders (United Kingdom, Switzerland) up to more than 
50 disorders (some parts of the United States of America). Notably, 
the United States screening panel also includes conditions that can 
be regarded as nondiseases or have at least a doubtful pathological 
meaning, such as the 3-​methylcrotonyl CoA carboxylase deficiency. 
It should be appreciated that a liberal expansion of the screening 
panel burdens the healthcare system, the affected individuals, and 
the increasing number of false-​positive individuals and their fam-
ilies. Given these difficulties, it is to be hoped that screening politics 
will become harmonized in a joint international effort.
Clinical considerations and diagnostic work-​up
History
A careful family history may reveal important clues to the diagnosis 
of protein-​dependent inborn metabolic diseases. Most disorders are 
inherited as autosomal recessive traits which may be suspected if 
the parents are consanguineous or the family has a confined ethnic 
or geographic background. Carriers for particular disorders and 
affected children may be more frequent in certain communities 
(e.g. Amish), ethnic groups (e.g. Ashkenazi Jews, Arabic tribes), 
or countries that have seen little immigration over many centuries 
(e.g. Finland). Often specialist investigations are started only after 
a second affected child is born into a family. Older siblings may be 


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1945
found to have a similar disorder to the index patient, or to have died 
from an acute unexplained disease classified as ‘sepsis with uniden-
tified pathogen’, ‘encephalopathy’, or ‘sudden infant death syndrome’. 
Notably, the disease course of the same disorder may vary consid-
erably even within families depending on genotype–​phenotype 
correlation (if any), varying X-​inactivation in female carriers (e.g. 
ornithine transcarbamylase deficiency), and dominant disorders 
with variable penetration (e.g. Segawa’s disease).
As a result of the successful treatment of inborn errors of metab-
olism, an increasing number of affected women are reaching repro-
ductive age. If they become pregnant, there may be a risk for their 
fetuses to be harmed by toxic metabolites from the mother. Especially 
important is maternal PKU, which is likely to become a major health 
problem. Other maternal conditions may cause ‘metabolic’ disease 
in the neonate or infant postnatally, for example, methylmalonic 
aciduria and hyperhomocystinaemia, in fully breastfed children of 
mothers who have pernicious anaemia or who are on a vegan diet, 
which fosters nutritional vitamin B12 deficiency.
Clinical spectrum
The range of clinical and biochemical manifestations of the protein-​
dependent metabolic errors is wide. Here we focus on the clinical 
manifestation and differential diagnosis of disorders presenting 
with acute metabolic decompensations (Boxes 12.2.1 and 12.2.2). 
There is only a limited repertoire of pathophysiological sequences in 
the response to metabolic intoxication and, consequently, a limited 
number of therapeutic measures. Timely and correct intervention 
during the initial episode is a critical prognostic factor.
Many protein-​dependent metabolic errors already manifest in 
the first days of life with progressive irritability or drowsiness. Most 
typically, a young infant may vomit or refuse to feed and then rap-
idly deteriorates. The initial erroneous diagnoses are usually neo-
natal sepsis or intracranial haemorrhage: a presumptive diagnosis of 
a protein-​dependent inborn error should be considered with equal 
priority. Children with milder forms may be repeatedly admitted, 
for example, with unusual metabolic acidosis, hypoglycaemia, or 
neutropenia in the course of common infections especially gastro-
enteritis, before an inborn disorder of metabolism is considered, and 
routine clinical chemistry may be normal in between crises.
A substantial number of patients with protein-​dependent inborn 
errors of metabolism may present differently with acute encephalop-
athy or chronic and fluctuating progressive neurological disease. The 
so-​called cerebral organic acidaemias (e.g. glutaric aciduria type I) 
characteristically present with (progressive) neurological symptoms 
such as ataxia, myoclonus, extrapyramidal symptoms, and metabolic 
stroke. Routine clinical chemistry is often unrevealing. Important diag-
nostic clues such as progressive disturbances of myelination, cere-
bellar atrophy, frontotemporal atrophy, signal abnormalities, and/​or 
infarcts of the basal ganglia can be derived from MRI of the brain. 
Chronic subdural effusions, haematomas, and retinal haemorrhages 
in infants and toddlers are characteristic findings in glutaric aciduria 
type I, although they are more commonly due to child abuse.
Laboratory investigations
The early consideration of metabolic diseases is of the utmost im-
portance. Basic evaluation of metabolic parameters including ana-
lyses of blood gases, serum glucose and lactate, plasma ammonia and 
amino acids, acylcarnitine profiling in dried blood spots (MS/​MS), 
and organic acid analysis in urine (GC/​MS) should be performed on 
an emergency basis in every patient presenting with symptoms of 
unexplained metabolic crisis, intoxication, or encephalopathy.
Routine laboratory parameters
Diagnostic clues can be obtained from routine laboratory inves-
tigations such as electrolytes (also required for the calculation of 
the anion gap), urinary ketones, serum transaminases, and cre-
atine kinase. Any child admitted to an intensive care unit with life-​
threatening nonsurgical illness should be tested for these parameters.
Box 12.2.1  Presentation of organic acidurias
Intoxication
	•	 Kussmaul tachypnoea/​acidotic breathing
	•	 Peculiar smell
	•	 Refusal of/​adverse reaction to feeding
	•	 Protracted episodic vomiting
	•	 Erroneous diagnosis of pyloric stenosis (with acidosis)
	•	 Reye’s syndrome presentation
	•	 Hepatomegaly/​liver failure
	•	 Rhabdomyolysis
	•	 Sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) or ‘near miss’ SIDS
Acute encephalopathy
	•	 Coma
	•	 Seizures (myoclonic, intractable)
	•	 Acute profound dyskinesia
	•	 Pseudotumour cerebri
	•	 Cerebral/​intraventricular haemorrhage in full-​term babies
	•	 Stroke-​like episodes
Chronic encephalo(myelo)pathy
	•	 Progressive psychomotor deterioration
	•	 Macrocephaly
	•	 Ataxia (progressive)
	•	 Hypotonia
	•	 Dystonia, athetosis
	•	 Myoclonus
	•	 Seizures (myoclonic, intractable)
	•	 Peripheral neuropathy
	•	 Pyramidal signs—​‘cerebral palsy’
	•	 Pronounced deficiency of speech
	•	 Congenital cerebral malformations
Box 12.2.2  Clinical chemical indices of organic acidurias
	•	 Metabolic acidosis
	•	 Increased anion gap
	•	 Hyperglycaemia
	•	 Ketosis and ketonuria (especially suggestive in newborns)
	•	 Lactic acidosis
	•	 Hyperammonaemia
	•	 Hyperuricaemia
	•	 Hypertriglyceridaemia
	•	 Increase of transaminases
	•	 Granulocytopenia, thrombocytopenia, and anaemia
	•	 Hypoketotic hypoglycaemia (fatty acid oxidation defects)
	•	 Increased creatine kinase (fatty acid oxidation defects)
	•	 Myoglobinuria (fatty acid oxidation defects)


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1946
Amino acid analysis
Many metabolic parameters show considerable diurnal fluctu-
ations. For example, plasma amino acid concentrations are highly 
dependent on the metabolic status, and standard samples should 
be obtained at least 4 h postprandially. Many amino acids can be 
reliably quantified in dried blood spots by MS/​MS (e.g. for PKU). 
Homocysteine and tryptophan require specific methods (usu-
ally high-​performance liquid chromatography (HPLC)) for exact 
quantification. Regular amino acid analyses are required in pa-
tients on specific dietary treatments to adjust intake of amino 
acids and to recognize a deficiency of essential amino acids and 
micronutrients. For optimal results, it is important to separate 
plasma as soon as possible and to ship samples frozen on dry ice. 
Haemolysis or shipment of whole blood results in useless values 
for some amino acids. Some potential problems are summarized 
in Box 12.2.3.
Quantitative urinary amino acid analysis is indicated only 
if a renal tubular reabsorption defect such as cystinuria is sus-
pected, and (in addition to plasma analysis) in hyperammonaemia 
when increased urinary excretion of specific metabolites (e.g. 
argininosuccinate) may be diagnostic.
Organic acid analysis
Organic acid analysis is best performed on early morning urine 
specimens. Complete information of the clinical status and recent 
management of the patient is indispensable for correct interpret-
ation, which is based on key diagnostic metabolites or character-
istic biochemical patterns. Repeated analyses may be necessary, 
preferably during exacerbation of metabolic decompensation, 
since analyses may be intermittently normal. Characteristic me-
tabolites may, however, also become masked in severe metabolic 
decompensation and ketosis. Some patients with organic acid dis-
orders may exhibit only slight elevations of diagnostic metabol-
ites that may be underestimated by conventional analysis, such 
as in 4-​hydroxybutyric aciduria, glutaric aciduria type I, and 
N-​acetylaspartic aciduria. In these disorders, quantification by 
stable isotope dilution assays is preferred. This is also the method 
of choice for biochemical prenatal diagnosis of organic acid dis-
orders in amniotic fluid, if the causative mutations are not avail-
able, providing more rapid diagnosis than enzyme analysis of 
cultured amniocytes.
Acylcarnitine analysis
A complementary and rapid diagnostic technique for some or-
ganic acid disorders is the analysis of acylcarnitine by MS/​
MS—​by analogy to newborn mass screening—​since accumu-
lating acyl-​CoA esters are in equilibrium with corresponding 
acylcarnitines.
Principles of treatment
General aspects
Protein-​dependent metabolic disorders are chronic conditions that 
involve various organ systems and thus require a multidisciplinary 
approach to care and treatment. Patients with genetic diseases that 
are prone to acute decompensations should carry an emergency card. 
Vaccinations should be carried out as recommended and should also 
include vaccinations against varicella, hepatitis A, pneumococcus, 
and influenza. Special precautions must be taken before, during, and 
after surgery/​anaesthesia.
Dietary treatment
In many protein-​dependent errors of metabolism, therapy is based 
on reduced intake of precursors in deficient pathways, prevention 
of catabolism, and an intensification of therapy during intercurrent 
illnesses. This aims to diminish the supply of toxic metabolites and 
restore energy supply. Dietary treatment must meet the general, age-​
dependent, and individual requirements for energy and essential 
nutrients to ensure normal growth and development (Table 12.2.1). 
Protein deficiency induces catabolism, failure to thrive, and growth 
retardation, and secondary depletion of essential amino acids and 
micronutrients may induce life-​threatening complications such as 
lactic acidosis (thiamine or biotin depletion) or pellagra (niacin 
depletion). Supplementation of precursor-​free mixtures of amino 
acids and semisynthetic supplements of minerals and trace elements 
minimizes the risk for malnutrition.
Pharmacotherapy
Carnitine at daily doses of 50–​200 mg/​kg body weight is essential for 
the elimination of accumulating toxic acyl-​CoA compounds and for 
the restoration of intramitochondrial free CoA-​SH in most organic 
acid disorders. In cofactor-​responsive disorders, enzyme activity 
may be restored by specific vitamins, for example, in biotinidase 
deficiency, cobalamin-​responsive methylmalonic acidurias, and 
riboflavin-​responsive multiple acyl-​CoA dehydrogenase deficiency. 
Box 12.2.3  Some pitfalls of amino acid analysis
	•	 Shipping/​storage without adequate cooling: ↓ glutamine, asparagine, 
cysteine, homocysteine; ↑ glutamate, aspartate
	•	 Haemolysis:  ↓ arginine, glutamine; ↑ aspartate, glutamate, glycine, 
ornithine
	•	 Postprandial changes: all amino acids
Table 12.2.1  Protein requirements
Age
Revised safe values (g/​kg per day)
0–​1 months
2.69
1–​2 months
2.04
2–​3 months
1.53
3–​4 months
1.37
4–​5 months
1.25
5–​6 months
1.19
6–​9 months
1.09
9–​12 months
1.02
1–​3 years
1.0–​0.92
4–​10 years
0.88–​0.86
11–​18 years
0.86–​0.77
Source data from Dewey KG, et al. (1996). Protein requirements of infants and children. 
Eur J Clin Nutr, 50 Suppl 1, S119–​47.


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1947
The accumulation of toxic metabolites derived from gut bacteria, 
such as propionic acid, can be reduced by intestinal antibiotics 
(e.g. metronidazole).
Emergency treatment
Treatment of intercurrent illness at home
Protein-​dependent inborn errors of metabolism often present with 
acute life-​threatening decompensation requiring prompt decisions 
and measures. A limited number of therapeutic measures have to be 
taken immediately (Box 12.2.4, Table 12.2.2).
It is imperative to decrease catabolism at an early stage of de-
compensation. As this usually happens at home, it is essential 
to educate the family adequately. Home treatment should in-
clude adequate control of fever and vomiting, moderate protein 
restriction, and ample calories, glucose, and fluid (Box 12.2.4). 
Intake of natural protein can be completely eliminated for the 
first 24 h of illness, especially if the patient receives precursor-​
free supplements of amino acids. After 24 h, stepwise reintroduc-
tion of natural protein is necessary to prevent protein catabolism. 
Immediate hospital admission and intravenous treatment is in-
dicated when vomiting persists, fluid and dextrose intake remain 
poor, the clinical condition deteriorates, or the disease course is 
prolonged. On admission to hospital, these patients must be as-
sessed and treated without delay. If emergency management is 
carried out in peripheral hospitals, this should ideally be super-
vised in consultation with a knowledgeable and experienced 
physician or paediatrician.
Emergency treatment in hospital
Provision of ample quantities and control of fluid and electrolytes is 
indispensable and must be continued before any laboratory results 
are available. Glucose infusions must be adapted to age to provide an 
adequate energy supply. For example, in neonates glucose infusion 
is usually started at 10 mg/​kg per min (i.e. 14.4 g glucose/​kg body 
weight per day). An insulin drip may be necessary to prevent hyper-
glycaemia and to induce an anabolic state. Overhydration is rarely 
a problem in metabolic crises as they are mostly accompanied by 
dehydration. Electrolytes, glucose, lactate, and acid–​base balance 
should be checked at least every 6 h and serum sodium should be 
maintained at no less than 138 mmol/​litre. If lactate is constantly 
increasing while the glucose supply is increasing, one should con-
sider a primary defect or secondary inhibition or energy metab-
olism, such as in classic organic acid disorders. Antibiotics should 
be started if there is evidence for an infectious cause. Antipyretics 
should be administered liberally since they help to reduce the add-
itional bioenergetic costs of fever.
Carnitine is essential for the elimination of toxic acyl-​CoA es-
ters in organic acidaemias, to prevent secondary carnitine deple-
tion, and to replenish the intracellular CoA pool. Carnitine should 
be administered intravenously at 100 to 200 mg/​kg per day. In 
hyperammonaemia, nitrogen-​disposing drugs are used:
	•	Sodium benzoate, 250 mg/​kg as bolus initially over 1 to 2 h, then 
250 (to 500) mg/​kg per 24 h.
Box 12.2.4  Basic principles for acute emergency therapy
	1	 Suppress muscle and liver protein catabolism and ensure a glucose 
supply above the basal metabolic demand
	2	 Treat the precipitating illness
	3	 Reduce increased production of toxic metabolites by reduction or 
omission of natural protein
	4	 Enhance detoxifying mechanisms and urinary excretion of patho-
logical metabolites
	5	 Aggressively treat dehydration and acidosis
	6	 Prevent secondary carnitine depletion
	7	 Provide alternative routes of ammonia disposal in hyperammonaemia
Table 12.2.2  Home and outpatient emergency treatment
Age (years)
%
kcal/​100 ml
Daily amount
A. Glucose polymer/​maltodextrin solutiona
0–​1
10
  40
150–​200 ml/​kg
1–​2
15
  60
95 ml/​kg
2–​10
20
  80
1200–​2000 ml/​day
>10
25
100
2000 ml/​day
B. Protein intake
Natural protein
Stop (if amino acid supplements are administered) or reduce to 50% of maintenance therapy (if no amino acid supplements are 
administered). Reintroduce and increase within 1–​2 days
Amino acid mixtures
If tolerated, amino acid supplements should be administered according to maintenance therapy, e.g. 0.8–​1.0 g/​kg body weight/​dayb
C. Pharmacotherapy
l-​Carnitine
Double carnitine intake: 200 mg/​kg body weight/​day orally (if tolerated)
Antipyreticsc
If temperature >38.5°C, e.g. ibuprofen (10–​15 mg/​kg body weight per dose, 3–​4 doses daily)
a Maltodextran/​dextrose solutions should be administered every 2 h day and night. If neonates and infants already receive a specific dietary treatment, protein-​free food can be 
continued but should be fortified by maltodextran. Patients should be reassessed every 2 h.
b All calculations should be based on the expected weight, not the actual weight.
c Paracetamol administration may be dangerous in acute metabolic decompensation (risk for glutathione depletion).


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1948
	•	Sodium phenylacetate, 250 mg/​kg as bolus initially over 1 to 
2 h, then 250 (to 600)  mg/​kg per 24 h; alternatively, sodium 
phenylbutyrate is administered at the same concentration orally.
	•	Arginine hydrochloride, 420 mg/​kg (i.e. 2 mmol/​kg) as bolus ini-
tially over 1 to 2 h, then 420 mg/​kg per 24 h.
If the response to emergency treatment is poor, the patient de-
teriorates, or the ammonia concentration exceeds 400 to 500 µmol/​
litre (neonate, infant), haemofiltration or haemodialysis should be 
urgently considered. Since intracranial pressure due to cerebral oe-
dema appears earlier in older children, adolescents, and adults than 
in newborns, infants, and younger children, extracorporeal detoxi-
fication should be considered if ammonia concentration exceeds 
200 µmol/​litre or even as first-​line treatment. If persisting lactic acid-
osis is present, thiamine (100–​500 mg/​day) and biotin (10–​20 mg) 
should be given empirically.
Monitoring of treatment
Dietary treatment without adequate monitoring is dangerous since 
disease-​specific complications, therapy-​specific adverse events (e.g. 
malnutrition), and developmental delay might be overlooked.
Anthropometric parameters such as weight, height, and head cir-
cumference should be recorded at each visit. Psychomotor devel-
opment must be regularly assessed with appropriate tests. Weight 
loss or insufficient weight gain in affected children is often caused by 
inadequate dietary treatment and may herald impending metabolic 
decompensation.
The major aim of biochemical monitoring is to ensure that nu-
trition is not compromised. Biochemical evaluation includes blood 
count, serum electrolytes, calcium, phosphate, magnesium, ferritin 
level, liver and kidney function tests, alkaline phosphatase, total 
protein, albumin, prealbumin, transferrin, cholesterol, triglycer-
ides, zinc, copper, retinol (plasma), carnitine, ammonia, lactate, 
and plasma amino acids. Although analyses of specific metabolic 
parameters are required to confirm the diagnosis of an inborn error 
of metabolism, these parameters are often not informative for bio-
chemical follow-​up monitoring since the relationship between the 
metabolic parameters and outcome is unclear for most disorders. 
However, regular monitoring of some metabolic parameters is ne-
cessary since they are directly related to the outcome. For example, 
plasma phenylalanine is monitored in PKU, plasma leucine in 
maple sugar urine disease, plasma glutamine and arginine in urea 
cycle defects, and plasma homocysteine in trans-​sulphuration and 
remethylation defects.
Likely future developments
The scientific and technological advances described in the previous 
sections have offered much benefit to patients with inborn errors 
of metabolism. To implement and utilize them properly, much 
remains to be done. Initially, metabolic physicians and scientists 
need to combine their efforts and concentrate on well-​conducted 
international studies and development of evidence-​based guide-
lines. Significant differences still exist in the diagnostic procedures, 
treatment, and monitoring of many diseases, resulting in a wide 
variation in outcome. Even for PKU, the disease with the greatest 
and longest experience in successful therapy, current guidelines 
recommend different cut-​offs for the indication of treatment ran-
ging from 400 µmol/​litre in the United Kingdom to 360  µmol/​litre 
in the United States of America and 600 µmol/​litre in France and 
Germany. The knowledge of the academic community must be 
combined and structured, transferred to the physicians and other 
medical staff, and implemented in healthcare systems. Nowadays, 
this process has become much easier by means of numerous re-
commendations, information, and even projects available on the 
Internet, permanent professional email round tables, Internet 
editions of book and journals, and open-​access databases. In the 
necessary implementation process, regional differences such as 
availability of funds, local pathology, and religious and geographic 
factors must be taken into account. Accordingly, specialized na-
tional metabolic centres and appropriate metabolic networks 
should be established and properly maintained. Unfortunately, 
novel diagnostic and therapeutic possibilities (Box 12.2.5), such as 
newborn screening or enzyme replacement therapy, are relatively 
expensive and are still unrealistic for many countries where there 
are no screening programmes and perhaps no well-​organized 
healthcare system.
Individual disorders
A summary of protein-​dependent inborn errors of metabolism 
including the enzyme defect, incidence, gene locus, and 
Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man (OMIM) number is given 
in Table 12.2.3.
Urea cycle defects
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
The major source of ammonia is catabolism of protein, which is 
detoxified to urea in the liver (Fig. 12.2.1). The efficiency of hep-
atic ammonia detoxification is enhanced through the action of glu-
tamine synthase. Hyperammonaemia (plasma ammonia >80 µmol/​
litre in newborns; >50 µmol/​litre after the newborn period) is caused 
by increased production (e.g. by intestinal urease-​producing bac-
teria) or decreased detoxification of ammonia. Decreased detoxifi-
cation results from inherited or acquired deficiency of key enzymes 
and transporters of the urea cycle, or bypassing of the liver (e.g. open 
hepatic duct). Secondary impairment of ammonia detoxification re-
sults from conditions where glutamate or acetyl-​CoA are decreased, 
Box 12.2.5  New treatment strategies in inborn errors 
of metabolism
	•	 Supplementation with end products
	•	 Anaplerotic therapy
	•	 Enzyme replacement
	•	 Chemical chaperones
	•	 Specific blockade of biosynthetic pathways
	•	 Specific blockade of degradation pathways
	•	 Specific blockade of pathophysiological signalling
	•	 (Stem) cell therapy
	•	 Gene therapy


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1949
Table 12.2.3  Summary of protein-​dependent inborn errors of metabolism
Disease
Enzyme defect
Incidencea
Gene map locus
Gene name
OMIM (phenotype 
number)
Defects of the urea cycle
Argininaemia
Arginase 1
1:100 000
6q23
ARG1
207800
Argininosuccinic aciduria
Argininosuccinate lyase
1:50 000
7cen–​q11.2
ASS1
207900
Citrullinaemia type I
Argininosuccinate synthetase 1
1:50 000
9q34
ASL
215700
Deficiency of
Citrin
<1:200 000
7q21.3
SLC25A13
605814 (neonatal onset)
603471 (adult onset)
Deficiency of
N-​Acetylglutamate synthase
<1:200 000
17q21.3
NAGS
237310
Deficiency of
Carbamoylphosphate synthetase 1
1:50 000
2q35
CPS1
237300
Deficiency of
Ornithine carbamoyltransferase
1:30 000
Xp21.1
OTC
311250
Dibasic amino aciduria II, lysinuric protein 
intolerance
<1:200 000
14q11.2
SLC7A7
222700
Hyperornithinaemia–​hyperammonaemia–​
homocitrullinuria syndrome
Ornithine transporter
<1:200 000
13q14
SLC25A15
238970
Carbonic anhydrase VA deficiency
Mitochondrial carbonic anhydrase VA
Unknown
16q24.2
CA5A
114761
Defects of branched-​chain amino acid metabolism
Isovaleric aciduria
Isovaleryl-​CoA dehydrogenase
1:80 000
15q14–​q15
IVD
243500
Maple syrup urine disease
Branched-​chain keto acid dehydrogenase 
(lipoamide)
1:200 000
248600
  Type Ia E1 component α-​chain
19q13.1–​q13.2
BCKDHA
  Type Ib component β-​chain
6p21–​p22
BCKDHB
  Type II dihydrolipoamide branched-​chain  
  transacylase (E2 component)
1p31
DBT
3-​Methylcrotonylglycinuria
3-​Methylcrotonyl-​CoA carboxylase
1:60 000
210200
  α-​subunit
3q25–​q27
MCCC1
  β-​subunit
5q12–​q13
MCCC2
3-​Methylglutaconyl-​CoA hydratase deficiency  
(3-​methylcrotonyl aciduria type I)
3-​Methylglutaconyl-​CoA hydratase
<1:200 000
9q22.31
AUH
250950
TAZ defect or Barth syndrome (3-​methylglutaconic 
aciduria type II)
Tafazzin
<1:200 000
Xq28
TAZ
302060
OPA3 defect or Costeff’s syndrome  
(3-​methylglutaconic aciduria type III)
OPA3A and OPAB protein
<1:200 000
19q13.2–​q13.3
OPA3
258501
3-​Methylglutaconic aciduria type IV (i.e. MEGDEL 
syndrome, TMEM70 defect, or not otherwise 
specified)
E.g. polymerase-​γ, transmembrane protein 
70, succinate-​CoA ligase, serine active site-​
containing protein 1 or not yet classified
<1:200 000
e.g. 15q26.1, 8q21.11, 
13q14.2, 6q25.3, or ?
e.g. POLG1, TMEM70, 
SUCLA2, SERAC1, or?
250951 (if not otherwise 
specified)
DNAJ19 defect or DCMA syndrome  
(3-​methylglutaconic aciduria type V)
Translocase of the inner mitochondrial 
membrane 14
Unknown
3q26.33
DNAJC19
610198
(continued)


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1950
Disease
Enzyme defect
Incidencea
Gene map locus
Gene name
OMIM (phenotype 
number)
2-​Methyl-​3-​hydroxybutyryl-​CoA deficiency
2-​Methyl-​3-​hydroxybutyryl-​CoA dehydrogenase
<1:200 000
Xp11.2
HSD17B10
300438
Methylmalonic aciduria (mut0/​mut− defects)
Methylmalonyl-​CoA mutase
1:100 000
6p12.3
MUT
251000
Propionic aciduria
Propionyl-​CoA carboxylase
1:200 000
  α-​chain
13q32
PCCA
232000
  β-​chain
3q21–​q22
PCCB
232050
3-​Hydroxyisobutyryl-​CoA hydrolase deficiency
3-​Hydroxyisobutyryl-​CoA hydrolase
Unknown
2q32.2
HIBCH
250620
Short-​chain enoyl-​CoA hydratase deficiency
Mitochondrial short-​chain enoyl-​CoA hydratase 1
Unknown
10q26.3
ECHS1
616277
Defects of lysine, hydroxylysine, and tryptophan metabolism
2-​Aminoadipic and oxoadipic aciduria
Dehydrogenase E1 and transketolase domains-​
containing protein 1
<1:200 000
10p14
DHTKD1
204750
2-​Oxoadipic aciduria
Dehydrogenase E1 and transketolase domains-​
containing protein 1
<1:200 000
10p14
DHTKD1
245130
Glutaric aciduria type I
Glutaryl-​CoA dehydrogenase
1:100 000
19p13.2
GCDH
231670
Gyrate atrophy of choroid and retina
Ornithine-​oxoacid/​ ornithine aminotransferase
<1:200 000
10q26
OAT
258870
Hyperlysinaemia
Saccharopine dehydrogenase/​lysine:α-​
ketoglutarate reductase
<1:200 000
7q31.32
AASS
238700
Saccharopinuria
Saccharopine dehydrogenase/​lysine:α-​
ketoglutarate reductase
<1:200 000
7q31.32
AASS
268700
Multiple carboxylase deficiency
Biotinidase deficiency
Biotinidase
1:80 000
3p25
BTD
253260
Holocarboxylase synthetase deficiency
Holocarboxylase synthetase
<1:200 000
21q22.1
HLCS
253270
Other organic acidurias
N-​Acetylaspartic aciduria (Canavan’s disease)
Aspartoacylase; aminoacylase 2
<1:200 000
17pter–​p13
ASPA
271900
Ethylmalonic encephalopathy
Mitochondrial matrix protein
<1:200 000
19q13.2
ETHE1
602473
D-​2-​Hydroxyglutaric aciduria
Type I: D-​2-​hydroxyglutaric acid dehydrogenase
<1:200 000
2p25.3
D2HGDH
600721
Type II: isocitrate dehydrogenase 2 
(mitochondrial)
<1:200 000
15q26.1
IDH2
613657
L-​2-​Hydroxyglutaric aciduria
FAD-​dependent L-​2-​hydroxyglutarate 
dehydrogenase
<1:200 000
14q22.1
L2HGDH
236792
Combined D-​2-​ and L-​2-​hydroxyglutaric aciduria
Mitochondrial citrate transporter
<1:200 000
22q11.21
SLC25A1
615182
Defects of phenylalanine and tyrosine metabolism
Alkaptonuria
Homogentisate 1,2-​dioxygenase
<1:200 000
3q21–​q23
HGD
203500
BH4 deficiency, dopa-​responsive dystonia 
(dominant)
Guanosine-​5-​triphosphate cyclohydrolase
1:100 000
14q22.1–​q22.2
GCH1
128230
Table 12.2.3  Continued


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1951
BH4 deficiency
Deficiency of
Dihydropteridine reductase
<1:200 000
4p15.32
QHPR
261630
Deficiency of
Guanosine-​5-​triphosphate cyclohydrolase
<1:200 000
14q22.1–​q22.2
GCH
233910
Deficiency of
6-​Pyruvoyltetrahydropterin synthase
<1:200 000
11q22.3–​q23.3
PTS
261640
Deficiency of
Sepiapterin reductase
<1:200 000
2p13.2
SPR
612716
Deficiency of
Pterin-​4α-​carbaminoline dehydratase
Unknown
10q22.1
PCBD1
264070
Phenylketonuria (PKU)
Phenylalanine hydroxylase
1:10 000
12q24.1
PAH
261600
  Type I
(Classical PKU = Phe >1200 µmol/​litre) c.50%
  Type II
(Mild PKU = 360–​600 µmol/​litre ≤ Phe ≤ 
1200 µmol/​litre) c.30%
  Type III
(Non-​PKU HPA/​MHP = Phe <360–​600 µmol/​
litre) c.20%
  Types II+III
(BH4-​PAH = Phe <1200 µmol/​litre + BH4-​
responsive) c.35%
Hyperphenylalaninaemia with primapterinuria
Pterin-​4α-​carbinolamine
<1:200 000
10q22.1
PCBD
264070
Tyrosinaemia type I
Fumarylacetoacetase
1:100 000
15q23.1
FAH
276700
Tyrosinaemia type II
Tyrosine aminotransferase
<1:200 000
16q22.2
TAT
276600
Tyrosinaemia type III
4-​Hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase
<1:200 000
12q24.31
HPD
276710
Neurotransmitter diseases and related disorders
Deficiency of
Aromatic L-​amino acid decarboxylase
<1:200 000
7p12.1
DDC
608643
Deficiency of
Dopamine β-​hydroxylase
<1:200 000
9q34.2
DBH
223360
Deficiency of
GABA transaminase
<1:200 000
16p13.2
ABAT
613163
Deficiency of
3-​Phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase
<1:200 000
1p12
PHGDH
601815
Deficiency of
Tyrosine hydroxylase
<1:200 000
11p15.5
TH
605407
Folinic acid-​responsive epilepsy (see ‘Pyridoxine-​
dependent epilepsy’)
α-​Aminoadipic semialdehyde dehydrogenase 
(antiquitin)
<1:200 000
5q23.2
ALDH7A1
266100
4-​Hydroxybutyric aciduria
Succinic semialdehyde dehydrogenase
<1:200 000
6p22.3
ALDH5A1
271980
Hyperprolinaemia type II
L-​Δ1-​pyrroline-​5-​carboxylate dehydrogenase
<1:200 000
1p36
ALDH4A1
239510
Nonketotic hyperglycinaemia (glycine 
encephalopathy)
1:60 000
605899
H-​protein deficiency
16q22.24
GCSH
P-​protein deficiency
9p24.1
GLDC
T-​protein deficiency
3p21.31
AMT
Other: transient
605899
Pyridoxal phosphate-​dependent epilepsy
Pyridox(am)ine 5′-​phosphate oxidase
<1:200 000
17q21.32
PNPO
610090
Pyridoxine-​dependent epilepsy
α-​Aminoadipic semialdehyde dehydrogenase 
(antiquitin)
<1:200 000
5q23.2
ALDH7A1
266100
(continued)


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1952
Disease
Enzyme defect
Incidencea
Gene map locus
Gene name
OMIM (phenotype 
number)
Defects of trans-​sulphuration and remethylation
Deficiency of
S-​adenosyl-​homocysteine hydrolase
<1:200 000
20q11.22
AHCY
613752
Deficiency of
Adenosine kinase
<1:200 000
10q22.2
ADK
614300
Deficiency of
Cysthationine γ-​lyase
< 1:70 000
1p31.1
CTH
219500
Deficiency of
Glycine N-​methyltransferase
<1:200 000
6p21.1
GNMT
606664
Deficiency of
Methionine adenosyltransferase 1
<1:200 000
10q23.1
MAT1A
250850
Deficiency of
Methionine synthase reductase (cobalamin E)
<1:200 000
5p15.31
MTRR
236270
Deficiency of
Methionine synthase (cobalamin G)
<1:200 000
1q43
MTR
250940
Deficiency of
5,10-​Methylene-​tetrahydrofolatreductase
<1:200 000
1p36.22
MTHFR
236250
Homocystinuria
Cystathionine-​β-​synthase
1:100 000
21q22.3
CBS
236200
a Incidences as estimated in the white population; they vary between populations of different ethnic background. <1:200 000 indicates incidence very low but uncertain because not specifically determined. Of some disorders, only two or 
three families are as yet known worldwide.
BH4-​PAH, BH4-​responsive phenylalanine hydroxylase deficiency; Phe, phenylalanine; PKU, phenylketonuria.
Table 12.2.3  Continued


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1953
such as in organic acid defects, mitochondrial β-​oxidation de-
fects, carnitine depletion, or valproate therapy, or where toxic 
acyl-​CoAs are increased, such as propionyl-​CoA in propionic and 
methylmalonic aciduria or isovaleryl-​CoA in isovaleric aciduria.
Hyperammonaemia is neurotoxic, resulting in brain oedema, 
convulsions, and coma. Neuropathological evaluation reveals an 
alteration of astrocyte morphology including cell swelling (acute 
hyperammonaemia) and Alzheimer type II astrocytosis (chronic 
hyperammonaemia). The brain relies on energy-​dependent glu-
tamine synthesis by astrocytic glutamine synthetase for the removal 
of excess ammonia. As a consequence, increased brain ammonia is 
considered to amplify glutamatergic signalling and cause redistri-
bution of cerebral blood flow and metabolism, impairment of brain 
energy metabolism affecting the glutamate/​glutamine cycle, and in-
creased serotonin secretion. Hyperammonaemia exerts reversible 
(mostly serotoninergic) and irreversible effects. Peak plasma am-
monia concentrations exceeding 500 µmol/​litre or a coma lasting 
more than 2 to 3 days appears to be associated with irreversible de-
fects which worsen with the duration of the coma. All inherited urea 
cycle defects follow an autosomal recessive trait except for ornithine 
transcarbamylase deficiency which is X-​linked.
Clinical presentation
Urea cycle defects are among the most common inborn errors of 
metabolism (cumulative incidence is approximately 1 in 40 000 
newborns). Six inherited urea cycle defects are well described, 
that is, deficiencies of N-​acetylglutamate synthetase, carbamoyl-​
phosphate synthase 1, ornithine transcarbamylase, argininosuccinate 
synthetase and lyase, and arginase 1 (Fig. 12.2.1). Deficiency of glu-
tamine synthetase has also been identified but is not described here. 
Five urea cycle defects share a common but variable clinical presen-
tation due to hyperammonaemia. Arginase 1 deficiency and defects 
of cellular transport including transporter proteins for the dibasic 
amino acids ornithine (hyperornithinaemia–​hyperammonaemia–​
homocitrullinuria syndrome) and aspartate (citrullinaemia II) 
result in a more subtle disease with predominantly neurological 
symptoms.
Onset of symptoms may occur at any age; however, it is par-
ticularly frequent during the neonatal period, late infancy, and 
puberty, and is precipitated by excess protein or episodes that in-
duce catabolism such as infectious diseases, trauma, or cortisone 
therapy. In general, symptoms are less severe with increasing age 
at onset. Neonatal presentation starts after a short asymptomatic 
interval with poor feeding, vomiting, lethargy, tachypnoea, and/​or 
irritability which cannot be distinguished clinically from neonatal 
sepsis. Untreated, acute encephalopathy rapidly progresses to death. 
In infancy, the symptoms are less acute and more variable than in the 
neonatal period including anorexia, vomiting, developmental delay, 
and behavioural problems. In X-​linked ornithine transcarbamylase 
deficiency, female carriers may also be affected due to variable in-
activation of the X chromosome (the Lyon hypothesis). Clinical 
presentation ranges from acute liver failure, cognitive disability, 
and behavioural problems to psychiatric disease. In arginase 1 defi-
ciency, patients usually present with progressive spasticity which is 
often mistaken for cerebral palsy, seizures, and learning difficulties. 
Dystonia and ataxia may develop. Acute decompensation occurs 
rarely. The phenotypic variation of patients with urea cycle disorders 
as well as evidence-​based recommendations for diagnosis, treat-
ment, and follow-​up have recently been reported by an international 
consortium of experts.
Diagnosis
Emergency analysis of ammonia must be part of the basic investiga-
tions in all patients at all ages with unclear encephalopathy or acute 
hepatic failure.
Among the inherited hyperammonaemias, two-​thirds are due to 
urea cycle defects and one-​third to organic acid and other inborn 
errors. Blood gas analyses and anion gap determinations may show 
alkalosis and normal anion gap in urea cycle defects and acidosis 
and increased anion gap in organic acid disorders. Characteristic 
biochemical changes (glutamine, alanine, citrulline, ornithine, ar-
ginine, argininosuccinic acid, orotic acid, uracil) can be identified 
by plasma amino acid analysis, GC/​MS analysis of urinary organic 
acids, or HPLC analysis of orotic acids and orotidine. The diagnosis 
can be confirmed by enzyme analysis in liver tissue (all urea cycle 
defects except for N-​acetylglutamate synthase deficiency), fibro-
blasts (argininosuccinate synthase 1 and lyase), or molecular genetic 
studies. Prenatal diagnosis is possible. Autosomal recessive inherited 
urea cycle disorders can be identified by molecular genetic studies 
on chorionic villus biopsy. Enzyme analysis can be performed for 
deficiencies of argininosuccinate lyase and synthase. Arginase defi-
ciency can also be diagnosed biochemically by fetal blood analysis.
Therapy and outcome
The aim of treatment is to correct the biochemical disorder (glutamine 
in plasma <800–​1000 µmol/​litre, ammonia <80 µmol/​litre, arginine 
80–​150 µmol/​litre) and to ensure that the patient grows normally and 
thrives. The major metabolic strategies are (1) reduction of natural 
protein to decrease ammonia production, (2) supplementation with 
essential amino acids to prevent malnutrition and to reutilize ni-
trogen for the synthesis of nonessential amino acids, (3) replacement 
of arginine or citrulline which become essential amino acids in all 
urea cycle disorders except for arginase 1 deficiency, and (4) utiliza-
tion of alternative pathways for nitrogen excretion. This last strategy 
­includes application of sodium benzoate (250–​500 mg/​kg per day) and 
Fumarate
Mitochondrion
= Ornithine transporter
Cytosol
Ammonia
HCO3−
CPS1
Carbamyl
phosphate
Orotic acid
Orotidine
Uracil
Glutamate
N-acetylglutamate
NAGS
Citrulline
Aspartate
Argininosuccinate
Arginine
Urea
Cycle
Ornithine
OTC
ASS
ASL
Arginase 1
Urea
T
T
⊕
Fig. 12.2.1  The urea cycle. ASL, argininosuccinate lyase; ASS, 
argininosuccinate synthase; CPS1, carbamyl phosphate synthase 1; 
NAGS, N-​acetylglutamate synthase; OTC, ornithine transcarbamylase; T, 
ornithine transporter.
Source data from Zschocke J, Hoffmann GF (2011). Vademecum metabolicum. 
Manual of metabolic paediatrics, 3rd edition. Schattauer, Stuttgart.


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1954
sodium phenylbutyrate or phenylacetate (250–​600 mg/​kg per day) 
to conjugate glycine or glutamine, resulting in urinary excretion 
of waste nitrogen in alternative compounds (hippurate, phenyl­
acetylglutamine). In N-​acetylglutamate synthase ­deficiency, N-​
carbamylglutamate can be used as an alternative allosteric activator 
of carbamoyl ​phosphate synthase.
All patients with urea cycle defects are at risk of acute metabolic 
decompensation precipitated by metabolic stress such as protein 
load, infection, anaesthesia, or surgery. To prevent or reverse meta-
bolic crises, a stepwise implementation of an intensified emergency 
treatment is required (see also ‘Emergency treatment’). If diet and 
pharmacotherapy is insufficient to improve hyperammonaemia sig-
nificantly and rapidly, haemofiltration or haemodialysis should be 
considered.
Main factors that determine outcome are duration and severity 
of hyperammonaemia the specific disease, and age at disease onset 
are considered as most important. In general, a beneficial outcome 
critically relies on rapid diagnosis and immediate start of treatment 
after the onset of first symptoms.
Carbonic anhydrase VA deficiency
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
Bicarbonate cannot enter the mitochondria and thus is generated 
within the mitochondria by two carbonic anhydrases:  VA and 
VB. Carbonic anhydrase VA provides bicarbonate as a substrate 
to carbamyl phosphate synthase 1, the first enzymatic step of the 
urea cycle, as well as to three mitochondrial carboxylases, pyruvate 
carboxylase, propionyl-​CoA carboxylase, and 3-​methylcrotonyl-​
CoA carboxylase which are involved in energy metabolism and the 
catabolic pathways of branched-​chain amino acids, respectively. 
Combined dysfunction of these four mitochondrial enzymes due to 
limited availability of their substrate bicarbonate causes a biochem-
ical derangement including hyperammonaemia, impaired energy 
metabolism (affecting gluconeogenesis and tricarboxylic cycle) with 
lactic acidosis, as well as organic acidurias resembling propionic 
aciduria and 3-​methylcrotonyl-​CoA carboxylase deficiency (see 
‘3-​Methylcrotonylglycinuria’).
Presentation
Recently, four patients with this disease have been reported. Three 
of them presented with lethargy, tachypnoea, hypoglycaemia, 
hyperammonaemia, hyperlactatemia with hyperalaninaemia, and 
respiratory alkalosis during the first days of life; in one of them, the 
initial metabolic crisis occurred at age 13 months. During the follow-​
up, episodes of acute encephalopathy were precipitated by catabolic 
stress. Motor and mental development was within the normal range 
in one child, whereas delayed motor development due to ataxia and 
mild axial hypotonia, psychomotor retardation, or learning difficul-
ties was found in the other children.
Diagnosis
Metabolic tests reveal a unique pattern of elevated lactate and 
hyperammonaemia with elevated glutamine and alanine, but low 
citrulline and arginine in plasma in combination with increased 
urinary excretion of lactate, ketone bodies, propionate metabolites, 
methylcrotonylglycine, and 3-​hydroxyisovaleric acid. The meta-
bolic pattern can be identified by analysis of plasma amino acids 
and organic acids in urine. Notably, newborn screening profiles, 
specifically C3 and C5OH levels, were unremarkable in all index pa-
tients. The diagnosis can be confirmed by molecular genetic testing. 
Carbamyl phosphate synthase 1 and N-​acetylglutamate synthase de-
ficiency are the most relevant differential diagnosis. In children with 
negative molecular genetic test results in CPS1 and NAGS genes, car-
bonic anhydrase VA deficiency should be considered.
Treatment and outcome
Treatment with preventive sick-​day management using high-​caloric, 
lipid-​rich and low-​protein formula to enhance anabolism and to re-
duce the formation of toxic metabolites as well as carglumic acid to 
enhance the activity of carbamyl phosphate synthase 1 can be ad-
ministered. Although carbonic anhydrase VA deficiency should be 
considered as treatable condition, treatment strategies have not yet 
been studied systematically. The long-​term outcome of this disease 
is unknown.
Defects of branched-​chain amino acid metabolism
Maple syrup urine disease
Maple syrup urine disease was first reported in 1954 by Menkes, 
Hurst, and Craig, who noticed an unusual odour reminiscent of 
maple syrup in the urines of four infants who died from a rapidly pro-
gressive neurological disease. In newborn screening programmes, a 
prevalence of approximately 1 in 200 000 newborns is encountered 
but in the Mennonites in Pennsylvania, the prevalence is as high as 1 
in 200. Maple syrup urine disease is frequent in other ethnic groups 
and isolates such as persons of French Canadian origin.
In maple syrup urine disease, the branched-​chain amino 
acids leucine, isoleucine, and valine, their corresponding α-​keto 
acids and hydroxy acid derivatives, as well as l-​alloisoleucine 
are increased in physiological fluids. These amino acids and 
their metabolites accumulate due to inherited deficiency of the 
thiamine-​dependent branched-​chain α-​keto acid dehydrogenase 
complex, consisting of subunits E1α, β, E2, and E3 (Fig. 12.2.2). 
l-​Alloisoleucine results from racemization of the 3-​carbon of 
l-​isoleucine during transamination. Its elevation is pathogno-
monic for maple syrup urine disease.
Presentation
Several clinical presentations have been delineated but there is con-
siderable overlap. Most frequently the condition comes to light in 
the first few days of life with lethargy, irritability, poor feeding, and 
neurological deterioration. Later-​onset forms of maple syrup urine 
disease are slower with failure to thrive, developmental delay, and 
sometimes seizures; episodic ataxia and stupor sometimes pro-
gressing to coma may be precipitated by high protein intake or 
intercurrent illness. In patients showing a response to thiamine, the 
condition tends to resemble later-​onset maple syrup urine disease. 
A very rare related disease results from deficiency of lipoamide de-
hydrogenase presenting after the neonatal period with lactic acid-
osis, hypotonia, developmental delay, abnormal movement, and 
progressive neurological deterioration.
Most patients with maple syrup urine disease have the classic 
form. If untreated, these neonates quickly deteriorate, developing 
lethargy, hypotonia alternating with muscular rigidity, opisthotonic 
posturing, and seizures (Fig. 12.2.3). Despite giving its name to 


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1955
the disease, the characteristic odour may be absent. Neuroimaging 
shows localized or diffuse generalized cerebral oedema. Convulsions 
appear regularly and electroencephalography reveals abnormalities 
with comb-​like rhythms (5–​9 Hz) of spindle-​like sharp waves over 
the central regions and multiple shifting spikes and sharp waves with 
suppression bursts. Untreated patients succumb within a few days. 
Prominent neuropathological signs of untreated maple syrup urine 
disease are cerebral atrophy, including neuron loss in pontine nu-
clei and the thalamus and myelin deficiency; spongy degeneration 
and astrocytic hyperplasia occur. Hypodensities may be present in 
globus pallidus and thalamus. In a few patients, mostly with inter-
mittent or intermediate variants, the metabolic defect can be cor-
rected by thiamine (‘thiamine-​responsive’ variant). Effective doses 
vary from 10 mg up to 300 mg per day.
Diagnosis
Maple syrup urine disease is strongly suggested when an odour of 
maple syrup is present (most noticeably in the ear wax). Immediate 
confirmation by positive 2,4-​dinitrophenylhydrazine testing is suf-
ficient justification to initiate treatment in families at high risk. 
Diagnosis is confirmed by detection of increased plasma con-
centrations of leucine, isoleucine, and valine and/​or by increased 
urinary excretion of α-​keto and hydroxy acids. The detection of 
l-​alloisoleucine is diagnostic. Reduced enzyme activity of the 
branched-​chain α-​keto acid dehydrogenase complex in leuco-
cytes, lymphoblasts, cultured fibroblasts, or amniocytes confirms 
the diagnosis. Except for the common Mennonite mutation, the 
2-Oxoisocaproate 
2-OH-isocaproate
3-OH-isovalerate
3-Methylcrotonyl-
glycine
3-OH-isovalerate
Isovalerylglycine
Isoleucine
2-Oxo-
3-methylvalerate
2-Methylbutyryl-CoA
Tiglyl-CoA
Aminotransferase
BCKDH
MBD
Hydratase
Valine
2-Oxo-
isovalerate
Isobutyryl-CoA
Methylacrylyl-CoA
Aminotransferase
BCKDH
Hydratase
Leucine
2-Oxo-
isocaproate
Isovaleryl-CoA
3-Methyl-
crotonyl-CoA
Aminotransferase
BCKDH
IVD
MCC
MHBD
Deacylase
Hydratase
3-Oxothiolase
DH
HMG-CoA lyase
2-Methyl-
3-OH-butyryl-CoA
3-OH-isobutyryl-CoA
3-Methyl-
glutaconyl-CoA
2-Methyl-
acetoacetyl-CoA
3-OH-isobutyrate
3-OH-3-methyl-
glutaryl-CoA
Methylmalonate
semialdehyde
IBD
Propionyl-CoA
Acetyl-CoA
Acetoacetate
Tiglyl-
glycine
3-OH-propionate
Methylcitrate
Methylmalonyl-CoA
Succinyl-CoA
Krebs
cycle
Mutase
2-OH-
isovalerate
3-Methylglutarate
Carboxylase
Alloisoleucine
DH
Fig. 12.2.2  Metabolism of branched-​chain amino acids. BCKDH, branched chain α-​keto acid 
dehydrogenase (deficient in MSUD); DH, dehydrogenase; hydratase, 3-​methylglutaconyl-​CoA hydratase 
(deficient in 3-​methylglutaconic aciduria type I); IVD, isovaleryl-​CoA dehydrogenase (deficient in isovaleric 
academia); MCC, 3-​methylcrotonyl-​CoA carboxylase (deficient in methylcrotonylglycinuria); MCM, 
methylmalonyl CoA mutase (deficient in methylmalonic aciduria); MHBD, 2-​methyl-​3-​hydroxybutyryl-​CoA 
dehydrogenase (deficient in 2-​methyl-​3-​hydroxybutyryl-​CoA dehydrogenase deficiency); PCC, propionyl-​
CoA carboxylase (deficient in propionic aciduria). Accumulating pathologic metabolites are shown in italics.
Source data from Zschocke J, Hoffmann GF (2011). Vademecum metabolicum. Manual of metabolic paediatrics, 3rd 
edition. Schattauer, Stuttgart.
Fig. 12.2.3  Opisthotonic hypertonic comatose infant with maple syrup 
urine disease.


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1956
molecular genetics of maple syrup urine disease are too complex 
for diagnostic use. Prenatal testing is available by enzymatic ana-
lysis of amniotic cells.
Treatment and outcome
Emergency treatment aims to reduce branched-​chain amino acids, 
particularly leucine. To induce anabolism, high calorie intake is re-
quired. Most importantly, glucose stimulates endogenous insulin 
secretion activating protein synthesis. If required, insulin should be 
started early. In parallel, supplements free of branched-​chain amino 
acids should be administered by nasogastric drip feeding. Since low 
plasma concentrations of isoleucine and valine limit protein syn-
thesis, cautious supplementation to decrease leucine concentrations 
is mostly required.
Extracorporeal detoxification (haemodialysis, haemofiltration) 
may be required if leucine exceeds 20 mg/​dl (1500 µmol/​litre). Liver 
transplantation may be considered a reasonable treatment option 
for patients with classic maple syrup urine disease. The decision of 
medical treatment versus transplantation, however, is very complex 
and must be reached for each patient individually.
Long-​term treatment of maple syrup urine disease is based on 
dietary restriction of branched-​chain amino acids and supplemen-
tation of thiamine, if proven beneficial. Management requires close 
and lifelong regulation of diet.
Children with the classic form of maple syrup urine disease have a 
satisfactory prognosis only if they are diagnosed and treated before 
symptom onset; for this reason MS/​MS-​based newborn screening 
has been introduced in some countries.
Isovaleric aciduria
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
Isovaleric aciduria was described by Tanaka in 1966. It is caused by 
deficiency of isovaleryl-​CoA dehydrogenase, an enzyme located 
proximally in the catabolic pathway of the essential branched-​chain 
amino acid leucine (Fig. 12.2.2). The encoding IVD gene is local-
ized on 15q14–​q15. Due to the metabolic block, isovaleryl-​CoA 
accumulates, and the pathognomonic metabolite isovalerylglycine 
is formed by conjugation of isovaleryl-​CoA to the amino group of 
glycine through the activity of the mitochondrial enzyme glycine- 
​N-​acylase. It is suggested that accumulating acyl-​CoA esters sequester 
CoA, thereby disturbing energy metabolism. Specifically, isovaleryl-​
CoA inhibits pyruvate dehydrogenase and N-​acetylglutamate syn-
thase causing lactic acidosis and hyperammonaemia. Furthermore, 
isovaleric acid inhibits granulopoiesis and occurs during metabolic 
decompensations.
Clinical presentation
Half of the patients with isovaleric aciduria present in the neonatal 
period with severe metabolic crises that may lead to coma and death, 
whereas the remainder experience chronic intermittent disease with 
episodes of metabolic acidosis and psychomotor retardation. Both 
phenotypes can occur within the same family suggesting a modi-
fying role of environmental and epigenetic factors. A mild, poten-
tially asymptomatic phenotype exists due to a common mutation 
(c.932C>T; p.A282V). This mutation was detected in one-​half of 
mutant alleles in patients identified by newborn screening and also 
in older, healthy siblings.
During metabolic crises, patients present with the typical features 
of classic organic acid disorders, that is, acidosis, ketosis, vomiting, 
progressive alteration of consciousness, and, finally, overwhelming 
illness, deep coma, and death if not given appropriate therapy. 
Clinical abnormalities often develop within the first days of life. 
A pathognomonic foul odour reminiscent of sweaty feet, caused by 
isovaleric acid, occurs. Abnormalities of the haematopoietic system 
such as thrombocytopenia, neutropenia, or pancytopenia develop; 
hyperammonaemia is usually mild.
In the chronic intermittent form, children slide into recur-
rent metabolic crises because of a high intake of protein or 
minor infections inducing a catabolic state. Cytopenias develop 
as described earlier, and hyperglycaemia may develop, most 
likely due to stress-​induced counter-​regulatory hormonal ef-
fects. Pancreatitis may be a complication of isovaleric aciduria. 
Older patients may have normal psychomotor development or 
mild to severe learning difficulties, depending on the frequency 
of decompensation and the age of diagnosis and institution of 
treatment.
Diagnosis
The clinical symptoms of isovaleric aciduria resemble other or-
ganic acidaemias; even the suggestive odour may be shared by 
similar disorders (Boxes 12.2.1 and 12.2.2). The combination of 
ketoacidosis, dehydration, and hyperglycaemia has led to erro-
neous diagnosis of diabetic ketoacidosis, and persistent vomiting 
in infancy to the wrong suggestion of hypertrophic pyloric sten-
osis and unnecessary surgery. A reliable way to accomplish the 
diagnosis is quantitative analysis of urinary organic acids and 
acylglycines by GC/​MS or the analysis of acylcarnitine profiles 
by MS/​MS.
During metabolic decompensation, the urinary organic acid profile 
reveals high excretion of isovalerylglycine which remains elevated. 
3-​Hydroxyisovaleric acid only increases during metabolic decom-
pensation. Isovalerylcarnitine is the characteristic acylcarnitine of 
this disease and its urinary excretion increases following supple-
mentation with l-​carnitine. The diagnosis of isovaleric aciduria can 
be confirmed by enzyme analysis in fibroblasts or mutation analysis 
in specialized laboratories. Several methods have been successfully 
used for prenatal diagnosis including stable isotope dilution ana-
lysis of isovalerylglycine, MS/​MS detection of isovalerylcarnitine in 
amniotic fluid, or macromolecular labelling from (1-​14C)-​isovaleric 
acid in cultured amniocytes. Molecular diagnosis is only available in 
a research setting.
Treatment and outcome
Total natural protein intake is restricted according to the patient’s 
leucine tolerance and is adjusted to age-​specific requirements. To 
provide a complementary source of the other amino acids, a leucine-​
free formula is available. Beyond childhood, a protein-​restricted 
diet allowing a moderate restriction of leucine intake is usually suf-
ficient. In addition, urinary excretion of isovaleryl-​CoA as nontoxic 
carnitine conjugates is activated by supplementation with carnitine 
(50–​100 mg/​kg per day).
During acute decompensation, isovaleric aciduria is treated fol-
lowing the general principles for other organic acid disorders (see 
‘Emergency treatment’).


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1957
Aspirin is contraindicated in patients with isovaleric aciduria be-
cause salicylic acid is a competing substrate for glycine-​N-​acylase, 
interfering with isovalerylglycine synthesis.
Most children will survive the first life-​threatening episode if 
correct treatment is set in place early. If effective treatment can be 
installed before any severe metabolic decompensation, it will sig-
nificantly improve outcome. Therefore, in some countries isovaleric 
aciduria is screened for in newborns using MS/​MS.
3-​Methylcrotonylglycinuria
3-​Methylcrotonylglycinuria is an inborn error of leucine catab-
olism due to deficiency of 3-​α-​methylcrotonyl-​CoA carboxylase 
(Fig. 12.2.2). It appears to be the most frequent inborn organic 
acid disorder, with a frequency of 1 in 50 000 newborns. The 
3-​methylcrotonylglycinuria enzyme requires biotin as a cofactor, 
and the isolated enzymatic defect must be differentiated from pri-
mary deficiencies in the biotin pathway (see ‘Biotinidase deficiency’ 
and ‘Holocarboxylase synthetase deficiency’). As a consequence 
of 3-​methylcrotonylglycinuria deficiency, 3-​hydroxyisovaleric 
acid, 3-​hydroxyisovalerylcarnitine, 3-​methylcrotonylcarnitine, and 
3-​methylcrotonylglycine accumulate.
Clinical presentation
From the follow-​up of individuals identified by newborn screening 
it has become evident that deficiency of 3-​methylcrotonylglycinuria 
is a genetic condition with low clinical expressivity and penetrance, 
representing largely (c.90%) a nondisease. Less than 10% of affected 
individuals may develop mostly mild neurological symptoms which 
are often not clearly attributed to 3-​methylcrotonylglycinuria de-
ficiency. However, a few patients may develop acute metabolic de-
compensation (ketoacidosis, hypoglycaemia, hyperammonaemia, 
Reye-​like syndrome) precipitated by febrile illness during infancy; 
this may be fatal if untreated.
Diagnosis
The diagnosis is confirmed biochemically by identification of 
3-​hydroxyisovaleric acid and 3-​methylcrotonylglycine in urine 
(GC/​MS) or 3-​hydroxyisovalerylcarnitine in dried blood spots or 
plasma (MS/​MS whereas in patients with additionally increased 
3-​hydroxypropionic, methylcitric, or lactic acids multiple carb-
oxylase deficiency or biotinidase deficiency should be considered. 
In particular, 3-​hydroxyisovalerylcarnitine concentrations which 
spontaneously decrease to normal values in follow-​up inves-
tigations of any neonate should prompt the investigation of 3-​
methylcrotonylglycinuria deficiency in the mother.
Significantly reduced enzyme activity in fibroblasts or leucocytes 
or mutation analysis confirms the diagnosis. It is important to ex-
clude multiple carboxylase deficiency by demonstrating normal en-
zyme activities of propionyl-​CoA carboxylase, pyruvate carboxylase, 
as well as biotinidase. Prenatal diagnosis is possible by stable isotope 
dilution analysis of amniotic fluid or by enzymatic and molecular 
analyses in cultivated amniocytes or chorionic villi.
Treatment and outcome
Most affected individuals do not require specific treatment, with 
the exception of carnitine supplementation if secondary carnitine 
depletion is found. However, moderate protein restriction and ad-
ministration of leucine-​free amino acid supplements has been 
tried. 3-​Methylcrotonylglycinuria is usually unresponsive to biotin 
whereas, in those with the p.R385S mutation, biotin responsiveness 
has been reported. If acute metabolic decompensation occurs, af-
fected patients are treated as with other organic acid disorders (see 
‘Emergency treatment’). Most affected individuals remain asymp-
tomatic without specific treatment and thus the benefit of newborn 
screening remains to be elucidated.
3-​Methylglutaconic acidurias
Increased urinary excretion of 3-​methylglutaconic acid is the 
biochemical hallmark of a heterogeneous group of inborn errors 
termed 3-​methylglutaconic acidurias types including a primary 
defect in leucine catabolism, primary mitochondrial disorders, for 
example, Pearson’s syndrome and ATP synthase deficiency, and 
patients with Smith–​Lemli–​Opitz syndrome, a cholesterol biosyn-
thesis disorder. Whereas in 3-​methylglutaconyl-​CoA hydratase de-
ficiency elevated 3-​methylglutaconic is caused by a primary defect 
in leucine degradation, in all other diseases with 3-​methylglutaconic 
aciduria the increase of this metabolite is thought to be secondary 
to mitochondrial membrane biosynthesis, maintenance, and 
phospholipid remodelling or disturbed cholesterol biosynthesis. 
Interestingly, leucine degradation is linked to cholesterol biosyn-
thesis via the Popjak shunt and the 3-​hydroxy-​3-​methylglutaryl-​
CoA salvage pathway. With recognition of an increasing number 
of underlying defects in recent years, the initial nomenclature of 3-​
methylglutaconic acidurias has been revised. In the following, both 
old (type I–​V) and new nomenclature (specifying the syndrome 
and affected gene) are given.
Primary 3-​methylglutaconic aciduria
3-​Methylglutaconic aciduria type I
Aetiology/​pathophysiology  3-​Methylglutaconic 
aciduria 
type 
I  is caused by deficiency of 3-​methylglutaconyl-​CoA hydratase 
(Fig. 12.2.2) required for the conversion of 3-​methylglutaconyl-​
CoA to 3-​hydroxy-​3-​methylglutaryl-​CoA in leucine catabolism. 
The hydratase is identical to an RNA-​binding protein (designated 
AUH) possessing enoyl-​CoA hydratase activity. The defect leads 
to an accumulation of 3-​methylglutaconic, 3-​methylglutaric, and 
3-​hydroxyisovaleric acids.
Clinical presentation  The clinical phenotype of affected individ-
uals is variable and also includes an asymptomatic disease course. 
Patients present with neurological symptoms including delayed 
speech and motor development. Metabolic decompensation with 
hypoglycaemia and metabolic acidosis is rare but can occur fol-
lowing a catabolic state. The recent discovery of the disorder in 
adult-​onset patients with slowly progressive ataxia, dementia, and 
leukoencephalopathy may point to the long-​term nature and mani-
festations of this disease.
Diagnosis  Urinary excretion of large amounts of 3-​methylglutaconic, 
3-​methylglutaric, and 3-​hydroxyisovaleric acids but normal excretion 
of 3-​hydroxy-​3-​methylglutaric acid points to hydratase deficiency. 
Increased 3-​hydroxyisovalerylcarnitine is a hint for either type of 
3-​methylglutaconic aciduria. The definitive diagnosis is made by en-
zyme analysis in fibroblasts or by mutation analysis.
Treatment and outcome  The need for treatment has not been es-
tablished, especially for dietary treatment. The outcome appears 


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1958
favourable as a significant number of untreated patients have never 
developed symptoms.
Secondary 3-​methylglutaconic acidurias
TAZ defect or Barth’s syndrome (formerly,  
3-​methylglutaconic aciduria type II)
Aetiology/​pathophysiology  The molecular basis of Barth’s syn-
drome is deficiency of tafazzin which is localized in the inner 
mitochondrial membrane affecting phospholipid metabolism, 
in particular cardiolipin. The origin of elevated levels of 3-​
methylglutaconic and 3-​methylglutaric acids in Barth’s syndrome is 
unknown.
The identification of the causative gene allowed the retrospective 
classification of different families labelled in the past as X-​linked 
endocardial fibrosis, severe X-​linked cardiomyopathy, or Barth’s 
syndrome. All these entities have been shown to share the same mo-
lecular pathology.
Clinical presentation  In 1983, Barth and colleagues described an 
X-​linked neuromuscular disease characterized by dilated cardio-
myopathy, skeletal myopathy, retarded growth, and neutropenia. 
Patients may present at birth or during the first weeks of life, usually 
with congestive cardiac failure. With long-​standing cardiac disease, 
endocardial fibroelastosis may develop. Delayed gross motor mile-
stones, myopathic facies, a waddling gait, and a positive Gower’s 
sign are common. Occasionally patients may show moderate lactic 
acidosis. Postnatal growth retardation may be severe, and beyond 
2 years of age patients are usually very stunted but with normal head 
circumferences.
Diagnosis  Barth’s syndrome should be considered in any male 
presenting with dilated cardiomyopathy. If neutropenia, idiopathic 
myopathy, and growth retardation are also present, the diagnosis 
of Barth’s syndrome is almost certain. Biochemically, increased 3-​
methylglutaconic acid is usually found in urine but is not a constant 
feature. 2-​Ethylhydracrylic acid may be also elevated. Muscle dis-
ease and lactic acidaemia may initiate a work-​up for mitochondrial 
disorders. Muscle biopsy may reveal involvement of deficient re-
spiratory chain complexes I and IV. The diagnosis is confirmed by 
cardiolipin analysis in thrombocytes or mutation analysis. Mutation 
analysis makes prenatal diagnosis now available.
Treatment and outcome  Children affected by Barth’s syndrome 
need to be carefully managed mainly by expert cardiologists; im-
munologists and neurologists should also be involved. Cardiac ar-
rhythmias carry a poor prognosis and may require implantation of 
an internal cardiac defibrillator. Successful heart transplantation has 
been carried out. Due to increased susceptibility to severe bacterial 
infections, infectious diseases need to be treated promptly and ag-
gressively. Protein restriction and carnitine supplementation has 
been employed with unclear benefit. About 25% of patients with 
Barth’s syndrome succumb during infancy and early childhood due 
to cardiac complications or overwhelming bacterial infections.
OPA3 defect or Costeff’s syndrome (formerly,  
3-​methylglutaconic aciduria type III)
Aetiology/​pathophysiology  Costeff’s syndrome is caused by mu-
tations in the OPA3 gene resulting in a defect of a putative mito-
chondrial protein with yet unknown function. The origin of elevated 
levels of 3-​methylglutaconic and 3-​methylglutaric acids is also un-
known. So far the disorder has only been reported in Iraqi Jews.
Clinical presentation  The determining clinical presentation is 
early-​onset optic atrophy, which may be accompanied by nystagmus. 
In later childhood or adolescence, patients may develop extrapyr-
amidal signs and moderate cognitive impairment. In about one-​half 
of the patients, spasticity develops and progresses over years.
Diagnosis  Costeff’s syndrome should be suspected in patients pre-
senting with early-​onset optic atrophy if additional neurological 
symptoms develop.  3-​Methylglutaconic aciduria is a biochemical 
indicator of Costeff’s syndrome, which may now be proven by mo-
lecular analysis.
Treatment and outcome  Effective treatment has not been reported. 
Treatment is symptomatic and focuses on the prevention of disabil-
ities due to progressive spasticity. The disease appears stationary but 
the long-​term outcome is unknown.
Specified and not otherwise specified 3-​methylglutaconic 
aciduria type IV
Aetiology/​pathophysiology  3-​Methylglutaconic aciduria type IV 
is undoubtedly the most heterogeneous and increasing group of 
3-​methylglutaconic acidurias. As unexplained 3-​methylglutaconic 
aciduria (i.e. type IV) was also found incidentally in asymptomatic 
adults, it appears doubtful that this biochemical feature by itself is of 
pathophysiological relevance.
Diagnosis  Patients are identified by elevated urinary con-
centrations of 3-​methylglutaconic and 3-​methylglutaric acids. 
Classification of type IV methylglutaconic aciduria is made by ex-
clusion of known causes of 3-​methylglutaconic aciduria (see other 
subsections), primary mitochondrial disorders (e.g. Pearson’s syn-
drome), and Smith–​Lemli–​Opitz syndrome. Four clinical pheno-
typic groups have been delineated including patients with an 
encephalopathic, hepatocerebral, cardiomyopathic, and myopathic 
disease form. Genetic testing in these patients has elucidated a high 
number of disease-​causing mutations in the POLG1, SUCLA2, 
TMEM70, and RYR1 genes which have been associated with known 
diseases. Furthermore, MEGDEL syndrome due to mutations in 
the SERAC1 gene was recently described. Based on this, the mo-
lecular cause of 3-​methylglutaconic aciduria type IV can be iden-
tified in many patients. In patients with a known molecular basis 
of 3-​methylglutaconic aciduria, 3-​methylglutaconic aciduria type 
IV shall be replaced by a more specific terminology, for example, 
SERAC1 defect or MEGDEL syndrome, or TMEM70 defect.
Treatment and outcome  No effective treatment has been re-
ported. Treatment is symptomatic and focuses on the prevention 
of neurological deterioration. The identification of type IV 3-​
methylglutaconic aciduria is not yet of prognostic relevance.
DNAJC19 defect or dilated cardiomyopathy with  
ataxia (DCMA) syndrome (formerly, 3-​methylglutaconic 
aciduria type V)
Aetiology/​pathophysiology  Another type of 3-​methylglutaconic 
aciduria has recently been elucidated in 18 patients of the Canadian 
Dariusleut Hutterite population. It is an autosomal recessive con-
dition caused by a mutated DNAJC19 gene. Proteins of the DNAJ 


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1959
domain are involved in molecular chaperone systems, DNAJ19 
having been localized to the inner mitochondrial membrane.
Clinical presentation  Inherited DNAJ19 deficiency leads to clin-
ical presentation which initially resembles Barth’s syndrome (3-​
methylglutaconic aciduria type II) with early-​onset severe dilated 
(or noncompaction) cardiomyopathy with conduction defects. 
However, it also leads to with nonprogressive cerebellar ataxia, tes-
ticular dysgenesis, and growth failure.
Diagnosis  The diagnosis can be made by genetic testing in patients 
with a suggestive clinical presentation and 3-​methylglutaonic aciduria.
Therapy and outcome  No effective treatment has been reported. 
Treatment is symptomatic and focuses on the prevention of cardiac 
deterioration.
2-​Methyl-​3-​hydroxybutyryl-​CoA dehydrogenase deficiency
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
2-​Methyl-​3-​hydroxybutyryl-​CoA dehydrogenase deficiency is a 
rare cerebral organic acid disorder. This mitochondrial enzyme is 
involved in the catabolism of isoleucine and branched-​chain fatty 
acids (Fig. 12.2.2). Retrospectively, patients were misdiagnosed 
as having 3-​oxothiolase deficiency until Zschocke and colleagues 
(2000) recognized the separate distinct clinical and biochemical 
presentation. Inheritance is X-​chromosomal semidominant (fe-
males may be symptomatic). Disease-​causing mutations were iden-
tified in the HSD17B10 gene. The pathophysiology of this disease is 
unknown. The enzyme is identical to an amyloid β-​peptide-​binding 
protein which is implicated in Alzheimer’s disease.
Clinical presentation
2-​Methyl-​3-​hydroxybutyryl-​CoA dehydrogenase deficiency mostly 
results in a progressive neurodegenerative disease. Regression usu-
ally becomes obvious in late infancy or early childhood but is vari-
able. Affected boys usually develop truncal hypotonia with spasticity 
of the limbs, dyskinesia and athetosis, a horizontal nystagmus, and 
retinal blindness. Motor and mental skills are completely lost, as are 
sensory modalities. Epilepsy is frequently found and is usually dif-
ficult to treat. When hypertrophic cardiomyopathy was diagnosed, 
deterioration was rapid with death due to progressive heart failure. 
Neuroimaging documents progressive generalized atrophy, basal 
ganglia injury, periventricular white matter abnormalities, and oc-
cipital infarctions in individual cases. Heterozygous female patients 
may be asymptomatic or may have variable stationary psychomotor 
retardation with impaired hearing.
Diagnosis
The disease should be considered in children presenting with 
early-​onset progressive encephalopathy, especially if X-​linked in-
heritance is suggested. The biochemical hallmark of this disease 
is increased urinary excretion of 2-​methyl-​3-​hydroxybutyric acid 
and tiglylglycine. Elevations of 2-​ethylhydracrylic acid and 3-​
hydroxyisobutyric acid in urine may also be found. These abnor-
malities may be subtle.
Treatment and outcome
No effective rational treatment is known. Care of patients with 
this disease should repeatedly entail (1) assessment of muscle and 
cardiac function, (2)  neurological examination including elec-
troencephalography and MRI, and (3) assessment of visual and 
hearing system. The prognosis is mostly poor, with death in early 
childhood.
Propionic aciduria
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
In 1961, Childs and coworkers described the index patient with pro-
pionic aciduria. Since ketosis and hyperglycinaemia were the bio-
chemical hallmarks recognized, the disorder was lumped together 
with methylmalonic acidurias as ‘ketotic hyperglycinaemia’ to dis-
tinguish it from nonketotic hyperglycinaemia. Implementation 
of GC/​MS analysis to metabolic diagnostic work-​up allowed the 
differentiation of these disorders in the 1970s. Propionic aciduria 
is caused by an autosomal recessive inherited deficiency of biotin-​
dependent duodecameric propionyl-​CoA carboxylase, the first step 
in propionate metabolism, in which propionyl-​CoA is converted to 
methylmalonyl-​CoA (Fig. 12.2.2). Over 100 disease-​causing muta-
tions have been identified in the PCCA gene (13q32) and the PCCB 
gene (3q21–​22).
Propionyl-​CoA is formed from the catabolism of isoleucine, 
threonine, methionine, valine, odd-​numbered fatty acids, and 
the side chain of cholesterol, and from gut bacteria. Deficiency 
of propionyl-​CoA carboxylase gives rise to accumulation of 
propionyl-​CoA and metabolites of alternative propionate oxidation 
such as 2-​methylcitric acid, 3-​hydroxypropionic acid, tiglic acid, 
propionylcarnitine, and propionylglycine. All of these can be de-
tected and quantified by GC/​MS (urine, plasma) or MS/​MS (dried 
blood spots, plasma).
Elevated propionyl-​CoA and its pathological derivatives inter-
fere with a variety of metabolic pathways including inhibition of 
(1)  the glycine cleavage enzyme resulting in hyperglycinaemia, 
(2)  N-​acetylglutamate synthase resulting in hyperammonaemia, 
and (3) pyruvate dehydrogenase complex as well as several enzymes 
of the tricarboxylic acid cycle resulting in lactic acidaemia and 
hyperketosis, and severe impairment of energy metabolism.
Clinical presentation
Propionic aciduria usually presents with severe neonatal meta-
bolic decompensation characterized clinically by multiorgan 
failure and biochemically by hyperammonaemia, metabolic 
acidosis, hyperketosis, lactic acidaemia, hyperglycinaemia, and 
hyperalaninaemia. Propionic aciduria may be misinterpreted as 
sepsis or ventricular haemorrhage. Acute metabolic decompen-
sation and long-​term complications usually involve organs with a 
high energy demand, including the brain, heart and skeletal muscle, 
liver, and bone marrow. Frequent signs and symptoms are failure to 
thrive, microcephaly, mild to severe motor disabilities and learning 
difficulties, truncal hypotonia, extrapyramidal symptoms (dystonia, 
chorea), seizures, cardiomyopathy, myopathy, hepatomegaly, acute 
or chronic pancreatitis, leucopenia, thrombocytopenia, anaemia, 
or pancytopenia, whereas renal complications are uncommon. 
Metabolic decompensations in infancy or childhood are similar to 
those in the neonatal period. The first symptom is often vomiting; 
this has led to erroneous diagnosis of pyloric stenosis or duodenal 
obstruction, resulting in a number of pyloromyotomies or other 
explorations. Basal ganglia injury, mostly affecting the putamen, 


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1960
occurs (Fig. 12.2.4); generalized cerebral atrophy and white matter 
disease is common.
A small subgroup of patients exhibit almost exclusively encephal-
opathy and progressive neurological disease, resembling a lysosomal 
storage disorder. A milder form of propionic aciduria reported in 
Japan manifests from childhood with mild learning difficulties or 
extrapyramidal symptoms, and only occasionally with metabolic 
acidosis. Finally, some individuals remain asymptomatic until 
teenage years and are identified during family studies.
Diagnosis
The method of diagnosis is GC/​MS analysis of organic acids 
(urine) or MS/​MS analysis of acylcarnitines (dried blood spots, 
plasma, urine). Characteristic metabolites are 2-​methylcitric 
acid, 3-​hydroxypropionic acid, tiglic acid, propionylglycine, and 
propionylcarnitine. The absence of methylmalonic acid excludes 
methylmalonic acidurias, and the absence of β-​hydroxyisovaleric 
acid and β-​methylcrotonylglycine rules out multiple carboxylase de-
ficiency. In plasma and urine, increased concentrations of glycine and 
ketone bodies may be present. Confirmation of diagnosis is made by 
enzyme analysis in leucocytes or fibroblasts, or by mutation analysis. 
Prenatal diagnosis can be made by mutation analysis, enzyme ana-
lysis, or quantitative GC/​MS analysis of 2-​methylcitric acid.
Treatment and outcome
Prevention of metabolic decompensation is the most important de-
terminant of outcome. During acute decompensation, propionic 
aciduria is treated like other organic acid disorders (see ‘Emergency 
treatment’). Long-​term treatment is based on lifelong dietary restric-
tion of the precursors isoleucine, valine, methionine, and threonine, 
as well as by supplementation with l-​carnitine. As significant propi-
onate production occurs in the gut, intermittent decontamination 
(10–​14 days/​month) with metronidazole or colistin as well as meas-
ures preventing constipation are often used. Some patients exhibit 
recurrent or almost chronic hyperammonaemia, especially during 
infancy. This may necessitate additional supplementation with ar-
ginine or citrulline and/​or administration of sodium benzoate or 
phenylbutyrate. However, benzoate treatment may aggravate the 
depletion of free carnitine and CoA. Biotin responsiveness in propi-
onic aciduria is very rare, if present at all. More than 20 children with 
propionic aciduria have undergone orthotopic liver transplantation, 
but the outcome is mixed. Auxiliary as well as living-​related liver 
transplantations have been successfully performed, but liver trans-
plantation in propionic aciduria seems to be more complicated than 
in patients with urea cycle defects.
Patients with neonatal onset of symptoms still have a poor out-
come. Patients with late onset of symptoms reach adulthood but often 
have physical and mental disabilities; nonetheless, some patients can 
survive to adulthood with normal intellects. The phenotypic vari-
ation of patients with propionic aciduria as well as evidence-​based 
recommendations for diagnosis, treatment, and follow-​up have re-
cently been reported by an international consortium of experts.
Methylmalonic aciduria
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
Methylmalonic aciduria is the biochemical hallmark of a heteroge-
neous group of inborn metabolic errors with a cumulative prevalence 
of at least 1 in 100 000 newborns in Europe. Index patients were first 
described in 1967 by Oberholzer and Stokke. This section focuses on 
isolated methylmalonic aciduria caused by mutations in the MUT 
gene localized on 6p21 encoding the apoenzyme methylmalonyl-​
CoA mutase. Methylmalonyl-​CoA mutase can alternatively be im-
paired by defects in the biosynthesis of 5′-​deoxyadenosylcobalamin, 
deficient cobalamin transport, or by acquired cobalamin deficiency 
as in pernicious anaemia.
In infancy, severe progressive disease may develop in breastfed 
infants of mothers who have (undiagnosed) pernicious anaemia or 
adhere to a strict vegan diet. Methylmalonic acid is a more reliable 
index of body stores of cobalamin than cobalamin levels in blood.
d-​Methylmalonyl-​CoA is formed in propionate metabolism by 
carboxylation of propionyl-​CoA. l-​Methylmalonyl-​CoA is formed 
from d-​methylmalonyl-​CoA by d-​methylmalonyl-​CoA racemase 
and, subsequently, is converted to succinyl-​CoA by the dimeric 
5′-​deoxyadenosylcobalamin-​dependent mitochondrial enzyme 
methylmalonyl-​CoA mutase (Fig. 12.2.2).
As with propionic aciduria (see ‘Propionic aciduria’), impairment 
of energy metabolism by propionyl-​CoA and 2-​methylcitric acid 
plays a key role in the pathophysiology of methylmalonic acidurias, 
resulting in multiorgan failure. In addition, methylmalonic acid may 
exert additional toxic effects.
Clinical presentation
Patients with severe methylmalonyl-​CoA mutase deficiency (mut0) 
usually present with neonatal metabolic crises which are clinically 
Fig. 12.2.4  Transverse MRI image of a 7-​year-​old girl, who had been 
diagnosed with propionic aciduria in infancy and had been successfully 
treated since then. While in good metabolic control, she suddenly 
became comatose. Massive infarction of the basal ganglia had occurred, 
and the child died a few days later. Spin echo technique.
Courtesy of Drs R. Haas and W.L. Nyhan, Department of Pediatrics, University of 
California, San Diego, USA.


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1961
and biochemically (except for methylmalonic acid) indistinguish-
able from those of patients with propionic aciduria. In patients with 
residual methylmalonyl-​CoA mutase activity (mut−), the onset of 
symptoms is more variable. Neonatal onset of symptoms is found 
as is a chronic intermittent form, that is, precipitation of recurrent 
metabolic crises in infancy and children following a high intake of 
protein or a catabolic state. Long-​term complications are frequent, 
in particular in mut0 patients. These include failure to thrive, chronic 
neurological symptoms such as extrapyramidal movement disorder, 
motor disabilities, learning difficulties, and epilepsy, cardiomyop-
athy, myopathy, and pancreatitis. Neuroradiological studies demon-
strate lesions of globus pallidus, generalized cerebral atrophy, and 
white matter disease. The development of chronic renal failure in a 
large proportion of patients appears inevitable.
Diagnosis
A reliable way to make the diagnosis is GC/​MS analysis of urinary 
organic acids or MS/​MS analysis of acylcarnitines showing ele-
vated concentrations of methylmalonic acid as well as of metab-
olites of alternative propionate oxidation (e.g. propionylglycine, 
3-​hydroxypropionic acid, 2-​methylcitric acid, propionylglycine, and 
propionylcarnitine; as in propionic aciduria). These biochemical 
abnormalities have a considerable interday and intraday variation 
and are influenced by responsiveness to cobalamin and metabolic 
state. Differential diagnosis of methylmalonic aciduria is acquired 
cobalamin depletion or inherited cobalamin deficiencies, transient 
mild methylmalonic acidurias of unknown origin in infants, and 
methylmalonic encephalopathy due to deficiency of succinyl-​CoA 
synthase. Concomitant megaloblastic anaemia and an increase of 
plasma homocysteine indicates disturbed cobalamin metabolism as 
the cause of methylmalonic aciduria.
Standardized criteria to define responsiveness to hydroxocobalamin 
are not established. The determination of methylmalonyl-​CoA 
mutase activity in fibroblast extracts, mutation analysis or the in-
vestigation of labelled propionate incorporation following transfec-
tion by a vector containing cloned mutase cDNA in intact patients’ 
fibroblasts may be required to differentiate primary defects of 
methylmalonyl-​CoA mutase (mut0, mut−) from primary defects of 5′-​
deoxyadenosylcobalamin (cblA and cblB defects). Prenatal diagnosis 
is available by enzyme or mutation analyses as well as by quantitative 
stable isotope dilution assay of 2-​methylcitric acid.
Treatment and outcome
Metabolic maintenance and emergency treatment follows the treat-
ment principles for organic acid disorders in general and propionic 
aciduria in particular (see ‘Propionic aciduria’). In addition, substi-
tution with cobalamin may be beneficial, since partial or complete 
response to cobalamin has been demonstrated (except for mut0 pa-
tients). In neonates and infants, intramuscular hydroxocobalamin 
is required; children and adults may be treated with oral cyano-
cobalamin. Chronic renal failure may progress, necessitating 
haemodialysis or peritoneal dialysis. Kidney transplantation has 
been performed in these patients. Liver transplantation can provide 
enzyme activity to ameliorate the metabolic defect and the idea of 
combined liver–​kidney or isolated liver transplantation has emerged. 
The benefit remains doubtful, however, as mortality is significant; in 
addition, liver transplantation does not reliably protect against se-
vere neurological and renal complications. The phenotypic variation 
of patients with methylmalonic aciduria as well as evidence-​based 
recommendations for diagnosis, treatment, and follow-​up have re-
cently been reported by an international consortium of experts.
3-​Hydroxyisobutyryl-​CoA hydrolase deficiency
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
3-​Hydroxyisobutyryl-​CoA hydrolase (HIBCH) catalyses the 
fifth step of valine catabolism converting 3-​hydroxyisobutyryl-​
CoA to 3-​hydroxyisobutyrate and is due to biallelic mutations 
of the HIBCH gene which is located on 2q32.2. HIBCH de-
ficiency is biochemically characterized by accumulation of 
3-​hydroxyisobutyrylcarnitine deriving from 3-​hydroxyisobutyryl-​
CoA and S-​2-​carboxypropyl-​L-​cysteine and -​cysteamine deriving 
from methyacrylyl-​CoA. Whereas 3-​hydroxyisobutyrylcarnitine 
can be eliminated via urinary excretion, methylacrylyl-​CoA is a 
highly reactive compound which readily undergoes addition reac-
tion with sulphhydryl groups. Inactivation of sulhydryl-​containing 
enzymes such as respiratory chain complexes and cofactors is con-
sidered as the major pathomechanism.
Clinical presentation
So far this disease has rarely been described. Patients presented with 
a (Leigh-​like) mitochondrial encephalopathy starting in infancy, 
delayed global development, muscular hypotonia, poor feeding, 
and multiple malformations (dysmorphic facial features, vertebral 
anomalies, tetralogy of Fallot, agenesis of cingulate gyrus and corpus 
callosum) in one patient. Neurological symptoms are progressive.
Diagnosis
The diagnosis is based on metabolic tests demonstrating elevated 
3-​hydroxyisobutyrylcarnitine by tandem mass spectrometry 
and 2-​methyl-​2,3-​dihydroxybutyric acid and 2-​hydroxyisovaleric 
acid by organic acid analysis. S-​2-​carboxypropyl-​L-​cysteine and -​
cysteamine can be determined by specific HPLC analysis. Enzymatic 
testing of the deficient enzyme in fibroblast and molecular genetic 
testing confirms the diagnosis. Analysis of respiratory chain en-
zymes in muscle biopsy often show decreased activity of pyruvate 
dehydrogenase complex and/​or multiple deficiencies of respiratory 
chain complexes.
Treatment and outcome
Since this disease is thought to be caused by accumulation of toxic 
metabolites of the valine catabolic pathway, a low-​valine diet should 
be considered as a treatment option. Carnitine supplementation 
prevents secondary carnitine depletion. However, the efficacy of this 
therapeutic approach has not yet been systematically studied.
Short-​chain enoyl-​CoA hydratase deficiency
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
Mitochondrial short-​chain enoyl-​CoA hydratase (ECHS1) is a 
multispecific enzyme that catalyses the hydration of chain-​shortened 
α,β-​unsaturated enoyl-​CoA thioesters in the β-​oxidation spiral of 
fatty acids as well as in the catabolic pathways of valine, isoleucine, 
tryptophan, and lysine. Deficiency of ECHS1, which is coded by the 
ECHS1 gene located on 10q26.3, induces a very similar biochem-
ical phenotype as in HIBCH deficiency. In contrast to HIBCH defi-
ciency, however, tiglylglycine but not 3-​hydroxyisobutyrylcarnitine 


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1962
is elevated. Inconsistently, there is evidence of mildly impaired 
mitochondrial oxidation of short-​chain fatty acids. The biochemical 
derangement highlights that in analogy to HIBCH deficiency, im-
pairment of valine catabolism and thus accumulation of the toxic 
metabolite methacrylyl-​CoA is most important.
Clinical presentation
Patients present with (Leigh-​like) mitochondrial encephalopathy, 
dystonia, epilepsy, optic nerve atrophy and cardiomyopathy. Onset 
of symptoms is usually found in the newborn period or during in-
fancy. The disease course is progressive and in its severest form it 
might be fatal in infancy or childhood.
Diagnosis
Diagnosis of this disease should be considered in patients with a 
combination of mitochondrial encephalopathy and cardiomyop-
athy. Urinary excretion of 2-​methyl-​2,3-​dihydroxybutyric acid is 
determined by organic acid analysis, S-​2-​carboxypropyl-​L-​cysteine 
and -​cysteamine can be analysed using specific HPLC methods. 
Enzymatic testing of the deficient enzyme in fibroblast and mo-
lecular genetic testing confirm the diagnosis. Analysis of respira-
tory chain enzymes in muscle biopsy often show decreased activity 
of pyruvate dehydrogenase complex and/​or multiple deficiencies of 
respiratory chain complexes.
Treatment and outcome
In analogy to HIBCH deficiency, a low-​valine diet should be con-
sidered a treatment option. It remains to be elucidated whether this 
therapeutic intervention is able to improve the disease course.
Malonic aciduria
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
First described in 1984, very few patients with malonic aciduria have 
been delineated until now. Malonic aciduria is caused by malonyl-​
CoA decarboxylase deficiency leading to a disturbed fatty acid me-
tabolism. Malonyl-​CoA is the first committed intermediate of fatty 
acid synthesis. In addition, it regulates carnitine acyltransferases 
among other enzymes steering fatty acid metabolism. The cytocolic 
enzyme is found most often in the liver, brain, heart, and skeletal 
muscle.
Clinical presentation
The clinical presentation is variable but mostly involves acute meta-
bolic episodes with progressive lethargy, hypotonia, and hepato-
megaly associated with metabolic acidosis. Hypoglycaemia, lactic 
acidosis, and/​ or mild hyperammonaemia can also develop. Cardiac 
involvement is present in about 40% of patients with cardiomy-
opathy which can progress to cardiac failure. Other patients were 
identified with less specific symptoms such as developmental delay, 
hypotonia, seizures, and short stature.
Diagnosis
Urinary organic acids identify increased malonic acid, sometimes in 
combination with fumaric acid, malic acid, and aethylmalonic acid. 
During metabolic decompensations ketosis develops with elevated 
dicarboxylic acids. Total and free carnitine levels are reduced due 
to the formation of malonylcarnitine, which may allow population 
newborn screening.
Treatment and outcome
A clearly effective therapeutic regimen has not been established. 
Carnitine supplementation as well as a diet high in carbohydrates 
and low in long-​chain triglycerides improved the clinical symp-
toms as well as metabolic disturbances in patients. In some patients, 
medium-​chain triglycerides supplements appeared helpful. Little is 
known about the long-​term prospects of this disorder. Patients were 
stable on the different treatment options at least until adolescence.
Defects of lysine, hydroxylysine, and 
tryptophan metabolism
The common catabolic pathway of lysine, hydroxylysine, and trypto-
phan is summarized in Fig. 12.2.5.
Hyperlysinaemia I/​hyperlysinaemia II or saccharopinuria
Hyperlysinaemia/​saccharopinuria is caused by a recessive deficiency 
of the bifunctional protein 2-​aminoadipic semialdehyde synthase. 
As hyperlysinaemia/​saccharopinuria is considered a nondisease, af-
fected individuals do not require specific treatment.
2-​Amino-​/​2-​oxoadipic aciduria
Disease-​causing mutations in the DHTKD1 gene cause autosomal 
recessive 2-​amino-​/​2-​oxoadipic aciduria. This gene encodes for the 
E1 subunit of a 2-​oxoglutarate dehydrogenase complex-​like pro-
tein in the lysine degradative pathway. Most affected individuals re-
main asymptomatic, whereas others may present with variable mild 
neurological symptoms.
Glutaric aciduria type I
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
Glutaric aciduria type I  was described in 1975. It occurs with 
an estimated frequency of 1 in 100 000 newborns, but which is 
Acetyl-CoA
Kynurenine
2-Aminoadipic semialdehyde
2-Aminoadipic acid
2-Oxoadipic acid
Glutaryl-CoA
Lysine
Tryptophan
Saccharopine
Phospho-
hydroxylysine
3-OH-kynurenine
2-Oxoadipic acid
2-Amino-
adipic acid
Reductase
Dehydrogenase
Aminotransferase
Dehydrogenase
GCDH
Crotonyl-CoA
SCHAD
Hydroxylysine
Kinase
Dioxygenase
Kynureninase
Cytosol
Mito-
chondrion
Transport
in/out
mitochondria
Fig. 12.2.5  Catabolic pathway of lysine, tryptophan, and hydroxylysine. 
2-​Aminoadipic semialdehyde synthase (deficient in hyperlysinaemia/​
saccharopinuria); 2-​aminoadipate aminotransferase (deficiency 
has not yet been reported), 2-​oxoglutarate dehydrogenase-​like 
complex (deficient in in 2-​amino-​/​2-​oxoadipic aciduria); glutaryl-​CoA 
dehydrogenase (GCDH; deficient in glutaric aciduria type I).
Source data from Zschocke J, Hoffmann GF (2011). Vademecum metabolicum. 
Manual of metabolic paediatrics, 3rd edition. Schattauer, Stuttgart.


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1963
considerably higher (up to 1 in 300) in some communities (e.g. the 
Amish in Pennsylvania, United States of America, and the Oji-​Cree 
First Nations in Canada). Glutaric aciduria type I is caused by de-
ficiency of flavin adenine dinucleotide-​dependent glutaryl-​CoA 
dehydrogenase, a mitochondrial enzyme in the catabolic pathway 
common to tryptophan, lysine, and hydroxylysine (Fig. 12.2.5). 
Glutaryl-​CoA dehydrogenase is encoded by the GCDH gene lo-
calized on 19p13.2. More than 200 disease-​causing mutations have 
been described. There is no genotype–​phenotype correlation. As a 
consequence of glutaryl-​CoA dehydrogenase deficiency, glutaric, 
3-​hydroxyglutaric, and (inconsistently) glutaconic acids as well 
as glutarylcarnitine accumulate. The limited permeability of the 
blood–​brain barrier to dicarboxylic acids (such as glutaric acid) 
leads to their accumulation in the brain (trapping hypothesis). Some 
of these metabolites are neurotoxins. Candidate mechanisms are 
stimulation of excitotoxic cell damage via activation of N-​methyl-​d-​
aspartate receptors, and inhibition of 2-​oxoglutarate dehydrogenase 
and the dicarboxylate shuttle between astrocytes and neurons.
Clinical presentation
Newborns are often asymptomatic but may present with transient 
and subtle neurological symptoms such as truncal hypotonia or 
asymmetric posturing. (Progressive) macrocephaly occurs in 75% 
of patients. Neuroimaging in infancy often reveals hypoplasia of the 
temporal pole, subependymal pseudocysts, and delayed myelin-
ation; subdural fluid collections may be found which may be mis-
taken as nonaccidental trauma.
The prognostically relevant event of glutaric aciduria type I is the 
onset of an acute encephalopathic crisis which is usually precipi-
tated by a catabolic state (e.g. febrile illness) during infancy and early 
childhood. Encephalopathic crises characteristically result in acute 
striatal injury and, subsequently, dystonia. Approximately 15% of 
patients with glutaric aciduria type I follow a chronic disease course 
and develop the same neurological symptoms as the acutely injured 
children over the first 2 years of life without overt crisis (insidious-​
onset variant) or during adolescence/​adulthood presenting with 
leukoencephalopathy (late-​onset variant). Asymptomatic indi-
viduals occur occasionally. Neuroradiological abnormalities are 
frequently found, including widening of the sylvian fissure due to re-
duced opercularization (Fig. 12.2.6a), ventriculomegaly and striatal 
lesions which develop after the encephalopathic crisis (Fig. 12.2.6b), 
and leukoencephalopathy which is mostly periventricular but may 
also affect subcortical U fibres (Fig. 12.2.6c).
Diagnosis
Glutaric aciduria type I should be suspected in patients with macro-
cephaly and an extrapyramidal movement disorder starting in in-
fancy or childhood. The diagnostic process can be guided by further 
clinical features. Diagnosis is ascertained by GC/​MS detection of 
glutaric and 3-​hydroxyglutaric acids in organic acid analysis (urine, 
plasma, or cerebrospinal fluid) or by MS/​MS detection of elevated 
glutarylcarnitine (dried blood spots, plasma, urine). Confirmation 
by enzymatic analysis in leucocytes or fibroblasts or demonstration 
of two pathogenic mutations is advisable. A subgroup of patients 
presents with a mild biochemical phenotype (low excretors) and 
thus may be missed if diagnostic work-​up does not include quan-
titative methods (e.g. stable isotope dilution assay). Examination of 
the carnitine status usually reveals low total and free carnitine.
Prenatal diagnosis is possible by determining glutaric acid with 
stable isotope dilution techniques and by enzymatic and/​or mo-
lecular testing.
Treatment and outcome
The principal aim of treatment is the prevention of encephalopathic 
crises and neurological deterioration. Strict adherence to the emer-
gency protocol is especially important (see ‘Emergency treatment’). 
During the vulnerable period (i.e. until age 6 years), lysine-​restricted 
dietary treatment (including lysine-​free amino acid supplements) 
and carnitine supplementation is recommended. Riboflavin is widely 
used but is of doubtful benefit. Treatment efficacy of movement dis-
orders is still poor. Baclofen, benzodiazepines, and trihexyphenidyl 
are widely used to treat dystonia. Botulinum toxin and intrathecal 
baclofen are valid additions. If patients are diagnosed while they 
are asymptomatic, treatment prevents brain degeneration in the 
majority of patients. Notably, best outcome results (≥90% remain 
healthy) were achieved for patients following international guide-
line recommendations including a low-​lysine diet and carnitine 
supplementation for maintenance treatment and immediate emer-
gency treatment during any putatively threatening episode such 
as intercurrent infectious diseases. Deviation from this combined 
metabolic treatment increases the risk of motor disability such as in 
untreated patients. More than 90% of untreated patients are thought 
to develop neurological disabilities. Life expectancy is markedly re-
duced following the manifestation of dystonia.
Hyperornithinaemia 
(ornithine-​5-​aminotransferase): gyrate atrophy
Autosomal recessive hyperornithinaemia associated with gyrate 
atrophy of the choroid and retina is caused by deficiency of 
ornithine-​5-​aminotransferase.
Clinical presentation
Progressive myopia is the first clinical symptom, followed by pro-
gressive chorioretinal degeneration with night blindness starting 
late in the first decade. Loss of peripheral vision proceeds to tunnel 
vision and eventually blindness by the third or fourth decade. The 
principal abnormality is an atrophy of choroid and retina. Cataracts 
also develop but optic discs, cornea, and iris remain normal. A few 
patients develop mild proximal muscle weakness.
Diagnosis
Severe isolated hyperornithinaemia is usually discovered by amino 
acid analysis with plasma ornithine concentrations ranging from 
400 to 1400 µmol/​litre (normal <200 µmol/​litre). The disease can 
be confirmed enzymatically by decreased activity of ornithine-​
5-​aminotransferase in fibroblasts as well as by identification of 
disease-​causing mutations in the OAT gene, but the diagnosis is usu-
ally evident.
Treatment and prognosis
Permanent reduction of plasma ornithine into the normal range 
(<200 µmol/​litre) is required to stop or at least slow chorioretinal 
degeneration. Only a small proportion of patients respond to 
pharmacological doses of the ornithine-​5-​aminotransferase co-
factor pyridoxine. Additional therapeutic approaches to reduce or-
nithine are the augmentation of renal losses by administration of 


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1964
pharmacological doses of l-​lysine or α-​aminoisobutyric acid (which 
is not metabolized), or substrate deprivation by dietary arginine re-
striction. Combined treatment appears to be necessary since no 
single therapy is unequivocally effective.
Multiple carboxylase deficiency
The water-​soluble vitamin biotin is a cofactor of four important 
carboxylases that take part in gluconeogenesis, fatty acid synthesis, 
and the catabolism of several amino acids and odd-​chain fatty acids 
(Fig. 12.2.7). The covalent binding of biotin with apocarboxylases 
forming the active holocarboxylases is catalysed by biotin 
holocarboxylase synthetase. In the biotin cycle, biotin is recycled 
after proteolytic degradation of holocarboxylases (Fig. 12.2.8). 
Biotin in small amounts is widely present in natural foods. Within the 
body, biotin bound to holocarboxylases represents the major source. 
In dietary and in endogenous sources, biotin is protein-​bound as 
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 12.2.6  (a) Axial T2-​weighted MRI spin echo image of a 2½-​year-​old boy with glutaryl-​CoA dehydrogenase deficiency. He was diagnosed 
neonatally, never suffered an encephalopathic crisis, and developed no major neurological deficit. Extension of sylvian fissures which was mild during 
early infancy had slowly regressed. He did not develop characteristic frontotemporal atrophy and showed a normal myelination. (b) Axial T2-​weighted 
spin echo image of a 15-​month-​old boy with glutaryl-​CoA dehydrogenase deficiency 2 weeks after acute encephalopathic crisis. In addition to 
extension of sylvian fissures, hyperintensity of putamen, caudate, and pallidum are obvious. (c) T2-​weighted axial and coronal MRIs of a 66-​year-​old 
man with glutaryl-​CoA dehydrogenase deficiency demonstrating confluent white matter changes, wide temporopolar and insular cerebrospinal fluid 
spaces, and cortical atrophy, but normal signal of basal ganglia. The previously healthy man presented from the age of 50 with slowly progressive 
neurological disease, including seizures, dementia, and speech problems. Aggressive behaviour as well as acoustic and visual hallucinations led to the 
suggestion of psychiatric disease.
(c) Reproduced with permission from Külkens et al. 2005.


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1965
biocytin or short biotinyl peptides. Liberation of biotin from its pro-
tein conjugates is catalysed by biotinidase.
Biotinidase deficiency
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
Biotinidase regenerates biotin from endogenous sources and liber-
ates protein-​bound biotin, which derives from natural foodstuffs 
and the holocarboxylases. Free biotin is recycled and used for the 
reformation of holocarboxylases by the action of holocarboxylase 
synthetase through the biotin cycle (Fig. 12.2.8). The primary bio-
chemical defect in most patients with late-​onset multiple carb-
oxylase deficiency was shown in 1983 to be a profound deficiency of 
serum biotinidase encoded by the BTD gene (3p25). The metabolic 
abnormalities caused by deficiency of the respective biotin-​dependent 
carboxylases are as follows:  lactic acidosis due to pyruvate carb-
oxylase deficiency; hyperammonaemia and accumulation of me-
tabolites of alternative propionate metabolism (see also ‘Propionic 
aciduria’) due to propionyl-​CoA carboxylase deficiency; and eleva-
tion of 3-​hydroxyisovaleric acid, 3-​methylcrotonylglycine, and 3-​
hydroxyisovalerylcarnitine (see also ‘3-​Methylcrotonylglycinuria’) 
due to methylcrotonyl-​CoA carboxylase deficiency.
Clinical presentation
Onset of first symptoms is variable, ranging from 1 week to 10 years 
of age. The mean age of presentation is between 3 and 6 months. 
Provision of biotin by the mother in utero delays symptoms and bio-
chemical abnormalities in newborns with biotinidase deficiency. 
The most frequent symptoms are lethargy, hypotonia, seizures, and 
ataxia often in combination with stridor, episodes of hyperventi-
lation, and apnoea. If undiagnosed and untreated, progression of 
the disease can be potentially fatal (Fig. 12.2.9). In older children, 
progressive neurological disease is often the leading presentation, 
including ataxia, (myoclonic) epileptic encephalopathy, and devel-
opmental delay. Neurosensory hearing loss and ophthalmic dis-
orders, such as optic atrophy, develop in most untreated patients. 
Skin rash and/​or alopecia are hallmarks of the disease.
Diagnosis
Urinary organic acid analysis is useful for differentiating isolated 
carboxylase deficiencies from the multiple carboxylase deficien-
cies that occur in biotinidase deficiency and holocarboxylase syn-
thase deficiency. However, metabolic abnormalities are highly 
variable and are absent at birth when the patient is not biotin de-
pleted. Whereas accumulation of abnormal organic acid metabol-
ites may show characteristic metabolites of propionic aciduria (see 
also ‘Propionic aciduria’), pyruvate carboxylase deficiency, and 
3-​methylcrotonylglycinuria (see also ‘3-​Methylcrotonylglycinuria’) 
(Fig. 12.2.2), only 3-​hydroxyisovaleric acid may be found ele-
vated, especially in the early stages of the disease. Notably, 
3-​hydroxyisovaleric acid is also the most commonly elevated 
urinary metabolite in holocarboxylase synthetase deficiency, 
3-​methylcrotonyl-​CoA carboxylase deficiency, and acquired biotin 
deficiency. Biotin is decreased in plasma and urine and biocytin is 
increased in urine.
Diagnosis is made by analysis of serum biotinidase activity. 
Enzymatic activity less than 10% is classified as profound biotinidase 
deficiency and activity between 10 and 30% as partial biotinidase 
deficiency. Furthermore, few patients with decreased affinity of 
biotinidase for biocytin (Km variants) exist. They may show erro-
neously high residual activity on in vitro testing. Prenatal diagnosis 
is feasible by measurement of biotinidase activity but may not be 
necessary because of effective treatment and favourable clinical out-
come. Newborn screening for biotinidase deficiency is now estab-
lished in many countries.
Treatment and outcome
Biotinidase deficiency is effectively treated by daily oral adminis-
tration of pharmacological doses of biotin. Restriction of protein is 
not necessary. Administration of 5 to 10 mg of oral biotin per day 
promptly reverses or prevents all clinical and biochemical abnor-
malities. Biotin treatment has to be maintained lifelong and has no 
Succinate
Oxaloacetate
3*
4*
2*
1*
Citrate
Acetyl-CoA
Pyruvate
Methylmalonyl-CoA
Propionyl-CoA
Malonyl-CoA
Fatty acids
3-Methylglutaconyl-CoA
3-Methylcrotonyl-CoA
Leucine
Glucose
Valine
Isoleucine
Threonine
Odd-chain fatty
acids
Fig. 12.2.7  Important carboxylases in amino acid metabolism. 
Asterisked enzymes are 1, 3-​methylcrotonyl coenzyme A carboxylase; 2, 
propionyl coenzyme A carboxylase; 3, pyruvate carboxylase; and 4, acetyl 
coenzyme A carboxylase.
Biotin
Apocarboxylases
(PCC, MCC, PC, ACC)
Holocarboxylases
Biocytin,
short biotinylpeptides 
Holocarboxylase 
synthetase
Proteolysis
Biotinidase
Protein-bound
biotin (diet)
Lysine
Lysylpeptides
Biotinidase
Fig. 12.2.8  The biotin cycle. Biotin is cleaved from biocytin (biotinyl-​
lysine) or small peptides by biotinidase. Activation of the apoenzymes 
resulting in functioning carboxylases (3-​methylcrotonyl-​CoA, 
propionyl-​CoA, acetyl-​CoA, and pyruvate carboxylases) is carried out 
by holocarboxylase synthetase. ACC, acetyl-​CoA carboxylase; MCC, 
3-​methylcrotonyl-​CoA carboxylase; PC, pyruvate carboxylase; PCC, 
propionyl-​CoA carboxylase.
Source data from Zschocke J, Hoffmann GF (2011). Vademecum metabolicum. 
Manual of metabolic paediatrics, 3rd edition. Schattauer, Stuttgart.


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1966
side effects. Most patients with biotinidase deficiency known today 
were detected by newborn screening. Patients with Km variants have 
an increased risk of becoming biotin deficient and thus must also be 
treated with biotin. After early detection and consequent treatment, 
the outcome of biotinidase deficiency is excellent.
Holocarboxylase synthetase deficiency
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
Holocarboxylase synthetase deficiency is a rare, autosomal reces-
sive disease. Several disease-​causing mutations have been identified 
in the HLCS gene (21q22.1). Only about 40 patients have been re-
ported. Residual activity has been observed in all affected individuals 
suggesting that complete enzyme deficiency may be lethal in utero. 
The coenzyme biotin is attached to the various apocarboxylases 
by the enzyme holocarboxylase synthetase. The carboxyl group of 
biotin is linked by an amide bond to an ε-​amino group of a specific 
lysine residue of the apoenzymes. Deficiency of holocarboxylase 
synthetase leads to failure of synthesis of all carboxylases, causing 
biochemical and clinical abnormalities attributable to the dysfunc-
tion of each respective carboxylase.
Clinical presentation
Although holocarboxylase synthetase deficiency was initially 
termed early-​onset multiple carboxylase deficiency, the age of onset 
of symptoms varies widely, from a few hours after birth to 6 years 
of age. Nevertheless, about one-​half of patients present acutely in 
the first days of life with severe metabolic decompensation, leth-
argy, hypotonia, vomiting, seizures, and hypothermia. Patients 
with early-​onset presentation exhibit severe metabolic acidosis with 
lactic acidaemia, ketosis, and hyperammonaemia in analogy to 
biotinidase deficiency (see also ‘Biotinidase deficiency’). The meta-
bolic derangement may quickly progress from lethargy to coma and 
early death. Skin rashes, feeding difficulties, vomiting, muscular 
hypotonia and hypertonia, seizures, and the odour of male cat urine 
are other symptoms. Ataxia, tremor, hyporeflexia, or hyperreflexia 
are neurological manifestations of the disease.
Diagnosis
Biochemical abnormalities of holocarboxylase synthetase deficiency 
are analogous to those described for patients with biotinidase de-
ficiency (see also ‘Biotinidase deficiency’). Importantly, plasma 
biotin is normal in holocarboxylase synthetase deficiency as is 
serum biotinidase activity. Holocarboxylase synthetase is charac-
terized by deficient activities of carboxylases in peripheral blood 
leucocytes prior to biotin administration; the activities of these 
enzymes increase to near-​normal or normal values after biotin 
treatment. Indirect confirmation of holocarboxylase synthetase de-
ficiency and differentiation from biotinidase deficiency is feasible 
by measurement of activities of the mitochondrial carboxylases in 
skin fibroblasts showing residual activity of 0 to 30% when incu-
bated in low-​biotin (10−10 mol/​litre) medium and an increase, some-
times to normal values in biotin-​supplemented medium (10−6–​10−5 
mol/​litre). In biotinidase deficiency, the activity of mitochondrial 
carboxylases in fibroblasts is normalized even under low-​biotin 
conditions. Definite diagnosis of holocarboxylase synthetase de-
ficiency is not routinely available. Prenatal diagnosis is feasible ei-
ther by demonstrating decreased carboxylase activities in cultured 
amniocytes or by demonstration of elevated 3-​hydroxyisovaleric 
acid and/​or methylcitrate in amniotic fluid. Prenatal molecular 
diagnosis can be offered in families with previously known disease-​
causing mutations in the HLCS gene.
Treatment and outcome
Holocarboxylase synthetase deficiency can be treated effectively 
with pharmacological doses of biotin. The required dose of biotin 
is dependent on the severity of the enzyme defect and has to be 
(a)
(b)
Fig. 12.2.9  Two T2-​weighted images of a 7-​month-​old boy with biotinidase deficiency. (a) The image displays absence of 
normal myelin signal in the cerebellum as well as hyperintense signal in both pyramidal tracts. (b) The image shows absence 
of normal myelin signal, cerebral atrophy, and symmetrical hyperintense lesions of both thalami.
Courtesy of Dr. T. Bast, Department of Pediatric Neurology, University of Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany.


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1967
assessed individually. In most patients, 10 to 20 mg of biotin per 
day is sufficient, but some need higher doses, that is, 40 to 100 mg/​
day. In spite of apparently complete recovery, biochemical and clin-
ical abnormalities persist in some patients owing to the high Km for 
biotin in the defective holocarboxylase synthetase. In case of acute 
decompensation, treatment according to the emergency protocol in 
organic acidurias (see ‘Emergency treatment’) has to start without 
delay. It is unclear whether prenatal treatment with biotin is bene-
ficial. The prognosis is good if treatment is initiated immediately, 
except for affected individuals with Km variants.
Other organic acidurias
d-​2-​Hydroxyglutaric aciduria type I and II
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
d-​2-​Hydroxyglutaric aciduria is an aetiologically heterogeneous 
cerebral organic acid disorder first described by Chalmers and col-
leagues in 1980. d-​2-​Hydroxyglutaric aciduria type I is caused by 
deficiency of d-​2-​hydroxyglutarate dehydrogenase, a mitochon-
drial enzyme converting d-​2-​hydroxyglutarate to 2-​oxoglutarate. 
Pathogenic mutations have been identified in the D2HGDH gene 
on 2p25.3. Recently, autosomal dominant germline mutations of 
the IDH2 gene located on 15q26.1 causing increased conversion of 
2-​oxoglutaric acid to d-​2-​HG using NADPH by isocitrate dehydro-
genase 2 were identified as molecular cause for d-​2-​hydroxyglutaric 
aciduria type II.  Neurodegeneration in d-​2-​hydroxyglutaric 
aciduria is explained by activation of N-​methyl-​d-​aspartate recep-
tors and inhibition of respiratory chain complexes (cytochrome c 
oxidase, ATP synthase) by d-​2-​hydroxyglutaric acid.
Clinical presentation
Patients with d-​2-​hydroxyglutaric aciduria exhibit variable pheno-
types. They have been divided into two subgroups based on clin-
ical, neuroradiological, and molecular findings. Patients with 
d-​2-​hydroxyglutaric aciduria type I are moderately affected and usu-
ally follow a mild clinical course with variable symptoms including 
learning difficulties, muscular hypotonia, and macrocephaly. Rarely 
individuals remain almost asymptomatic, that is, presenting only 
with well-​treatable oligoepilepsy or even with no neurological symp-
toms. The clinical presentation of patients with d-​2-​hydroxyglutaric 
aciduria type II is usually more severe than in patients with type 
I.  Patients present with encephalopathy of early infantile onset, 
demonstrating a combination of catastrophic epilepsy, muscular 
hypotonia, cerebral visual failure, and severe psychomotor retard-
ation. Facial dysmorphism, macrocephaly, and cardiomyopathy 
may also be present. Neuroimaging findings in these patients show 
ventriculomegaly, enlarged subarachnoid spaces, subdural effusions, 
subependymal cysts, and delayed cerebral maturation (Fig. 12.2.10). 
Recently, agenesis of the corpus callosum, bilateral involvement of the 
striatum, and cerebral artery infarctions were added to the spectrum.
Diagnosis
The biochemical hallmark of this disease is the accumulation of 
d-​2-​hydroxyglutaric acid in all body fluids. Type I patients excrete 
lower concentrations of d-​2-​hydroxyglutarate than type II patients. 
Demonstration of elevated levels of 2-​hydroxyglutaric acid must be 
followed up by differential quantitation of the two isomers l-​ and d-​
2-​hydroxyglutaric acid. 2-​Oxoglutaric acid and other tricarboxylic 
acid cycle intermediates are usually also elevated in urine. γ-​
Aminobutyric acid (GABA) and total protein concentrations may 
be elevated in cerebrospinal fluid. d-​2-​Hydroxyglutaric acid can also 
be elevated in multiple acyl-​CoA dehydrogenase deficiency, succinic 
semialdehyde dehydrogenase deficiency, and following bacterial 
overgrowth of the urine specimen. However, due to characteristic 
additional parameters these differential diagnoses are usually easy to 
exclude. Prenatal diagnosis can be performed either through genetic 
testing or by metabolite determination in amniotic fluid by stable 
isotope dilution GC/​MS assay.
Treatment and outcome
No specific therapy exists to date. Long-​term care of patients should 
entail regular evaluation of cardiomyopathy and the progression of 
neurological disease. The prognosis of d-​2-​hydroxyglutaric aciduria 
is extremely variable. Severely affected children may die in infancy, 
while moderately affected patients have a better prognosis up to an 
unimpaired life.
l-​2-​Hydroxyglutaric aciduria
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
l-​2-​Hydroxyglutaric aciduria is a rare, autosomal recessively in-
herited cerebral disorder. The disease is caused by deficiency of the 
flavin adenine dinucleotide-​dependent mitochondrial enzyme l-​2-​
hydroxyglutarate dehydrogenase converting l-​2-​hydroxyglutarate 
to 2-​oxoglutarate. This enzyme is encoded by the L2HGDH gene on 
14q22.1. The pathophysiology of this disease is unknown.
Clinical presentation
l-​2-​Hydroxyglutaric aciduria was first described by Duran and 
coworkers in 1980. It is characterized by progressive loss of 
Fig. 12.2.10  Axial T1-​weighted spin echo image of a 2-​month-​old girl 
with d-​2-​hydroxyglutaric aciduria type II. The lateral ventricles are highly 
dilated, occipital more than frontal, the cerebral maturation is delayed.
Reproduced with permission from Kölker et al. 2002.


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1968
myelinated arcuate fibres and a spongiform encephalopathy. In the 
first 2 years of life, mental and psychomotor development may be 
normal or slightly delayed. Febrile seizures, nonspecific develop-
mental delay, and muscular hypotonia are the presenting symptoms. 
Progressive ataxia, variable extrapyramidal and pyramidal signs, 
epilepsy, and progressive learning difficulties eventually develop. By 
adolescence, patients are usually bedridden and severely mentally 
disabled (IQ 40–​50). Two patients have developed cerebral tumours.
Two patients presented at birth with depressed vital signs, severe 
epileptic encephalopathy, and an abnormal CT scan showing cere-
bellar involvement; however, the disease course is usually slowly 
progressive without metabolic decompensation.
The neuroimaging findings in l-​2-​hydroxyglutaric aciduria are 
unique and mostly uniform comprising a progressive loss of arcuate 
fibres combined with progressive cerebellar atrophy and signal 
changes in globus pallidus and the dentate nuclei (Fig. 12.2.11).
Diagnosis
l-​2-​hydroxyglutaric aciduria results in a rather homogeneous clin-
ical picture and characteristic abnormalities on neuroimaging. 
Clinical or neuroradiological suspicion should prompt GC/​MS 
analysis of urinary organic acids followed by differentiation of l-​
2-​ and d-​2-​stereoisomers. Lysine is often increased both in plasma 
and cerebrospinal fluid. Prenatal diagnosis is based on the analysis 
of l-​2-​hydroxyglutaric acid in amniotic fluid samples or molecular 
analysis.
Treatment and outcome
No specific therapy exists to date. Epilepsy can generally be controlled 
by antiepileptic medications. Patients with l-​2-​hydroxyglutaric 
aciduria can be expected to reach adult life. The oldest known pa-
tients are close to 40 years of age, bedridden, and severely disabled.
Combined d-​2-​ and l-​2-​hydroxyglutaric aciduria
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
The molecular basis of combined d-​2-​ and l-​2-​hydroxyglutaric 
aciduria has recently been unravelled. The disease is caused by 
homozygous or compound heterozygous mutations in the SLC25A1 
gene (gene locus 22q11.21) resulting in a dysfunction of the mito-
chondrial citrate carrier and thus in impaired mitochondrial citrate 
efflux.
Clinical presentation
In a similar manner to patients with d-​2-​hydroxyglutaric aciduria 
type II, patients with the combined d-​2-​ and l-​2-​hydroxyglutaric 
aciduria usually present with a severe clinical manifestation in the 
newborn period. This includes epileptic encephalopathy, mus-
cular hypotonia, respiratory insufficiency, extrapyramidal move-
ment disorders, cortical visual failure, microcephaly, and severe 
developmental delay. Agenesis of corpus callosum and optic nerve 
hypoplasia may be present. Otherwise, brain MRI may be similar to 
patients with d-​2-​hydroxyglutaric aciduria type II.
Diagnosis
Clinical and neuroradiological suspicion should prompt GC/​MS 
analysis of urinary organic acids and differentiation of l-​2-​ and d-​2-​
stereoisomers. The diagnosis can be confirmed by molecular genetic 
analysis.
Treatment and outcome
Treatment is symptomatic. Patients with a severe onset and intract-
able epileptic seizures have a poor prognosis: eight of twelve recently 
reported cases died between 1 month and 5 years of age.
N-​Acetylaspartic aciduria (Canavan’s disease)
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
N-​Acetylaspartic aciduria is a devastating infantile neuro­
degenerative disorder. In 1931, a child with spongy matter 
(a)
(b)
Fig. 12.2.11  (a) Axial T2-​weighted spin echo image of an 8½-​year-​
old boy with l-​2-​hydroxyglutaric aciduria. Subcortical white matter is 
severely deficient with much less involvement of the internal capsule 
and the periventricular white matter. Please note signal changes in the 
putamen. (b) Axial T2-​weighted spin echo image of an 8½-​year-​old boy 
with l-​2-​hydroxyglutaric aciduria. Please note hyperintense lesions in 
both dentate nuclei.
(a) Reproduced with permission from Kölker et al. 2002.


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1969
degeneration was described by Canavan. In 1986, it was rec-
ognized that N-​acetylaspartic aciduria was caused by deficient 
aspartoacylase in a child with a similar clinical presentation. 
In 1988, aspartoacylase deficiency was definitely linked to 
Canavan’s disease.
Canavan’s disease is found in all ethnic populations but re-
veals a much higher frequency in Ashkenazi Jews (1 in 5000 to 1 
in 14 000 newborns). The frequent missense mutation p.E285A in 
the aspartoacylase gene, localized on 17p13-​pter, accounts for more 
than 80% of alleles in Ashkenazi Jews and for 60% of alleles in pa-
tients of non-​Jewish origin. In healthy individuals, high concen-
trations of N-​acetylaspartic acid (8 mmol/​g tissue) are exclusively 
found in brain tissue.
Aspartoacylase is localized in oligodendrocytes catalysing the 
deacetylation of N-​acetylaspartic acid to produce acetate, a substrate 
for the synthesis of myelin lipids including cholesterol. It has been 
proposed that N-​acetyl-​l-​aspartate may function as a molecular 
water pump in myelinated neurons, transporting water against its 
gradient from neurons to oligodendrocytes. Thus aspartoacylase de-
ficiency may cause both accumulation of metabolic water causing 
spongiform white matter changes, and deficiency of acetyl groups 
needed for cholesterol biosynthesis, causing demyelination; both are 
characteristic of Canavan’s disease.
Clinical presentation
Canavan’s disease mostly manifests at age 2 to 4 months with delayed 
development. Hypotonia with prominent head lag, epilepsy, loss of 
previously acquired skills, as well as progressive megalencephaly are 
regularly found. Seizures and optic nerve atrophy develop during 
the second year of life. As the disease progresses, affected children 
develop pyramidal signs, and finally decerebration.
Neuroimaging reveals characteristic symmetrical leukodystrophic 
changes with loss of arcuate fibres; histology demonstrates spongi-
form degeneration, in particular of the cortex and subcortical white 
matter (Fig. 12.2.12) with less involvement in the cerebellum and 
brainstem. In infancy, changes may be subtle and misinterpreted 
as delayed myelination or periventricular leukomalacia. Variant 
Canavan’s disease has been described and partially been proven to 
be caused by the same metabolic defect.
Diagnosis
Muscular hypotonia, head lag, and progressive megalencephaly in 
infancy are the classic clinical triad of Canavan’s disease.
The identification of the accumulating N-​acetylaspartic acid by 
GC/​MS analysis and confirmation of the suspected diagnosis by en-
zyme analysis (skin fibroblasts) or mutation analysis has obviated 
the need for brain biopsy for the diagnosis of Canavan’s disease.
Prenatal diagnosis is possible by quantitative GC/​MS analysis of 
N-​acetylaspartic acid in amniotic fluid or by mutation analysis. In 
contrast, enzyme activity is unsuitable for reliable prenatal diagnosis.
Treatment and outcome
Management is symptomatic (antiepileptics) and palliative. Special 
care is needed to prevent recurrent aspirations. Many patients need 
tube or gastrostomy feeding. Dietary therapies have not been shown 
to be beneficial and are potentially harmful. A promising protocol 
for gene therapy was published in 2002 involving the transfer of 
human aspartoacylase cDNA intraventricularly; however, the 
clinical changes were not pronounced and were relatively tran-
sient. The prognosis of infantile Canavan’s disease is rapidly fatal, 
whereas milder disease has been described with survival beyond the 
teenage years.
Ethylmalonic encephalopathy
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
Ethylmalonic encephalopathy is a devastating, infantile, autosomal 
recessive neurometabolic disorder affecting the brain, gastrointes-
tinal tract, and peripheral veins. The underlying metabolic defect was 
identified in a β-​lactamase-​like, iron-​coordinating metalloprotein 
of the mitochondrial matrix encoded by the ETHE1 gene. Only re-
cently, it was elucidated using Ethe1-​deficient mice that the deficient 
protein is a mitochondrial sulphur dioxygenase which is involved 
in the catabolism of sulphide in ethylmalonic encephalopathy. As 
a consequence, toxic levels of sulphide and thiosulphide are found 
causing powerful inhibition of cytochrome c oxidase, short-​chain 
fatty acid oxidation, and exerting vasoactive and vasotoxic effects. 
This explains deficient mitochondrial energy metabolism, the ab-
normal accumulation short-​chain organic acids, acylglycines and 
acylcarnitines, as well as microangiopathy.
Clinical presentation
Ethylmalonic encephalopathy is characterized biochemically by 
ethylmalonic aciduria and methylsuccinic aciduria, lactic acidaemia, 
and clinically by severe psychomotor retardation, acrocyanosis, pe-
techiae, and chronic diarrhoea.
Newborns present with muscular hypotonia followed by pro-
gressive neurological deterioration, especially pyramidal dys-
function, learning difficulties, orthostatic acrocyanosis with distal 
Fig. 12.2.12  Axial fast spin echo image of a 6½-​year-​old girl with 
aspartoacylase deficiency. Note the marked discrepancy between the 
severely affected subcortical white matter and the relatively spared 
central white matter, at least frontally.
Reproduced with permission from Kölker et al. 2002.


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1970
swelling, chronic diarrhoea, and recurrent petechiae (Fig. 12.2.13). 
Haematuria is often present. MRI scans show signal changes in cere-
bellar white matter and lesions in the basal ganglia, the latter ap-
pearing suddenly.
Diagnosis
The biochemical hallmark is increased urinary excretion of 
ethylmalonic and methylsuccinic acids associated with abnormal 
excretion of C4-​ and C5-​ (n-​butyryl-​, isobutyryl-​, isovaleryl-​, and 2-​
methylbutyryl-​) acylglycines and acylcarnitines as well as intermit-
tent lactic acidosis. Since primary mitochondrial disorders are an 
important differential diagnosis, enzymatic analyses of respiratory 
chain enzymes in muscle biopsy specimen have been performed in 
some patients revealing secondary cytochrome c oxidase deficiency. 
Mutation analysis of the ETHE1 gene provides the definitive diag-
nosis including prenatal diagnosis. Increased ethylmalonate in urine 
is also found in multiple-​ and short-​chain acyl-​CoA dehydrogenase 
deficiencies, primary respiratory chain deficiencies, and Jamaican 
vomiting sickness.
Treatment and outcome
No effective treatment is known. The prognosis is poor and 
ethylmalonic encephalopathy is usually lethal in early childhood.
Defects of phenylalanine and tyrosine metabolism
Phenylketonuria
The hyperphenylalaninaemias are a group of disorders characterized 
by defective hydroxylation of phenylalanine to tyrosine resulting in 
plasma phenylalanine values above the normal fasting range of 40 
to 80 µmol/​litre. PKU was first identified by the Norwegian Asbjørn 
Følling in 1934 in several severely disabled individuals. Følling de-
termined the urinary excretion of phenylpyruvic acid which led 
to the previously used term ‘phenylpyruvic oligophrenia’. In 1947, 
Jervis localized the metabolic error as an inability to oxidize phenyl-
alanine to tyrosine. In 1953, Bickel and colleagues demonstrated 
that a phenylalanine-​restricted diet was beneficial, and was thus the 
first successful treatment of an inborn error of metabolism and one 
which led the way to early diagnosis by newborn screening and treat-
ment. The worldwide overall incidence of PKU is approximately 1 in 
10 000, with a large national and ethnic variability.
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
PKU is an autosomal recessive disorder caused by a severe defect 
of phenylalanine hydroxylase which converts phenylalanine into 
tyrosine (Fig. 12.2.14). Tetrahydrobiopterin is required as a cofactor 
and thus hyperphenylalaninaemia may also be caused by inappro-
priate generation of tetrahydrobiopterin. Through mechanisms still 
not completely understood, the excess phenylalanine is toxic to the 
central nervous system. Phenylalanine competes with the transport 
of large neutral amino acids through the blood–​brain barrier using 
the sodium-​independent system L and induces cerebral depletion 
of these amino acids and, subsequently, reduced synthesis of pro-
teins and neurotransmitters (large neutral amino acid hypothesis of 
PKU). In addition, phenylalanine competes with glycine and glu-
tamate at their binding sites in N-​methyl-​d-​aspartate and α-​amino-​
3-​hydroxy-​5-​methyl-​4-​isoxazolepropionic acid receptors, thus 
impairing glutamate signalling and, subsequently, synapse forma-
tion and cognitive function. Furthermore, phenylalanine inhibits 
the rate-​limiting enzyme of cholesterol biosynthesis, 3-​hydroxy-​3-​
methylglutaryl-​CoA reductase, and switches forebrain oligodendro-
cytes to a nonmyelinating state.
Clinical presentation
Untreated, PKU almost invariably causes severe learning difficulties. 
Newborns with PKU are asymptomatic since fetal phenylalanine is 
metabolized by the mother’s liver. On regular intake of natural pro-
tein, phenylalanine levels quickly rise. Constitutional abnormal-
ities (80–​100% of patients) such as hypopigmentation of the skin 
and hair (fair) and iris (blue) develop rapidly because synthesis of 
Fig. 12.2.13  Patient with ethylmalonic encephalopathy.
Phenylalanine
Phenyl
pyruvate
BH4
BH2
4*
3*
BH4
BH2
3*
5*
6*
BH4
BH2
3*
5OH
Tryptophan
5-Hydroxytryptamine
7*
Tryptophan
1*
2*
Tyrosine
Dihydroxyphenylalanine
Dopamine
Noradrenaline
Adrenaline
Phenylacetate
Phenylacetylglutamine
p-Hydroxyphenyl
pyruvate
Homogentisate
Maleylacetoacetate
Fumarylacetoacetate
Fumarate
+
acetoacetate
Fig. 12.2.14  The metabolism of phenylalanine and tyrosine and the 
role of tetrahydrobiopterin. The asterisked enzymes are 1, phenylalanine 
hydroxylase; 2, tyrosine hydroxylase; 3, dihydrobiopterin reductase; 
4, tyrosine aminotransferase; 5, homogentisic acid oxidase; 6, fumaryl 
acetoacetate hydrolyase; and 7, tryptophan hydroxylase.


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1971
melanin from tyrosine is impaired. Elevated phenylacetate excretion 
gives the urine an odour reminiscent of mice and can cause an ec-
zematous skin eruption.
Delayed psychomotor development may become evident from 
the third month of life. It has been estimated that one IQ point is 
lost for each week of delay in diagnosis and treatment. Cognitive 
function is severely compromised in untreated children (IQ 
<40). Microcephaly and movement disorders are frequent, as are 
hyperexcitability as well as hypoexcitability and seizures; some pa-
tients develop autistic behaviour or aggressiveness. Most patients 
with untreated PKU cannot be managed by their families and re-
quire institutional care.
Diagnosis
In many countries, newborns are screened for increased phenyl-
alanine levels in dried blood spots during the first days of life (new-
born screening). Originally, newborn screening of phenylalanine 
was performed by a bacterial inhibition assay (Guthrie test). The 
implementation of MS/​MS techniques has, however, significantly 
improved the early identification of affected individuals by new-
born screening. Confirmation of a positive screening result is per-
formed by quantitative amino acid analysis and mutation analysis. 
Liver biopsy and subsequent determination of the hepatic activity of 
phenylalanine hydroxylase is not indicated.
Defects in the metabolism of tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4), the 
cofactor of phenylalanine hydroxylase, have to be differentiated 
from classic PKU by urinary pterin analysis and enzyme ana-
lysis of dihydropteridine reductase in dried blood spots. In many 
centres, an oral dose of 20 mg/​kg BH4 is administered. To per-
form this test accurately, the initial plasma phenylalanine con-
centration should be greater than 400 µmol/​litre (6.7 mg/​dl). 
Following BH4 administration, plasma samples are collected for 
phenylalanine and tyrosine analysis at defined time points as well 
as urine samples for pterin analysis. Notably, BH4 normalizes 
phenylalanine concentrations in patients with a primary disorder 
of BH4 (see ‘Defects of biopterin metabolism’). This test has the 
advantage that it may also identify BH4-​responsive individuals 
with PKU.
Treatment and outcome
The most important therapeutic intervention in PKU is 
phenylalanine-​restricted dietary treatment. Regular phenylalanine 
determinations are used for monitoring. Unfortunately, recom-
mendations for PKU treatment differ considerably with regard to 
cut-​off levels to begin dietary treatment, age-​dependent recom-
mendations for phenylalanine concentrations, frequency of clinical 
examinations, and phenylalanine monitoring (Table 12.2.4). There 
is no rational explanation for this.
The concept of dietary treatment has four components: (1) com-
plete avoidance of food containing abundant phenylalanine (e.g. 
meat, fish, milk, etc.); (2) calculated intake of natural food with a 
low phenylalanine/​protein ratio (e.g. vegetables and fruit) and low-​
protein products; (3)  adequate intake of energy substrates; and 
(4) calculated intake of phenylalanine-​free amino acid supplements, 
vitamins, minerals, and trace elements. During catabolic states 
phenylalanine concentrations may increase, which is counteracted 
by dietary reduction of phenylalanine intake. In contrast, during 
growth spurts in childhood and adolescence the requirement for 
phenylalanine may transiently increase.
When a very strict diet is begun early and is well maintained, 
affected children can expect normal development. Regression of 
IQ and development of neurological symptoms when diets were 
stopped in later childhood have led to continuation of dietary treat-
ment into the teenage years and adulthood. Patients generally have 
not suffered when the diet was stopped at or after 15 or 16 years of 
age. However, there is no follow-​up with respect to IQ change of 
a substantial number who have been off diet for 20 years or more. 
Most recommendations and centres have adopted a philosophy of 
‘diet for life’. However, the urgent need for more detailed informa-
tion remains.
Maternal PKU
In 1980, Lenke and Levy reported the severe effects of maternal 
hyperphenylalaninaemia in the fetus (Table 12.2.5). The clinical 
features are similar to the fetal alcohol syndrome, and the severity 
of manifestations depends on the maternal phenylalanine level. In 
addition to learning difficulties and behavioural disorders, the ad-
verse effects include malformations such as cardiac defects (usu-
ally conotruncal), microcephaly, dysmorphic features, intrauterine 
growth retardation, neuronal migration disorders, and agenesis of 
the corpus callosum.
Treatment and outcome
Because of active placental transport, the ratio of fetal to maternal 
phenylalanine plasma levels is 1.5 to 1.7. Maternal phenylalanine 
values should be between 120 and 360 µmol/​litre, which requires a 
strict diet and very careful monitoring twice weekly. Microcephaly 
and congenital heart disease in the offspring of mothers returning 
to diet at the seventh or eighth week emphasizes the need for pre-
conception diet and training. Lowering maternal plasma phenyl-
alanine concentrations during pregnancy to a level between 120 and 
360 µmol/​litre results in a favourable outcome in virtually all cases.
Defects of biopterin metabolism
In the hydroxylation of phenylalanine, the cofactor BH4 is con-
sumed and must be regenerated. BH4 is formed in a three-​step 
pathway from guanosine triphosphate. The first and rate-​limiting 
reaction is catalysed by guanosine triphosphate cyclohydrolase and 
leads to the production of dihydroneopterin triphosphate. A defi-
ciency of BH4 does not only impair phenylalanine hydroxylase in 
the liver, resulting in hyperphenylalaninaemia, but also tyrosine 
hydroxylase, tryptophan hydroxylase, as well as nitric oxide syn-
thases (Fig. 12.2.15). Tyrosine hydroxylation is needed for the 
synthesis of noradrenaline and dopamine, and tryptophan hydrox-
ylation for the production of serotonin. BH4 is therefore crucial to 
the production of neurotransmitters. The supply of this coenzyme is 
impaired in five recessively inherited enzyme defects. Most produce 
hyperphenylalaninaemia, which may not be marked. All but pterin-​
4α-​carbinolamine dehydratase deficiency cause progressive neuro-
logical disease. In less than 1% of newborns a raised phenylalanine 
value detected by newborn screening is due to a defect of biopterin 
metabolism.
The enzyme defects lead to reduced levels of BH4 within the cen-
tral nervous system without significantly affecting phenylalanine 
metabolism in the liver (normal plasma phenylalanine). However, 


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1972
Table 12.2.4  Guidelines for treatment and monitoring of PKU: international comparison
Germany 1999
UK 1993
USA 2014
Indication for dietary treatment
>600 µmol/​litre
>400 µmol/​litre
>360 µmol/​litre
Start of dietary treatment
As soon as possible
≤ day 20 of life
≤ day 7 of life
Recommendations for phenylalanine levels and frequency of phenylalanine monitoring
Germany 1999
UK 1993
USA 2014
Age
Germany 1999
UK 1993
USA 2014
40–​240 µmol/​litre
(0.7–​4 mg/​dl)
120–​360 µmol/​litre
(2–​6 mg/​dl)
120–​360 µmol/​litre
(2–​6 mg/​dl)
0
2–​4×/​month
4×/​month
4×/​month
1
1–​2×/​month
2×/​month
2
3
4
5
2×/​month
School age:
6
120–​480 µmol/​litre
(2–​8 mg/​dl)
7
8
9
40–​900 µmol/​litre (0.7–​15 mg/​dl)
10
1×/​month
1×/​month
11
Adolescence and adulthood
Adolescence and adulthood
12
120–​700 µmol/​litre
(2–​11.7 mg/​dl)
120–​360 µmol/​litre
(2–​6 mg/​dl)
13
1×/​month
14
15
40–​1200 µmol/​litre
(0.7–​20 mg/​dl)
16
4–​6 ×/​year
17
120–​360 µmol/​litre
(2–​6 mg/​dl)
18+
Recommendations for clinical monitoring
Germany 1999
Germany 2004
UK 1993
USA 2000
Dietary training
Amino acid profile
Nutrition
No details
Anthropometric data
Blood count
Growth
Health status
Minerals, trace elements
General health status
Neurological status
Calcium and phosphorus metabolism
Psychological development
Enzymes: AP, GOT, GPT
Vitamins and serum lipid status


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1973
turnover of serotonin and the catecholamines in the brain can still 
become severely compromised. Fasting plasma phenylalanine levels 
are always normal in the dominantly inherited guanosine triphos-
phate cyclohydrolase deficiency (Segawa’s disease) and the auto-
somal recessive sepiapterin reductase deficiency.
Clinical presentation
Except for pterin-​4α-​carbinolamine dehydratase (PCBD1) defi-
ciency, autosomal recessive defects of biopterin metabolism re-
sult in severe encephalopathies. Common but variable symptoms 
are progressive learning difficulties, dystonia, chorea, oculogyric 
crises, convulsions, tremor, spasticity, microcephaly, growth re-
tardation, swallowing difficulties, and depressive and aggressive be-
haviour. Diurnal variation is often present. Onset of symptoms is 
in the first months of life with hypotonia; sometimes affected new-
borns have difficulties in postnatal adaptation. Signs of autonomic 
dysfunction include hypersalivation, temperature instability, leth-
argy, hypersomnolence, and episodes of sweating and pallor. Less 
frequently reported are ‘bulbar’ signs (drooling, dysarthria, ab-
normal tongue movements), ‘ataxia’, probably not cerebellar ataxia 
or sensory ataxia but dystonic gait, and Gower’s sign. PCBD1 is 
a bifunctional protein that acts as an enzyme in the regeneration 
of BH4 and as a dimerization cofactor of the transcription factors 
HNF1A and HNF1B, which are important in liver, pancreas, and 
kidney development and function. Mutations in PCBD1 have re-
cently been reported to cause early-​onset nonautoimmune diabetes 
mellitus highlighting that PCBD1 activity is required for early pan-
creatic development. In addition, adult patients with PCBD1 defi-
ciency and hypomagnesaemia due to renal magnesium wasting have 
been identified demonstrating that PCBD1 also plays an important 
role in the kidney, in particular in the distal convoluted tubule.
In later infancy and childhood, defects in the metabolism of the 
biogenic monoamines may be suspected in patients with (fluc-
tuating) extrapyramidal disorders, in particular parkinsonism 
dystonia or more general ‘athetoid cerebral palsy’, and vegetative 
disturbances. A  severe epileptic encephalopathy and progressive 
learning difficulties may be present.
Diagnosis
Every infant with hyperphenylalaninaemia detected in a population 
newborn screening programme or in the course of other diagnos-
tics later in life must be carefully investigated for possible defects of 
biopterin metabolism (see also ‘Phenylketonuria’). Differential diag-
nosis requires the analysis of pterins in urine or from Guthrie cards 
as well as the determination of enzyme activity of dihydropteridine 
reductase in dried blood spots. If the initial plasma phenylalanine 
concentration is above 400 µmol/​litre (6.7 mg/​dl), oral loading with 
BH4 (20 mg/​kg) will result in normalization of phenylalanine values 
within 4 to 8 h. Urinary biopterin and neopterin values are low in 
the guanosine triphosphate cyclohydrolase deficiency, whereas 6-​
pyruvoyltetrahydrobiopterin synthase deficiency has high neopterin 
values and low biopterin values. In patients with dihydropteridine 
reductase deficiency, neopterin is normal or slightly elevated and 
biopterin very high. After the biochemical diagnosis, all defects 
should be ascertained enzymatically and, if available, by mutation 
analysis. Following a diagnosis of a defect of biopterin metabolism, a 
lumbar puncture becomes necessary for analysis of the neurotrans-
mitter metabolites 5-​hydroxyindoleacetic acid and homovanillic 
acid as well as neopterin, biopterin, and 5-​methyltetrahydrofolic 
acid. This allows differentiation between severe and mild forms 
of BH4 deficiencies and sets the indication for treatment with the 
neurotransmitter precursors l-​dopa and 5-​hydroxytryptophan. 
In patients with suggestive encephalopathies and normal phenyl-
alanine values, analysis of neurotransmitters in cerebrospinal fluid 
is the only way of diagnosis.
Treatment and outcome
Blood phenylalanine concentrations should be more rigidly con-
trolled than in classic PKU patients. In patients with guan­osine triphos-
phate cyclohydrolase deficiency and 6-​pyruvoyl­tetrahydrobiopterin 
deficiency, administration of BH4 appears to be the most efficient 
therapy in controlling blood phenylalanine levels. Patients with 
dihydropteridine reductase deficiency need a low-​phenylalanine 
diet as in PKU.
Deficiency of neurotransmitters requires treatment with the 
neurotransmitter precursors l-​dopa (3–​15 mg/​kg per day) and 
5-​hydroxytryptophan (2–​9 mg/​kg per day) in combination with 
carbidopa (10 or 25% of l-​dopa). Lumbar punctures must be repeated 
regularly to adjust doses. In patients revealing l-​dopa-​induced peak-​
dose dyskinesia slow-​release forms of drugs can be used, and reaching 
the upper therapeutic limits of l-​dopa may be an indication for the 
use of monoamine oxidase and/​or catechol-​O-​methyltransferase 
Table 12.2.5  Incidences (%) of abnormalities in the offspring 
of mothers affected with classical PKU
Congenital abnormalities
Maternal PKU
Unaffected mothers
Mental disability
92
5
Microcephaly
73
4.8
Intrauterine retardation
40
9.6
Congenital heart defects
12
0.8
Source data from Lenke R, Levy HL (1980). Maternal PKU and hyperphenylalaninemia: 
an international study of treated and untreated pregnancies. N Engl J Med, 303, 1202–​8.
GTP
BH4
PTPS
Neopterin
SR
BH2
Biopterin
PAH,
TYH,
TPH,
NOS
PCD
DHPR
GTPCH
Fig. 12.2.15  Biopterin metabolism. BH4 is synthesized and regenerated 
by five enzymes. BH4 is consumed as a cofactor in the hydroxylation 
of tyrosine and tryptophan as well as phenylalanine (see also PKU) and 
nitric oxide synthase (NOS). BH2, dihydrobiopterin. Relevant enzyme 
defects: DHPR, dihydropteridine reductase; GTPCH, GTP cyclohydrolase; 
PCD, pterin carbinolamine dehydratase; PTPS, 6-​pyruvoyl-​
tetrahydropterin synthase; SR, sepiapterin reductase.
Source data from Zschocke J, Hoffmann GF (2011). Vademecum metabolicum. 
Manual of metabolic paediatrics, 3rd edition. Schattauer, Stuttgart.


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1974
inhibitors. Patients with dihydropteridine reductase deficiency, in 
addition, need administration of folinic acid to restore normal cere-
brospinal fluid folate concentrations.
Normal long-​term psychomotor development can be achieved 
but outcome strongly depends on the age when the diagnosis is 
made and how rigidly therapy is followed, especially in early life.
Dominantly inherited guanosine triphosphate 
cyclohydrolase deficiency
Clinical presentation
Dominantly inherited guanosine triphosphate cyclohydrolase 
deficiency, often called Segawa’s disease, is an eminently treat-
able condition. Early recognition is therefore of crucial import-
ance. Presentation in children usually occurs within the first 
decade of life with a mean age of onset of symptoms being about 
7 years (range 16 months to 13 years). The first symptom is usu-
ally postural dystonia of one leg with progression to all limbs 
followed by action dystonia and hand tremor within the next 
10 to 15 years, during which time cognition remains intact. 
Occasionally, in older children, the first signs may start in the 
arms with torticollis or writer’s cramp (focal dystonia). The dys-
tonia is frequently asymmetrical and accompanied by reduced 
facial expression or slowing of fine finger movements. Diurnal 
fluctuation is often present, with symptoms improving after night-​
time sleep or bed rest. The variation in presenting symptoms is 
large. Penetrance is reduced and many carriers of a mutant gene 
are asymptomatic.
Diagnosis
In classic cases with prominent dystonia of the lower limbs, marked 
diurnal variation, as well as worsening of the symptoms after ex-
ercise, the clinical diagnosis of the deficiency is easily made, in 
particular in the presence of dramatic and sustained response to 
l-​dopa. However, the diagnosis can be a real challenge in atypical 
cases, in which it can be ascertained by determining BH4, and de-
creased levels of neopterin and homovanillic acid in cerebrospinal 
fluid. Confirmation of the diagnosis can be achieved by enzyme ana-
lysis in cultured skin fibroblasts or by mutation analysis.
Treatment and outcome
Treatment relies on l-​dopa in combination with 10 to 25% carbidopa. 
Amounts administered have varied between 3 and 10 mg/​kg per day 
divided into one to four doses with the effectiveness of treatment 
being monitored by the clinical outcome. The long-​term prognosis 
is usually excellent.
Tyrosinaemias
The steps in tyrosine metabolism starting with the rate-​limiting 
step—​the conversion to p-​hydroxyphenylpyruvic acid by tyrosine 
aminotransferase—​are outlined in Fig. 12.2.14. Intermediates of 
this tyrosine metabolism are used for production of catecholamines, 
dopamine, and the principal pigment of hair and skin, melanin.
Tyrosinaemia type I (fumarylacetoacetase deficiency)
Clinical presentation  Tyrosinaemia type I is also known as 
hepatorenal tyrosinosis. About one-​third of patients present 
acutely in the early weeks of life with failure to thrive, vomiting, 
hepatomegaly, fever, oedema, and epistaxis; by the end of the first 
year of life 90% have developed symptoms. The disease can progress 
rapidly and death from hepatic failure often occurs in infancy.
A milder more chronic presentation is compatible with survival 
for several years with chronic liver disease, a renal tubular Fanconi’s 
syndrome with hypophosphataemic rickets, and episodic abdom-
inal pain and neuropathy suggestive of acute porphyria. The most 
serious complication is hepatocellular carcinoma which develops in 
early childhood in one-​third of untreated patients.
Diagnosis  Raised plasma tyrosine (often together with methio-
nine), succinylacetone, and 5-​aminolaevulinic acid excretion as 
well as renal Fanconi’s syndrome are the biochemical markers of 
tyrosinaemia type I caused by a deficiency of fumarylacetoacetate 
hydrolyase, the last enzyme in the pathway of tyrosine degradation 
(Fig. 12.2.14). Serum α-​fetoprotein is usually strikingly elevated. 
Succinylacetone, formed from fumarylacetoacetate, is the most spe-
cific diagnostic metabolite. Plasma tyrosine values may be normal, 
resulting in insufficient specificity of this parameter for newborn 
screening.
Fumarylacetoacetate hydrolyase can be assayed in lymphocytes 
or fibroblasts. It is nonspecifically depressed in the liver in a var-
iety of liver diseases. The measurement of succinylacetone in amni-
otic fluid and activity of fumarylacetoacetate hydrolyase in cultured 
amniocytes or chorionic villus samples forms the basis of prenatal 
diagnosis, if informative mutations are not available.
Treatment and outcome  Restricted intake of tyrosine and phenyl-
alanine may reduce the excretion of succinylacetone and produce 
regression of the Fanconi tubular defects, but does not cure the liver 
disease. The risk of hepatocellular carcinoma remains and early 
liver transplantation was the treatment of choice until nitisinone 
(2-​(2-​nitro-​4-​trifluoromethylbenzoyl)1–​3-​cyclohexanedione) was 
introduced by Lindstedt and colleagues in 1991. Nitisinone almost 
completely blocks 4-​hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase thus 
turning tyrosinaemia type I into tyrosinaemia type III and redu-
cing the production of toxic metabolites. Treatment with nitisinone 
should start as soon as the diagnosis is made with a dose of 1 mg/​
kg per day. In most patients there is a rapid improvement in liver 
and renal function; succinylacetone should disappear from the urine 
within 1 week of treatment. Patients need to be treated with a diet 
low in phenylalanine and tyrosine at the same time as introducing 
nitisinone. Plasma levels of tyrosine should be kept between 250 and 
500 µmol/​litre.
The long-​term results of nitisinone treatment are encouraging 
with greatly reduced incidence of liver damage and hepatic car-
cinoma. Liver transplantation remains the treatment of choice for 
a few patients who do not respond to nitisinone and if there is any 
suggestion of malignant change.
Tyrosinaemia type II (tyrosine aminotransferase deficiency)
Clinical presentation  Corneal erosions and dendritic ulcers may 
form within a few months of birth with later scarring, nystagmus, 
and glaucoma. Skin lesions may begin after the eye lesions with blis-
tering, painful palms and soles, and hyperkeratosis. Tongue changes 
have been described. Learning difficulties are an inconstant feature 
in about 50% of patients, but language defects may be more common 
with possible impaired coordination and self-​mutilation.


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1975
Diagnosis  Tyrosine aminotransferase, which is deficient, cata-
lyses the formation of p-​hydroxyphenylpyruvic acid (Fig. 12.2.14). 
Plasma tyrosine values reach 20 times normal (normal 40–​100 µmol/​
litre) in younger patients and 10 times normal in others. There is 
increased excretion of tyrosine, N-​acetyltyrosine, tyramine, and of 
phenolic acids; there is no Fanconi’s syndrome and no increase in 
succinylacetone.
The clinical features and amino acid analyses are usually sufficient 
for diagnosis, which may be confirmed either by measuring the en-
zyme activity in liver or by molecular genetic studies.
Treatment and outcome  A low-​tyrosine, low-​phenylalanine diet 
has been used to produce rapid improvement of skin and eye mani-
festations. Corneal transplants can be valuable. The neurological 
symptoms appear to improve less. The degree of dietary control 
needed to sustain clinical improvement is uncertain. Plasma tyro-
sine concentrations less than 500 μmol/​litre are considered desirable.
Tyrosinaemia type III (4-​hydroxyphenylpyruvate  
dioxygenase deficiency)
4-​Hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase deficiency (Fig. 12.2.14) ap-
pears to be very rare and possibly without clinical pathology, that is, 
a nondisease. It may be associated with learning difficulties and pos-
sibly other neurological complications. The biochemical findings 
are similar to those in tyrosinaemia type II, but the plasma values 
of tyrosine are usually less than 1200 µmol/​litre. Enzyme and mo-
lecular genetic studies can prove the diagnosis. Most patients are 
treated with a low-​tyrosine, low-​phenylalanine diet.
Alkaptonuria
Clinical presentation
In 1902, alkaptonuria was the first disorder to be recognized as an 
inborn error of metabolism by Garrod. It is caused by a deficiency 
of homogentisate dioxygenase resulting in the accumulation of 
homogentisic acid and its oxidized derivative benzoquinone acetic 
acid. The latter can then be polymerized to form a dark pigment 
which is deposited in connective tissue. The disorder is extremely 
rare in most populations but occurs with greatly increased fre-
quency in the Dominican Republic and in Slovakia. Presentation in 
infancy occurs only if discoloration of the urine is noticed. It is usu-
ally normal when passed but darkens on standing (more rapidly at 
alkaline pH) to deep brown or almost black. Back pain begins in the 
second and third decade with increasing stiffness due to interverte-
bral disc degeneration. Involvement of the hips, knees, and shoul-
ders follows. Greyish discoloration of cartilage is seen in the pinna, 
and pigment is deposited in the sclera. Abnormal pigmentation is 
seen in the heart valves and joint cartilages, and pigmented stones 
are common in the prostate. Valvular calcification is prominent, es-
pecially in the coronary arteries. Recent studies of the natural course 
of alkaptonuria indicate that it is associated with premature heart 
disease and premature death with long-​standing impairment of 
quality of life. Pigment deposition with involvement of the fibrolipid 
components of atherosclerotic plaques cause calcific stenosis of the 
aortic valve. In 58 patients studied by Phornphutkul and colleagues 
(2002), life-​table analysis showed that joint replacement occurred 
at a mean age of 55 years, renal stones at 64 years, and cardiac valve 
involvement at 54 years; coronary calcification occurred at a mean 
age of 59 years.
Diagnosis
Homogentisic acid can be demonstrated by urinary organic acid 
analysis. Enzymatic as well as molecular confirmation is possible. 
Plasma tyrosine concentrations are normal.
Treatment and outcome
So far no treatment has been shown to prevent the long-​term com-
plications. The prognosis for the joints is poor. By the fifth decade, 
the lumbar spine is likely to be rigid and other joints will be ser-
iously affected. Patients often require large amounts of analgesic and 
risk the complications of long-​term consumption of nonsteroidal 
anti-​inflammatory agents, which may exacerbate incipient coronary 
heart disease.
Homogentisic acid can be decreased by a low-​protein diet. It is 
very probable that specifically designed low-​phenylalanine and low-​
tyrosine diets would lower the production still further. Nitisinone, 
the triketone inhibitor of 4-​hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase 
introduced by Lindstedt in 1991, greatly reduces overproduction 
of homogentisic acid in alkaptonuria. Early studies from Gahl’s 
group at the National Institutes of Health, United States of America, 
showed that in adults of both sexes with alkaptonuria, an oral dose 
of 1.05 mg twice daily reduced urinary homogentisic acid excretion 
from a mean of 4 g to 0.2 g per day. More than 220 patients with her-
editary tyrosinaemia type I have received the drug at daily doses of 
0.5 to 2.0 mg/​kg body weight and even at these doses it is generally 
well tolerated, apart from mild blood cytopenias. In alkaptonuria 
nitisinone, as predicted, may elevate the plasma tyrosine concentra-
tions (in the early trial from c.70 to 760 μmol/​litre) and there is thus 
a theoretical risk of lens opacities, which can be avoided by careful 
slit-​lamp monitoring, plasma amino acid measurement, and dietary 
adjustment. In alkaptonuria, the outcome of nitisinone treatment 
will take many years to evaluate fully, but comprehensive therapeutic 
study is justified by the clear relationship between overproduction 
of a single metabolite and life-​shortening tissue manifestations with 
disabling joint disease.
Neurotransmitter diseases and related disorders
Monogenic defects of neurotransmission have become recog-
nized as a cause of early-​onset, severe, progressive, and often treat-
able encephalopathies. The diagnosis is based on the quantitative 
determination of the neurotransmitters or their metabolites in 
cerebrospinal fluid, that is, glycine, serine, and GABA, the acidic me-
tabolites of the biogenic monoamines, and individual pterin species 
(Box 12.2.6). Determinations of metabolites in blood or urine are 
neither sensitive nor specific. In contrast to inborn errors in cata-
bolic pathways, neurotransmitter defects are determined by the 
Box 12.2.6  Cerebrospinal fluid: investigation 
for neurotransmitter disorders
	•	 Cells, protein, immunoglobulin classes, and glucose (plus plasma glu-
cose and evaluation of blood–​brain barrier)
	•	 Lactate and pyruvate
	•	 Amino acids (plus plasma obtained simultaneously)
	•	 Biogenic monoamine metabolites
	•	 Individual pterin species
	•	 5-​Methyltetrahydrofolate


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1976
interplay of biosynthesis, degradation, and receptor status. Even 
borderline abnormalities can be diagnostic and their recognition 
requires a strictly standardized sampling protocol and adequate age-​
related reference values.
Disorders of monoamine metabolism
Defects in the metabolism of the biogenic monoamines affect sero-
tonin and/​or catecholamine (dopamine and noradrenaline) metab-
olism (Fig. 12.2.16). They present from infancy or childhood with 
(fluctuating) extrapyramidal disorders, in particular parkinsonian 
dystonia or more general ‘athetoid cerebral palsy’, and vegetative 
disturbances, most noticeably hypoglycaemia. A severe epileptic en-
cephalopathy and progressive learning difficulties may be present.
Tyrosine hydroxylase deficiency
Tyrosine hydroxylase catalyses the hydroxylation of l-​tyrosine to 
l-​dopa, the rate-​limiting step in the biosynthesis of the catechol-
amines dopamine, noradrenaline, and adrenaline (Fig. 12.2.16). The 
iron-​containing mixed function oxidase requires molecular oxygen 
and the cofactor BH4. Tyrosine hydroxylase is expressed only in 
catecholaminergic neurons and the adrenal medulla.
Tyrosine hydroxylase deficiency has become incorporated into 
concepts and classifications of dystonias as the cause of reces-
sive l-​dopa-​responsive dystonia, but can also present as l-​dopa-​
nonresponsive dystonia or progressive early-​onset encephalopathy.
Clinical presentation  Clinical symptoms often develop between 
3 and 7 months of age. Most patients show a substantial clin-
ical improvement already on low doses of l-​dopa together with 
the decarboxylase inhibitor carbidopa, although in contrast to 
l-​dopa-​responsive dystonia due to haploinsufficiency of guanosine 
triphosphate cyclohydrolase I, often neither the neurological status 
nor the catecholamine levels in cerebrospinal fluid can be com-
pletely normalized in most patients.
At the severe end of the spectrum, virtually no movements are 
observed, not even dystonic movements. Some patients are more 
severely affected and present with a progressive neurometabolic 
disorder from early infancy with a progressive infantile enceph-
alopathy characterized by abnormal extrapyramidal movements 
and affecting several cerebral and possibly cerebellar systems. It is 
important to stress that such patients also show symptoms of sig-
nificant catecholamine deficiency, such as hypoglycaemia and in-
adequate stress responses. There is an obvious tendency to preterm 
birth with troublesome cardiorespiratory perinatal adaptation.
Most infants with tyrosine hydroxylase deficiency develop sur-
prisingly normally until an arrest of motor development with 
a characteristic combination of neurological symptoms later in 
infancy. Hypokinesia, marked truncal hypotonia, a mask face, 
oculogyric crises, myoclonic jerks, and an extrapyramidal tremor 
can progressively develop. The last three symptoms can be mis-
taken as epileptic phenomena. Oculogyric crises are present but, as 
with the miosis, may go undiagnosed because of prominent ptosis. 
Contractures, failure to thrive, and immobilization may develop. 
It appears likely that life expectancy is significantly reduced; (dys-
tonic) cerebral palsy is a likely descriptive (mis-​)diagnosis. Some 
patients did not develop extrapyramidal symptoms in the first 
year of life, were able to walk independently, and followed a clin-
ical course best summarized as spastic paraplegia. Their symptoms 
fully resolved following l-​dopa supplementation, and they are now 
healthy adults living independently.
5-HIAA
noradrenaline
DβH
adrenaline
PNM
3-O-methyldopa
vanillyllactic acid
COMT
DOPAC
MAO
COMT
3MT
COMT
COMT
MAO
HVA
NM
M
VMA
MHP G
ALD
MAO + aldd.
MAO + alcd.
COMT
COMT
COMT
MAO
tryptophan
tyrosine
5-OH-tryptophan
serotonin 
dopamine 
L -DOPA 
AADC + B6
TR + BH4
TH + BH4
AADC + B6
Fig. 12.2.16  Metabolism of biogenic monoamines. 5-​ HIAA, 5-​hydroxyindolacetic acid; AADC, aromatic l-​aminoacid decarboxylase; alcd., 
alcohol dehydrogenase; ALD, intermediate aldehyde (3-​methoxy-​4-​hydroxyphenyl-​ hydroxyacetaldehyde); aldd., aldehyde dehydrogenase; 
BH4, tetrahydrobiopterin; COMT, catechol-​ortho-​methyltransferase; DbH, dopamine-​b-​hydroxylase; DOPAC, 3,4-​dihydroxyphenylacetic acid; 
HVA, homovanillic acid; M, metanephrine; MAO, monoaminooxidase; MHPG, 3-​methoxy-​4-​hydroxy-​phenylglycol; MT, 3-​methoxytyramine; 
NM, normetanephrine; PNM, phenylethanolamine-​N-​methyltransferase; TH, tyrosin hydroxylase; TR, tryptophan hydroxylase; VMA, 
vanillylmandelic acid; . . ., several steps involved.


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1977
Diagnosis  The diagnosis of tyrosine hydroxylase deficiency can 
only be made via cerebrospinal fluid analysis following a stand-
ardized lumbar puncture protocol. A  characteristic metabolite 
constellation is found: low concentrations of metabolites of dopa-
minergic neurotransmission homovanillic acid and 3-​methoxy-​
4-​hydroxyphenylethyleneglycol in the presence of normal 
concentrations of metabolites belonging to the serotonin neurotrans-
mission system such as 5-​hydroxyindoleacetic acid (Fig. 12.2.16). 
Urinary determinations of catecholamines and homovanillic acid 
turned out to be inconclusive in several affected individuals.
Enzyme analysis is not possible in tyrosine hydroxylase deficiency 
because tissues expressing enzyme activity—​brain and adrenal 
medulla—​are difficult to obtain. Thus mutation analysis is the only 
way to confirm the diagnosis.
Treatment and outcome  Therapeutic interventions with l-​dopa 
together with the decarboxylase inhibitor carbidopa and selegiline 
were able to improve and/​or even normalize the clinical picture in 
most patients but not all. Despite all therapeutic interventions, the 
disease course can be lethal.
Treatment with l-​dopa has to be started slowly and carefully, with 
doses as low as 0.5 mg/​kg per day in two to six divided doses to avoid 
dyskinesias due to hypersensitivity and up-​regulation of dopamine 
receptors in dopamine-​deficient patients. In such patients, l-​dopa 
can only be increased very slowly, sometimes over several years. 
Slow-​release preparations may be useful to ensure constant l-​dopa 
levels. In general, incremental steps of l-​dopa/​carbidopa should not 
be more than 1 mg/​kg per day.
Aromatic l-​amino acid decarboxylase deficiency
Aromatic l-​amino acid decarboxylase deficiency is caused by 
autosomal recessively inherited mutations in the DDC gene. The 
enzyme is required for the synthesis of both serotonin and the 
catecholamines.
Clinical presentation  Clinical symptoms are indistinguishable 
from those of patients with tyrosine hydroxylase deficiency. The se-
verity seems to fall into two groups. About half of the patients pre-
sent with feeding difficulties, autonomic dysfunction, and hypotonia 
in the neonatal period. In the first few months of life dystonia or 
intermittent limb spasticity, axial and truncal hypotonia, extreme 
irritability, oculogyric crises, and psychomotor retardation be-
come obvious. More mildly affected patients may initially develop 
unremarkably or only slightly delayed and present with motor re-
tardation, hypokinesia, rigidity, and truncal hypotonia from early 
childhood.
Diagnosis  The enzyme deficiency leads to accumulation of 3-​
O-​methyldopa, 5-​hydroxytryptophan, and l-​dopa together with 
low concentrations of the end products homovanillic acid and 5-​
hydroxyindoleacetic acid (Fig. 12.2.16). 3-​O-​Methyldopa is formed 
by methylation of l-​dopa. Confirmation of the diagnosis is by en-
zyme assay in plasma and finally by mutation analysis.
Treatment and outcome  Different approaches using dopamine 
agonists (pergolide, pramipexole, bromocriptine, and ropinirole) 
and/​or nonselective monoamine oxidase inhibitors (tranyl­
cypromine, phenelzine) have been attempted. Response to treat-
ment is variable but outcome appears to be better in more mildly 
affected and later-​presenting patients. The overall prognosis is 
guarded. About half of the patients improve on individual treatment 
regimens and acquire different degrees of motor and psychosocial 
skills. Others do not show any improvements.
Dopamine β-​hydroxylase deficiency
Clinical presentation  Recessively inherited mutations in the dopa-
mine β-​hydroxylase gene lead to lowered levels of noradrenaline 
within central and autonomic noradrenergic neurons (Fig. 12.2.16). 
The disorder is characterized by sympathetic noradrenergic de-
nervation and adrenomedullary failure. The central consequences 
appear minimal. Syndromes become obvious in adolescence with 
noradrenergic failure, severe orthostatic hypotension, and ptosis 
of the eyelids. During childhood fatigue, episodes of fainting, syn-
copes, and exercise intolerance are generally present. Physical and 
cognitive function is normal. In males, autonomic neuropathy leads 
to retrograde ejaculation.
Diagnosis  Dopamine β-​hydroxylase deficiency is classified as a pri-
mary autonomic neuropathy. Conditions that lead to chronic failure 
of the autonomic nervous system are, therefore, the primary differ-
ential diagnosis. Biochemically, dopamine β-​hydroxylase deficiency 
is different from other conditions with orthostatic hypotension or 
autonomic dysfunction. Failure to produce noradrenaline and the 
consequent lack of end-​product inhibition of tyrosine hydroxylase 
leads to a noradrenaline/​dopamine ratio of less than 0.1, and such 
a finding is pathognomonic for the disease. An increase in blood 
pressure and correction of the orthostatic hypotension in response 
to dihydroxyphenylserine is also diagnostic. Some 3 to 4% of the 
normal adult population have near zero levels of the enzyme in 
plasma, therefore plasma enzyme determination alone cannot be 
used to confirm the diagnosis, it requires mutation analysis.
Treatment and outcome  Dopamine β-​hydroxylase deficiency 
is treated with dihydroxyphenylserine. This compound is decarb-
oxylated by l-​amino acid decarboxylase to form noradrenaline. 
Administration of 250 to 500 mg twice daily results in an increase 
in blood pressure and sustained relief of the orthostatic symptoms. 
Without appropriate treatment postural hypotension can lead to sig-
nificant injuries or even death.
Disorders of pyridoxine metabolism
In 1954, Hunt and colleagues described a patient with a seizure dis-
order that was successfully treated solely by administration of pyri-
doxine (vitamin B6) and coined the term ‘pyridoxine dependency’. 
It became good clinical practice to test for pyridoxine responsive-
ness in every child with ‘difficult-​to-​treat’ seizures starting before 
2 years of age. Later, a similar therapeutic response was described in 
the same clinical constellation for folinic acid. Finally, the enzymatic 
defect has been pinpointed to the α-​aminoadipic semialdehyde de-
hydrogenase located in the lysine degradation pathway in the brain, 
which results in the accumulation of the intermediate piperideine-​6-​
carboxylate scavenging pyridoxal phosphate. A similar pathogenic 
mechanism again leading to intractable seizures is responsible for 
pyridoxal deficiency in hyperprolinaemia type II and during treat-
ment with the tuberculostatic drug isoniazid.
Another monogenic defect in humans is directly located within the 
synthesis of pyridoxal 5′-​phosphate: pyridox(am)ine 5′-​phosphate 
oxidase deficiency resulting in pyridoxal phosphate-​responsive seiz-
ures (Fig. 12.2.17).


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1978
Each newborn with severe neonatal/​infantile epileptic enceph-
alopathy should have a lumbar puncture and then immediately 
receive consecutive therapeutic trials with vitamin B6, pyridoxal 
5′-​phosphate, and folinic acid.
Aetiology/​pathophysiology
Pyridoxine-​dependent epilepsy and folinic acid-​responsive seiz-
ures are treatable causes of neonatal epileptic encephalopathy. 
The genetic base of both conditions is autosomal recessive inher-
itance of pathogenic mutations in the ALDH7A1 (antiquitin) gene 
causing deficiency of the enzyme α-​aminoadipic semialdehyde 
dehydrogenase located in the pipecolic acid pathway, the major 
route of cerebral lysine oxidation. As a consequence of accumu-
lating α-​aminoadipic semialdehyde and the cyclic compound ∆1-​
piperideine 6-​carboxylate, which spontaneously forms an adduct 
with pyridoxal phosphate via a Knoevenagel reaction, pyridoxal 
phosphate is inactivated resulting in cerebral depletion of pyridoxal 
phosphate. Pyridoxal phosphate-​dependent enzymes such as glu-
tamate dehydrogenase, GABA transaminase and aromatic l-​amino 
acid dehydrogenase are inactivated by pyridoxal phosphate deple-
tion causing significant disturbance in the metabolism of the neuro-
transmitters dopamine, serotonin, glutamate and GABA and thus a 
severe epileptic encephalopathy. The conversion of pyridoxine, pyri-
doxal, and pyridoxamine to pyridoxal phosphate however remains 
unaffected.
Clinical presentation
Pyridoxine-​dependent epilepsy can be heterogeneous in its presen-
tation, and sometimes idiopathic epilepsies respond to treatment 
with high-​dose pyridoxine. Classical patients with pyridoxine-​
dependent epilepsy present with an intractable seizure disorder 
within the first 2 days of life, and at the latest within 28 days. In 
some patients intrauterine convulsions are reported. There is no 
consistent electrographic pattern. Continuous and discontinuous 
backgrounds, suppression burst-​like patterns, and hypsarrhythmia 
have all been observed. There are additional atypical presentations: 
(1) late onset, that is, later than 28 days; (2) neonatal onset but with an 
initial response to conventional anticonvulsant therapy; (3) neonatal 
onset with initially negative, but a later sustained positive response 
to pyridoxine.
Folinic acid-​sensitive seizures have been an enigmatic clinical and 
biochemical entity until it has been elucidated recently that they are 
alleic to pyridoxine-​dependent epilepsy. Patients present with myo-
clonic or clonic seizures, apnoea, and irritability within 5 days after 
birth. The electroencephalogram shows a discontinuous background 
pattern with multifocal spikes and sharp waves. Without specific 
treatment seizures will only be partially controlled. Psychomotor 
development will become severely impaired. It is therefore recom-
mended that all patients with ‘difficult-​to-​treat’ seizures starting be-
fore 2 years should have a trial of pyridoxine and folinic acid (usually 
given orally in this circumstance).
Diagnosis
The diagnosis of pyridoxine-​dependent epilepsy and folinic acid-​
responsive seizures should be suspected clinically in patients with 
neonatal epileptic encephalopathy or ‘difficult-​to-​treat’ seizures 
starting before 2  years of age who respond to pyridoxine and/​
or folinic acid. Because it is a treatable condition, a high index of 
suspicion is warranted. Both pyridoxine and pyridoxal phosphate 
may cause apnoea and prolonged cerebral depression after the ini-
tial dose, and resuscitation equipment and intensive care facilities 
should be available.
The suspected diagnosis can be confirmed by measurement of α-​
aminoadipic semialdehyde in body fluids. Elevated CSF and plasma 
pipecolic acid is also used as a biomarker. Furthermore, CSF analysis 
may reveal a monoamine pattern similar to l-​amino acid dehydro-
genase deficiency, elevated glutamate, and decreased GABA concen-
trations. Enzyme assay and mutation analysis of the ALDH7A1 gene 
is the most definitive proof of diagnosis.
Treatment and outcome
Treatment requires 5 to 30 mg/​kg body weight per day of pyridoxine 
in one dose. Successful treatment with folinic acid can be achieved 
with 3 to 5 mg/​kg body weight per day of folinic acid given in three 
doses. Doses need to be increased and adjusted to body weight 
during growth. Breakthrough seizures are an obvious criterion for 
increasing the dose. There is evidence that lower doses of pyridoxine 
and folinic acid, while controlling seizures, may still not prevent the 
development of cognitive impairment. High doses of pyridoxine 
carry the risk of developing skin photosensitivity as well of a per-
ipheral sensory neuropathy. Doses up to 1 g/​day can be regarded 
as safe in older children. Serial cognitive assessment is therefore 
recommended. If there is a positive family history of pyridoxine-​
dependent seizures, maternal treatment in utero is indicated.
Since pyridoxine-​dependent epilepsy and folinic acid-​sensitive 
seizures appear to be genetically and biochemically identical, this 
new understanding requires a re-​evaluation of optimal strategies 
such as the combined use of pyridoxine and folinic acid as well as of a 
low-​lysine diet aiming to reduce the accumulation of α-​aminoadipic 
semialdehyde and ∆1-​piperideine 6-​carboxylate.
Hyperprolinaemia type II: l-​Δ1-​pyrrolines-​5-​carboxylate 
dehydrogenase deficiency
Clinical presentation  For a long time hyperprolinaemia type 
I, which has no clinically relevant phenotype, was not separ-
ated from hyperprolinaemia type II. Also, as individuals with 
PK
PNPO
PNPO
PK
PK
Membrane-associated phosphatases
Cellular uptake 
PK
Pyridoxamine
Pyridoxine
Pyridoxamine-P
Pyridoxine-P
Pyridoxal-P
Pyridoxal
Intracellular pyridoxal-phosphate
Fig. 12.2.17  Pyridoxine metabolism. Pyridoxal phosphate (PALP; 
vitamin B6) is cofactor of transamination and decarboxylation reactions 
in various pathways including serotonin and dopamine biosynthesis. 
It is synthesized from dietary pyridoxal, pyridoxamine, and pyridoxine; 
enzymes involved include pyridoxal kinase (PK) and pyridox(am)ine  
5-​phosphate oxidase (PNPO).
Source data from Zschocke J, Hoffmann GF (2011). Vademecum metabolicum. 
Manual of metabolic paediatrics, 3rd edition. Schattauer, Stuttgart.


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1979
hyperprolinaemia type II often have no clinical manifestations, 
hyperprolinaemia was considered a nondisease. However, on inves-
tigation of larger cohorts of affected individuals it became obvious 
that hyperprolinaemia type II can lead to epilepsy in more than 50% 
of patients. The epilepsy usually disappears in adulthood.
Diagnosis  Plasma concentrations of proline are highly elevated, ex-
ceeding 1500 μmol/​litre. Whereas proline is the only amino acid ele-
vated in plasma and cerebrospinal fluid, glycine and hydroxyproline 
are also found elevated in urine as these three amino acids share 
a common renal tubular transport system. Hyperprolinaemia type 
II must be distinguished from hyperprolinaemia type I by demon-
stration of elevated levels of l-​Δ1-​pyrroline-​5-​carboxylate and/​or by 
enzyme assay or molecular analysis.
Treatment and outcome  Unless a seizure disorder is present, no 
specific treatment is required. In a child with a seizure disorder, 
treatment with 5 to 30 mg/​kg body weight per day of pyridoxine in 
one dose should be started. There are usually no adverse sequelae.
Pyridoxal phosphate-​responsive seizures: pyridox(am)ine  
5′-​phosphate oxidase deficiency
Clinical presentation  Pyridoxal phosphate responsive seizures due 
to pyridox(am)ine 5′-​phosphate oxidase deficiency (Fig. 12.2.17) 
result in a most severe early neonatal encephalopathy with con-
vulsions, myoclonus, rotatory eye movements, and sudden clonic 
contractions. Seizures are resistant to conventional anticonvulsant 
therapy. Many patients are born prematurely, and fetal distress is 
common, including ‘signs of asphyxia’ and low Apgar scores. Early 
(lactic) acidosis and hypoglycaemia may be observed. Thus pyri-
doxal phosphate-​responsive seizures must enter the differential 
diagnosis of hypoxic–​ischaemic encephalopathy in prematurely 
born infants.
Diagnosis  The deficiency of pyridox(am)ine 5′-​phosphate oxidase 
results in combined deficiencies of l-​amino acid decarboxylase, 
threonine dehydratase, ornithine δ-​aminotransferase, and the gly-
cine cleavage enzyme with the concomitant biochemical findings. 
In addition, some patients display variable lactic acidaemia as well 
as a tendency to hypoglycaemia. However, no biochemical abnor-
mality is 100% specific or sensitive, and a positive response to the 
drug remains the most reliable indication of pyridoxal phosphate-​
responsive seizures. The diagnosis is confirmed by mutation analysis.
Treatment and outcome  Pyridoxal 5′-​phosphate given by nasogas-
tric tube is dramatically effective in stopping seizures and improving 
the appearances of the electroencephalogram. Long-​term treat-
ment requires 30 to 60 mg/​kg body weight per day of pyridoxal 5′-​
phosphate in four doses. Doses need to be increased and adjusted 
to body weight during growth. Patients probably require lifelong 
supplementation. Breakthrough seizures are an obvious criterion 
for increasing the dose. So far many questions remain open with 
regards to prognosis. Serial cognitive assessment is recommended.
Defects of glycine and serine metabolism
Nonketotic hyperglycinaemia
Nonketotic hyperglycinaemia is the second most common dis-
order of amino acid metabolism, second to PKU, with an overall 
worldwide frequency estimated at 1 in 60 000 births. It is caused by 
deficient activity of the glycine cleavage system which represents the 
main catabolic route of glycine (Fig. 12.2.18) and is present at high 
levels in liver, brain, and placenta. In brain, it keeps glycine levels 
very low, resulting in a typically low cerebrospinal fluid to plasma 
glycine ratio.
Glycine is connected to multiple biochemical pathways. Most im-
portant is the generation of methylenetetrahydrofolate. The glycine 
cleavage system is made up of four mitochondrial proteins, P, H, T, 
and L. The P protein is a decarboxylase requiring pyridoxal phos-
phate. The heat-​resistant H protein contains lipoic acid and carries 
the aminomethyl moiety. Both proteins are needed to generate CO2 
from the carbon-​1 of glycine. The T protein requires tetrahydrofolate 
and produces methylenetetrahydrofolate from carbon-​2 of glycine. 
The fourth protein (L protein) is needed to transfer hydrogen from 
the lipoic acid moiety of the H protein to nicotinamide adenine 
diphosphate.
Clinical presentation  Symptoms of nonketotic hyperglycinaemia 
are exclusively neurological. Pregnancy and delivery are generally 
uneventful. Hiccupping in utero maybe recognized retrospectively. 
Lethargy, convulsions, anorexia, poor feeding, and vomiting pro-
gress to coma and unresponsiveness 24 to 48 h after birth. Patients 
are severely hypotonic. Seizures with hiccupping and myoclonic 
spasms are prominent, and there is a burst suppression pattern on 
electroencephalography. Apnoea worsens during the third day of 
life, mostly requiring ventilation. The mortality rate at this stage is 
high, especially, if the children are not ventilated. After 2 to 3 weeks 
the patients improve slightly and no longer require intensive care. 
However, intellectual development does not occur in survivors, seiz-
ures persist, and tendon reflexes are increased. Microcephaly, poor 
head control, profound retardation, and a picture of spastic cerebral 
palsy develop.
Up to 15% of patients with neonatal presentation have a better 
recovery after the neonatal period. They have a milder seizure dis-
order, usually controlled by benzoate therapy or by a single anticon-
vulsant. Most of these patients make some developmental progress, 
but they are still mentally disabled with developmental quotients 
varying between 10 and 60.
Variant forms of nonketotic hyperglycinaemia present in later in-
fancy or childhood with severe seizures, spastic paraparesis, clonus, 
and extensor plantar responses with modestly raised plasma and 
cerebrospinal fluid glycine values. Optic atrophy with cerebellar 
signs has also been described. The outcome is similar to that of pa-
tients with the severe form of neonatal nonketotic hyperglycinaemia.
Glycine
Serine
3-Phosphoserine
3-Phosphohydroxypyruvate
3-Phosphoglycerate
Methylene
tetrahydrofolate
Glycine + H2O
Tetrahydrofolate
CO2 + H2O
Fig. 12.2.18  Reversible glycine cleavage to carbon dioxide and water 
is illustrated together with reversible interconversion of serine and 
glycine. These reactions also serve to generate one-​carbon units.  
3-​phosphoglycerate (glycolysis) is the ultimate source.


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1980
Diagnosis  Confirmation of diagnosis by enzyme assay and/​or mo-
lecular analysis is highly advisable and should be pursued to facili-
tate future prenatal diagnosis.
Biochemically, nonketotic hyperglycinaemia is characterized by 
elevated glycine in plasma and in cerebrospinal fluid, with glycine 
being more elevated in cerebrospinal fluid than in plasma. Plasma 
glycine is elevated to values of 600 to 1200 µmol/​litre but may vary 
throughout the day, and can be normal at times. Normal values for 
cerebrospinal fluid levels of glycine are around 4 to 5 µmol/​litre, the 
normal cerebrospinal fluid to plasma ratio being less than 0.04. In 
nonketotic hyperglycinaemia patients, the cerebrospinal fluid to 
plasma glycine ratio is between 0.07 and 0.30.
Great care must be taken to obtain simultaneous plasma and cere-
brospinal fluid samples. Diagnostic pitfalls can arise due to postpran-
dial blood sampling, blood contamination of the cerebrospinal fluid, 
profound liver dysfunction, and treatment with valproate. Urine or-
ganic acids must be determined to exclude propionic aciduria and 
methylmalonic aciduria, as well as glyceric aciduria. Activity of the 
glycine cleavage system can only be reliably measured on liver biop-
sies and in direct uncultured chorionic villi for prenatal diagnosis.
So far the molecular structures of the P protein, the T protein, and 
the H protein have been elucidated, allowing molecular diagnosis of 
defects of these three proteins. Molecular studies have demonstrated 
a defect of the P protein in about 50 to 60% of patients and in the T 
protein in about 30% of patients; a few patients were found to have 
mutations in the GLDC gene leaving approximately 15% of patients 
with no mutations found after all three genes had been analysed.
Treatment and outcome  Therapeutic interventions are unsatisfac-
tory. Some damage to the central nervous system may be prenatal. 
Withdrawal of artificial ventilation and intensive care support should 
be discussed with the parents of neonates in the apnoeic phase. Once 
breathing resumes, most patients survive for many years.
Plasma glycine can be lowered by exchange transfusion or peri-
toneal dialysis but without clinical improvement. Low-​protein diets 
have only a limited effect on decreasing plasma glycine concentra-
tions. Supplying one-​carbon units in the form of methionine or 
N-​formyltetrahydrofolate has not helped. The combination of so-
dium benzoate to increase glycine excretion and diazepines, which 
compete for inhibitory glycine receptors in the central nervous 
system, has lowered plasma and cerebrospinal fluid levels of glycine 
and reduced seizures. Doses up to 600 to 750 mg/​kg per day may 
be required to lower glycine sufficiently to values between 120 and 
280 µmol/​litre. At such high, potentially toxic doses monitoring of 
benzoate levels is advised, nevertheless gastric irritation is very fre-
quent and gastric protection with H2-​antihistamine or proton pump 
inhibitors is preventively recommended.
Most patients need gastric tube feeding or gastrostomy. Gastro-​
oesophageal reflux develops frequently, and many patients benefit 
from a Nissen fundoplication. Recurrent bronchitis is a major 
problem and bronchopneumonia is frequently the cause of death. 
For patients with mild nonketotic hyperglycinaemia, management 
of the hyperactivity can be a major challenge.
3-​Phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase deficiency
Serine 
is 
synthesized 
from 
the 
glycolytic 
intermediate 
3-​phosphoglycerate by 3-​phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase yielding 
3-​phosphohydroxypyruvate (Fig. 12.2.18). Deficiency of this en-
zyme leads to serine deficiency.
Clinical presentation  Patients with serine deficiency due to 3-​
phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase deficiency have congenital micro-
cephaly. They develop severe psychomotor retardation with spastic 
tetraparesis and severe microcephaly. Seizures usually start in in-
fancy as West’s syndrome with hypsarrhythmia. The MRI scan is 
characterized by striking delayed or absent myelination, with subse-
quent cortical and subcortical atrophy. Variable symptoms include 
cataract, hypogonadism, megaloblastic anaemia, and nystagmus.
Diagnosis  Serine deficiency in 3-​phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase 
deficiency is most reliably diagnosed in cerebrospinal fluid with 
values less than 14 µmol/​litre (normal cerebrospinal fluid serine 
42–​86 µmol/​litre in infancy). Serine values in fasting plasma are also 
reduced (28–​64 µmol/​litre, controls 70–​187 µmol/​litre). However, 
nonfasting plasma levels can be normal.
Treatment and outcome  l-​Serine should be administered orally 
until normalized (300–​500 mg/​kg per day). If seizures persist, gly-
cine should be added up to 300 mg/​kg per day. A very satisfactory 
outcome was achieved by antenatal treatment in one patient.
Defects of γ-​aminobutyric acid metabolism
GABA is formed from glutamate in the brain by the cytosolic en-
zyme glutamate decarboxylase, which requires pyridoxal phos-
phate (Fig. 12.2.19). Glutamate can be regenerated from GABA by 
transamination with ketoglutarate (GABA transaminase), which is 
also pyridoxal phosphate dependent. The other product is succinic 
semialdehyde, which is dehydrogenated to succinate and enters the 
citric acid cycle. Deficiency of succinic semialdehyde dehydrogenase 
leads to formation and excretion of 4-​hydroxybutyric acid.
GABA transaminase deficiency
Some patients with GABA transaminase deficiency presented with a 
fatal neonatal encephalopathy, characterized by seizures, hypotonia, 
hyperreflexia, a high-​pitched cry (cat cry), and accelerated growth. 
The diagnosis can be suspected from significantly elevated levels of 
GABA (both free and total), as well as β-​alanine and homocarnosine 
Fig. 12.2.19  Synthesis and catabolism of 4-​aminobutyric acid (GABA). 
The enzymes recognized for known monogenic disorders in humans are 
shown in boxes: GAD, glutamic acid decarboxylase deficiency, GT, GABA 
transaminase deficiency, SSADH, succinic semialdehyde dehydrogenase 
deficiency. The cofactor vit. B6 (vitamin B6) is underlined.
Source data from Zschocke J, Hoffmann GF (2011). Vademecum metabolicum. 
Manual of metabolic paediatrics, 3rd edition. Schattauer, Stuttgart.


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1981
in cerebrospinal fluid. Plasma levels of these amino acids are also 
increased, but not as significantly. The diagnosis must be confirmed 
by enzyme assay and possibly mutation analysis, both of which 
can also be used for prenatal diagnosis. Unfortunately, there is no 
rational treatment available. Recently, in a family suffering from 
encephalomyopathic mitochondrial DNA depletion syndrome, the 
underlying molecular defect was detected in GABA transaminase 
encoded by 4-​aminobutyrate aminotransferase (ABAT). Apparently, 
GABA transaminase connects GABA and nucleoside metabolism 
resulting in a neurometabolic disorder including mitochondrial 
DNA depletion.
Succinic semialdehyde dehydrogenase deficiency  
(4-​hydroxybutyric aciduria)
Clinical presentation  The clinical presentation of succinic 
semialdehyde dehydrogenase deficiency is highly heterogeneous, 
even within sibships. The cardinal manifestations are complex and 
rather nonspecific: hypotonia and delay of motor, mental, and fine 
motor skills and language. Ataxia and/​or seizures occur in about half 
of the patients. Hyperkinesis and aggressive and autistic behaviour 
are additional features. MRI studies show bilateral globus pallidus 
abnormalities but again not constantly.
Diagnosis  Diagnosis is usually suspected by demonstrating in-
creased levels of γ-​hydroxybutyrate by organic acid analysis. It is 
confirmed by enzyme assay and preferentially additional mutation 
analysis.
Treatment and outcome  A common treatment for succinic 
semialdehyde dehydrogenase deficiency is the antiepileptic drug 
vigabatrin. The results have been encouraging in some patients, but 
of little value or even detrimental in others. Seizures respond to con-
ventional anticonvulsants. A ketogenic diet shows promise. Succinic 
semialdehyde dehydrogenase deficiency is a slowly progressive en-
cephalopathy in childhood; it eventually stabilizes in most patients.
Defects of trans-​sulphuration and remethylation
The trans-​sulphuration pathway transfers the sulphur of methio-
nine to serine, thus generating cysteine (Fig. 12.2.20). Methionine 
adenosyltransferase, with widely distributed isoenzyme forms, 
produces S-​adenosylmethionine, the donor in a variety of methy-
lation reactions. S-​Adenosylhomocysteine is cleaved to homocyst-
eine, the sulphydryl compound that exists in reversible equilibrium 
with its disulphide homocystine. Half of the homocysteine formed 
goes through the trans-​sulphuration pathway and the other half 
takes a methyl group from betaine (betaine methyltransferase) or 
5-​methyltetrahydrofolic acid (methionine synthase). The latter is a 
cobalamin-​dependent enzyme which is functionally impaired in de-
fects of vitamin B12 metabolism. In addition, methionine synthase 
reductase is necessary to keep the methionine synthase-​bound co-
balamin in a functional state. The remethylation of homocysteine 
is also impaired if the activity of the reductase that generates 5-​
methyltetrahydrofolate is inadequate. When accumulation of homo-
cysteine and its products homocystine and the also formed mixed 
disulphide results from defects of homocysteine remethylation, 
plasma methionine concentrations are low. They are high when 
homocystine accumulates from impaired activity of cystathionine 
β-​synthase.
Classic homocystinuria: cystathionine β-​synthase deficiency
Clinical presentation
Untreated classic homocystinuria is a slowly progressive, devastating 
multiorgan disorder. First symptoms in childhood are a rapidly pro-
gressive myopia and lens dislocation. Lens dislocation usually oc-
curs in preschool years, but later dislocation is well recognized in 
pyridoxine-​responsive patients, and a few have not developed it 
even in adult life. Monocular and binocular blindness has been rela-
tively frequent due to secondary glaucoma, staphyloma formation, 
buphthalmos, and retinal detachment.
In the older child, skeletal abnormalities and learning difficul-
ties become obvious. Genu valgum and pes cavus are usually the 
first signs of skeletal changes, which include osteoporosis and spon-
taneous crush vertebral fractures. The common abnormalities seen 
in Marfan’s syndrome—​high-​arched palate, pectus excavatum or 
carinatum, genu valgum, pes cavus or planus, scoliosis—​are all well 
recognized in homocystinuria. Arachnodactyly is less common 
and the fingers not infrequently (and elbows occasionally) show 
mild flexion contractures. Skeletal disproportion with a crown–​
pubis length less than the pubis–​heel length is usual (Fig. 12.2.21). 
Learning difficulties affect two-​thirds of patients. Patients responsive 
to pyridoxine (vitamin B6) (see following ‘Treatment and outcome’ 
subsection) have generally higher IQ values than nonresponsive 
patients. Seizures affect about one-​fifth of patients and a few show 
extrapyramidal features, sometimes with severe involuntary move-
ments. Psychiatric disturbances have also been described.
Thromboembolism is a major cause of morbidity and the main 
cause of high premature mortality. Thromboses have been described 
in a wide variety of arteries and veins: cerebral, coronary, mesen-
teric, renal, and peripheral.
–CH3
–CH3
3*
Tetrahydrofolate
Glycine
SO4
Cysteine
Cystathionine
Serine
Homocysteine
**1
S-adenosyl
homocysteine
S-adenosyl
methionine
Methionine
4*
Dimethyl
glycine
Methyltetrahydrofolate
Methylene
tetrahydrofolate
Betaine
–CH3
CH2
2*
Fig. 12.2.20  The trans-​sulphuration pathway from methionine to 
cysteine is shown on the right and the remethylation of homocysteine 
on the left. Asterisked enzymes are: 1, cystathionine β-synthase; 2, 
methylene tetrahydrofolate reductase, 3, methionine synthase; and 4, 
betaine methyltransferase.


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1982
Diagnosis
Elevated plasma methionine values between 100 and 500 µmol/​
litre (sometimes higher) are seen with plasma total homocysteine 
values of 50 to 200 µmol/​litre. A mixed disulphide (half homocyst-
eine, half cysteine) is always present at concentrations somewhat 
below those of homocystine. Diagnosis requires the determination 
of fasting quantitative plasma amino acids, as well as plasma total 
homocysteine. Total homocysteine measured by HPLC includes 
both homocysteine moieties of homocystine, the homocysteine 
moiety of the mixed disulphide, and the homocysteine bound to 
plasma proteins. The urine gives a positive nitroprusside test (it is 
also positive in cystinuria). However, this test can be falsely negative. 
Unfortunately, methionine elevation is unreliable in the early days 
of life, hampering the possibility of newborn screening. This can be 
reliably performed by screening for homocystinuria but still exclu-
sively detects the more severely pyridoxine nonresponsive patients. 
Confirmation of the diagnosis can be performed by enzyme assay 
using cultured skin fibroblasts and/​or mutation analysis, which al-
lows prenatal diagnosis.
Treatment and outcome
Optimal outcome of treatment depends on its earliest possible intro-
duction. Treatment is focused on correcting homocysteine levels; 
lifelong monitoring is essential. In about one-​half of the patients, 
oral pyridoxine rapidly reduces methionine and homocysteine to 
near-​normal values. The first treatment should be to try using doses 
from as low as 50 mg in infants to 1000 mg/​day in older children or 
adults and reducing the dose if a response is achieved; 5 to 10 mg/​
day of folic acid should also be given. Very large sustained doses 
(1000 mg/​day or more) in adults can cause peripheral neuropathy.
Those responding only partially or not at all to pyridoxine require 
a very low-​protein diet supplemented with a methionine-​free amino 
acid supplement, minerals, and vitamins. Biochemical control may 
only be achieved in older children and adults on natural protein in-
takes of 5 to 10 g/​day. Plasma cystine should be maintained in the 
normal range and supplementation should be considered. Both 
folic acid (5–​10 mg/​day) and betaine (up to 12 g/​day) can further re-
duce plasma homocysteine levels but may produce large elevations 
of plasma methionine. Low red-​cell folate values occur and even 
megaloblastic anaemia. Low serum vitamin B12 values also occur 
and should be corrected. Treatment started early can prevent or re-
duce the clinical sequels and lower the incidence of vascular events 
throughout life; many patients have a normal life expectancy.
Methylene tetrahydrofolate reductase deficiency
Clinical presentation
Neurological features predominate with psychomotor retardation, 
seizures, abnormalities of gait, and psychiatric disturbance. The age 
of symptom development varies widely from infancy with a pro-
gressive encephalopathy with apnoea, seizures, and microcephaly to 
adulthood with ataxia, motor abnormalities, psychiatric symptoms, 
subacute degeneration of spinal cord, and cerebrovascular events. 
Demyelination occurs and the changes may resemble the classic 
findings of subacute combined degeneration seen in vitamin B12 de-
ficiency. The risk of vascular disease is high.
Diagnosis
Plasma methionine concentrations are below normal and plasma 
homocysteine concentrations are in the range 20 to 200 µmol/​litre 
with an elevated excretion of 15 to 600 µmol/​day. As homocysteine 
is easily missed on amino acid analysis, quantitative determination 
of total homocysteine by HPLC is the most important clue to diag-
nosis. There is no megaloblastic anaemia. The enzyme can be as-
sayed in liver, leucocytes, lymphocytes, or fibroblasts also allowing 
prenatal diagnosis.
Treatment and outcome
Betaine in large doses (20–​150 mg/​kg per day) effectively lowers 
plasma homocysteine and raises plasma methionine. Other treat-
ments tried alone or in combination include folinic acid, vitamin 
B12, pyridoxine, and methionine. Some have suggested a cocktail of 
all these treatments. It is difficult to be sure of clinical success.
Deficiencies of methionine synthase reductase (cobalamin E 
defect) and methionine synthase (cobalamin G defect)
Clinical and biochemical findings of methionine synthase reduc-
tase (cobalamin E defect) and methionine synthase (cobalamin 
G defect) deficiencies are virtually identical. Characteristic find-
ings are developmental delay and megaloblastic anaemia, but the 
onset may be in later in childhood with dementia and spasticity. 
Retinal degeneration, cardiac defects, and haemolysis have been 
described.
Megaloblastic anaemia occurs in almost all patients. Biochemical 
findings include low plasma methionine and raised homocysteine 
as well as homocystine in plasma and urine. Methylmalonic acid 
should be measured in urine to exclude other cobalamin defects 
(see ‘Methylmalonic aciduria’). Methionine synthase can be as-
sayed in liver or fibroblasts and antenatal diagnosis has been carried 
out on cultured amniocytes. Cells with the cobalamin E defect re-
quire specific reducing conditions to demonstrate the deficient en-
zyme activity. Molecular diagnosis is possible for both conditions. 
Treatment involves large doses of hydroxocobalamin with betaine 
Fig. 12.2.21  A patient with cystathionine synthase deficiency. Note the 
kyphosis and disproportionate short trunk.


12.2  Protein-dependent inborn errors of metabolism
1983
and possibly folinic acid. Success of therapy and outcome is variable 
and often unfavourable.
Other defects of sulphur amino acid metabolism
Among several additional defects known, cystathioninuria 
due to cystathionase deficiency is probably clinically harmless. 
Cystathionine in excess of 1 g/​day may be excreted at clearance 
values close to the glomerular filtration rate.
Methionine adenosyltransferase deficiency causes raised plasma 
methionine levels (up to 1200 µmol/​litre; normal 15–​30 µmol/​litre) 
and appears to be harmless in most patients. The enzyme defect is 
partial. Severe deficiency of methionine adenosyltransferase I/​III 
may be associated with demyelination and neurological features. In 
such patients, treatment with S-​adenosylmethionine (400 mg of the 
toluene sulphonate, twice daily) is an option.
Glycine N-​methyltransferase deficiency is very rare and was dem-
onstrated in children with mild liver disease. Biochemical findings 
included elevated plasma methionine and S-​adenosylmethionine 
levels.
Similarly rare appear to be patients affected with S-​
adenosylhomocysteine hydrolase. Pathology and clinical findings 
are significant in liver, muscle, and the nervous system. Biochemical 
findings are complex, with elevated plasma methionine, S-​
adenosylhomocysteine, and S-​adenosylmethionine levels. Total 
homocysteine and cystathionine may also be slightly elevated.
FURTHER READING
Ando T, et  al. (1971). Propionic acidemia in patients with ketotic 
hyperglycinemia. J Pediatr, 78, 827–​32.
Besse A, et al. (2015) The GABA transaminase, ABAT, is essential for 
mitochondrial nucleoside metabolism. Cell Metab, 21, 417–​27.
Bickel H, Gerrard J, Hickmans E (1953). Influence of phenylalanine on 
PKU. Lancet, 2, 812–​13.
Baumgartner MR, et  al. (2014). Proposed guidelines for the diag-
nosis and management of methylmalonic and propionic acidemia. 
Orphanet J Rare Dis, 9, 130.
Blau N, et al. (eds) (2014). Physician’s guide to the diagnosis, treatment, 
and follow-​up of inherited metabolic disease, 2nd edition. Springer, 
Heidelberg.
Brown GK, et al. (1984). Malonyl coenzyme A decarboxylase defi-
ciency. J Inherit Metab Dis, 7, 21–​6.
Bursell MK, et al. (2011). Adenosine kinase deficiency disrupts the 
methionine cycle and causes hypermethioninemia, encephalopathy, 
and abnormal liver function. Am J Hum Genet, 78, 507–​15.
Canavan MM (1931). Schilder’s encephalitis perioxalis diffusa. Arch 
Neurol Psychiatry, 25, 299.
Danhauser K, et al. (2012). DHTKD1 mutations cause 2-​aminoadipic 
and 2-​oxoadipic aciduria. Am J Hum Genet, 91, 1082–​7.
Dewey KG, et al. (1996). Protein requirements of infants and children. 
Eur J Clin Nutr, 50 Suppl 1, S119–​47.
Dixon MA, Leonard JV (1992). Intercurrent illness in inborn errors of 
intermediary metabolism. Arch Dis Child, 67, 1387–​91.
Edvardson S, et al. (2013). Agenesis of corpus callosum and optic nerve 
hypoplasia due to mutations in SLC25A1 encoding the mitochon-
drial citrate transporter. Am J Hum Genet, 50, 240–​5.
Ensenauer R, et al. (2004). A common mutation is associated with 
a mild, potentially asymptomatic phenotype in patients with 
isovaleric acidemia diagnosed by newborn screening. Am J Hum 
Genet, 75, 1136–​42.
Ferdinandusse S, et al. (2013). HIBCH mutations can cause Leigh-​like 
disease with combined deficiency of multiple mitochondrial respira-
tory chain enzymes and pyruvate dehydrogenase. Orphanet J Rare 
Dis, 8, 188.
Fernandes J, et al. (eds) (2006). Inborn metabolic diseases, 4th edition. 
Springer, Heidelberg.
Ferre S, et al. (2014). Mutations in PCBD1 cause hypomagnesemia and 
renal magnesium wasting. J Am Soc Nephrol, 25, 574–​86.
Garrod AE (1902). The incidence of alkaptonuria. A study in chemical 
individuality. Lancet, 2, 1616–​20.
Garrod AE (1909). Inborn errors of metabolism. Oxford University 
Press, Oxford.
Goodman SI, et al. (1975). Glutaric aciduria: a ‘new’ disorder of amino 
acid metabolism. Biochem Med, 12, 12–​21.
Guthrie R, Susi A (1963). A simple phenylalanine method for 
detecting PKU in large populations of newborn infants. Pediatrics, 
32, 338–​43.
Haack TB, et al. (2015). Deficiency of ECHS1 causes mitochondrial 
encephalopathy with cardiac involvement. Ann Clin Translat Neurol, 
2, 492–​509.
Hoffmann B, et al. (2006). Impact of longitudinal plasma leucine levels 
on the intellectual outcome in patients with classic MSUD. Pediatr 
Res, 59, 17–​20.
Häberle J, et al. (2012). Suggested guidelines for the diagnosis and 
management of urea cycle disorders. Orphanet J Rare Dis, 7, 32.
Hoffmann GF (1994). Selective screening for inborn errors of 
metabolism—​past, present and future. Eur J Pediatr, 153 Suppl 
1, S2–​8.
Hoffmann GF, Blau N (eds) (2014). Congenital neurotransmitter disor-
ders. Nova Science Publishers, New York.
Hoffmann GF, Surtees RA, Wevers RA (1998). Cerebrospinal fluid 
investigations for neurometabolic disorders. Neuropediatrics, 
29, 59–​71.
Hoffmann GF, et al. (1994). Neurological manifestations of organic 
acid disorders. Eur J Pediatr, 153 Suppl 1, S94–​100.
Hörster F, et  al. (2007). Long-​term outcome in methylmalonic 
acidurias is influenced by the underlying defect (mut0, mut−, cblA, 
cblB). Pediatr Res, 62, 225–​30.
Hunt AD Jr, et al. (1954). Pyridoxine dependency: report of a case 
of intractable convulsions in an infant controlled by pyridoxine. 
Pediatrics, 13, 140–​5.
Jakobs C, ten Brink H, Stellaard F (1990). Prenatal diagnosis of in-
herited metabolic disorders by quantitation of characteristic metab-
olites in amniotic fluid: facts and future. Prenat Diagn, 10, 265–​71.
Karnebeek CD, et  al. (2014). Mitochondrial carbonic anhydrase 
VA deficiency resulting from CA5A alterations presents with 
hyperammonemia in early childhood. Am J Hum Genet, 94, 453–​61.
Koch R, et al. (2003). The maternal PKU international study: 1984–​
2002. Pediatrics, 112, 1523–​9.
Kölker S, et al. (2006). Natural history, outcome, and treatment efficacy 
in children and adults with glutaryl-​CoA dehydrogenase deficiency. 
Pediatr Res, 59, 840–​7.
Kölker S, et al. (2015). The phenotypic spectrum of organic acidurias 
and urea cycle disorders. Part 1: the initial presentation. J Inherit 
Metab Dis, 38, 1041–​57.
Kölker S, et al. (2015). The phenotypic spectrum of organic acidurias 
and urea cycle disorders. Part 2: the evolving clinical phenotype. J 
Inherit Metab Dis, 38, 1059–​74.


SECTION 12  Metabolic disorders
1984
Lenke R, Levy HL (1980). Maternal PKU and hyperphenylal­
aninemia: an international study of treated and untreated pregnan-
cies. N Engl J Med, 303, 1202–​8.
Ly TB, et  al. (2003). Mutations in the AUH gene cause 3-​
methylglutaconic aciduria type I. Hum Mutat, 21, 410–​17.
Menkes JH, Hurst PL, Craig JM (1954). New syndrome: progressive 
familial infantile cerebral dysfunction associated with an unusual 
urinary substance. Pediatrics, 14, 462–​7.
Millington DS, et  al. (1990). Tandem mass spectrometry:  a new 
method for acylcarnitine profiling with potential for neonatal 
screening for inborn errors of metabolism. J Inherit Metab Dis, 
13, 321–​4.
Nota B, et al. (2013). Deficiency in SLC25A1, encoding the mitochon-
drial citrate carrier, causes combined d-​2-​ and l-​2-​hydroxyglutaric 
aciduria. Am J Human Genet, 92, 627–​31.
Nyhan WL, Barshop BA, Al-​Aqueel A (2012). Atlas of metabolic dis-
eases. Hodder Headline, London.
Oberholzer VG, et al. (1967). Methylmalonic aciduria: an inborn error 
of metabolism leading to chronic metabolic acidosis. Arch Dis Child, 
42, 492–​504.
Peters H, et al. (2014). ECHS1 mutations in Leigh disease: a new in-
born error of metabolism affecting valine metabolism. Brain, 137, 
2903–​8.
Phornphutkul C, et al. (2002). Natural history of alkaptonuria. N Engl 
J Med, 347, 2111–​21.
Posset R, et al. (2019). Impact of Diagnosis and Therapy on Cognitive 
Function in Urea Cycle Disorders. Ann Neurol, 86, 116–28.
Prietsch V, et al. (2002). Emergency management of inherited meta-
bolic disease. J Inherit Metab Dis, 25, 531–​46.
Salomons GS, et al. (2007) Clinical, enzymatic and molecular charac-
terization of nine new patients with malonyl-​coenzyme A decarb-
oxylase deficiency. J Inherit Metab Dis, 30, 23–​8.
Schaefer F, et al. (1999). Dialysis in neonates with inborn errors of me-
tabolism. Nephrol Dial Transplant, 14, 910–​18.
Schulze A, et al. (2003). Expanded newborn screening for inborn errors 
of metabolism by electrospray ionization-​tandem mass spectrom-
etry: results, outcome, and implications. Pediatrics, 111, 1399–​406.
Scriver CR, et al. (eds) (2001). The metabolic and molecular bases of 
inherited disease, 8th edition. McGraw-​Hill, New York.
Strauss KA, et al. (2006). Elective liver transplantation for the treat-
ment of classical maple syrup urine disease. Am J Transplant, 6, 
557–​64.
Suwannarat P, et  al. (2005). Use of nitisinone in patients with 
alkaptonuria. Metabolism, 54, 719–​28.
 Tanaka K, et al. (1966). Isovaleric acidemia: a new genetic defect of 
leucine metabolism. Proc Natl Acad Sci, 56, 236–​42.
Unsinn C, et al. (2016). Clinical course of 63 patients with neonatal 
onset urea cycle disorders in the years 2001–2013. Orphanet J Rare 
Dis, 11(1), 116.
Wilson JMG, Jungner G (1968). Principles and practice of screening for 
disease. Public Health Papers No. 34. World Health Organization, 
Geneva.
Wolf B, et al. (1983). Biotinidase deficiency: the enzymatic defect in late-​
onset multiple carboxylase deficiency. Clin Chim Acta, 13, 273–​81.
Wolf B, et al. (1983). Deficient biotinidase activity in late-​onset mul-
tiple carboxylase deficiency. N Engl J Med, 308, 161.
Wortmann S, et al. (2012). Mutations in the phospholipid remodel-
ling gene SERAC1 impair mitochondrial function and intracellular 
cholesterol trafficking and cause dystonia and deafness. Nat Genet, 
44, 797–​802.
Wortmann S, et al. (2013). 3-​Methylglutaconic aciduria—​lessons from 
50 genes and 977 patients. J Inherit Metab Dis, 36, 913–​21.
Zschocke J, Hoffmann GF (2011). Vademecum metabolicum. Manual 
of metabolic paediatrics, 3rd edition. Schattauer, Stuttgart.
Zschocke J, et  al. (2000). Progressive infantile neurodegeneration 
caused by 2-​methyl-​3-​hydroxybutyryl-​CoA dehydrogenase defi-
ciency: a novel inborn error of branched chain fatty acid and isoleu-
cine metabolism. Pediatr Res, 48, 852–​5.