# 12 - 9 Chronic Pain and Its Treatment

# 01 - 9 Chronic Pain and Its Treatment

# 9 Chronic Pain and Its Treatment

Chronic Pain and 

Its Treatment
What is Pain?  379
“Normal” Pain and the Activation of Nociceptive 
Nerve Fibers  381
Nociceptive Pathway to the Spinal Cord  381
Nociceptive Pathway from the Spinal Cord to the 
Brain  382
Neuropathic Pain  382
Peripheral Mechanisms in Neuropathic Pain  382
Central Mechanisms in Neuropathic Pain  382
The Spectrum of Mood and Anxiety Disorders with 
Pain Disorders  387
This chapter will provide a brief overview of chronic pain 
conditions associated with different psychiatric disorders 
and treated with psychotropic drugs. Included here are 
discussions of the symptomatic and pathophysiological 
overlap between disorders with pain and many other 
disorders treated in psychopharmacology, especially 
depression and anxiety. Clinical descriptions and formal 
criteria for how to diagnose painful conditions are only 
mentioned here in passing. The reader should consult 
standard reference sources for this material. The discussion 
here will emphasize how discoveries about the functioning 
of various brain circuits and neurotransmitters – especially 
those acting upon the central processing of pain – have 
impacted our understanding of the pathophysiology and 
treatment of many painful conditions that may occur 
with or without various psychiatric disorders. The goal 
of this chapter is to acquaint the reader with ideas about 
the clinical and biological aspects of the symptom of 
pain, how it can hypothetically be caused by alterations 
of pain processing within the central nervous system, 
how it can be associated with many of the symptoms of 
depression and anxiety, and finally, how it can be treated 
with several of the same agents that can treat depression 
and anxiety. The discussion in this chapter is at the 
conceptual level, and not at the pragmatic level. The reader 
should consult standard drug handbooks (such as Stahl’s 
Essential Psychopharmacology: the Prescriber’s Guide) for 
details of doses, side effects, drug interactions, and other 
issues relevant to the prescribing of these drugs in clinical 
practice.
Fibromyalgia  387
Decreased Gray Matter in Chronic Pain 
Syndromes?  387
Descending Spinal Synapses in the Dorsal Horn 
and the Treatment of Chronic Pain  390
Targeting Sensitized Circuits in Chronic Pain 
Conditions  395
Targeting Ancillary Symptoms in 
Fibromyalgia  399
Summary  400
WHAT IS PAIN?
No experience rivals pain for its ability to capture our 
attention, focus our actions, and cause suffering (see 
Table 9-1 for some useful definitions regarding pain). The 
powerful experience of pain, especially acute pain, can 
serve a vital function – to make us aware of damage to 
our bodies, and to rest the injured part until it has healed. 
When acute pain is peripheral in origin (i.e., originating 
outside of the central nervous system) but continues as 
chronic pain, it can cause changes in central nervous 
system pain mechanisms that enhance or perpetuate the 
original peripheral pain. For example, osteoarthritis, low 
back pain, and diabetic peripheral neuropathic pain all 
begin as peripheral pain, but over time these conditions 
can trigger central pain mechanisms that amplify 
peripheral pain and generate additional pain centrally. 
This may explain why research has recently shown that 
chronic pain conditions of peripheral origin can be 
successfully targeted for relief by psychotropic drugs that 
work on central pain mechanisms.
Many other chronic pain conditions may start 
centrally and never have a peripheral causation to the 
pain, especially conditions associated with multiple 
unexplained painful physical symptoms such as 
depression, anxiety, and fibromyalgia. Because these 
centrally mediated pain conditions are associated 
with emotional symptoms, that type of pain has until 
recently often not been considered “real” but rather 
a nonspecific outcome of unresolved psychological 
379

STAHL’S ESSENTIAL PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
conflicts that would improve when the associated 
psychiatric condition improved, and therefore that this 
type of pain did not need to be targeted specifically for 
treatment. Today, however, many painful conditions 
without identifiable peripheral lesions that were once 
linked only to psychiatric disorders are now hypothesized 
to be forms of chronic neuropathic pain syndromes and 
can be treated with the same agents that successfully treat 
neuropathic pain syndromes that are not associated with 
psychiatric disorders. These treatments include the SNRIs 
(serotonin–norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors, discussed 
in Chapter 7 on treatment for mood disorders [Figures 
7-28 through 7-33]) and the α2δ ligands (anticonvulsants 
that block voltage-gated calcium channels or VSCCs, 
discussed in Chapter 8 on anxiety disorders [Figures 
8-17 and 8-18]). Additional psychotropic agents acting 
centrally at various other sites are also used to treat a 
variety of chronic pain conditions and will be mentioned 
below. Many additional drugs are being tested as 
potential novel pain treatments as well.
Table 9-1  Pain: some useful definitions
Pain
An unpleasant sensory and emotional experience associated with actual or potential 
tissue damage, or described in terms of such damage
Acute pain
Pain that is of short duration and resolves; usually directly related to the resolution or 
healing of tissue damage
Chronic pain
Pain that persists for longer than would be expected; an artificial threshold for chronicity 
(e.g., 1 month) is not appropriate
Neuropathic pain
Pain that arises from damage to, or dysfunction of, any part of the peripheral or central 
nervous system
Nociception
The process by which noxious stimuli produce activity in the sensory pathways that convey 
“painful” information
Allodynia
Pain caused by a stimulus that does not normally provoke pain
Hyperalgesia
An increased response to a stimulus that is not normally painful
Analgesia
Any process that reduces the sensation of pain, while not affecting normal touch
Local anesthesia
Blockade of all sensation (innocuous and painful) from a local area
Noxious stimulus
Stimulus that inflicts damage, or would potentially inflict damage, on tissues of the body
Primary afferent 
neuron (PAN)
The first neuron in the somatosensory pathway; detects mechanical, thermal, or chemical 
stimuli at its peripheral terminals and transmits action potentials to its central terminals in 
the spinal cord; all PANs have a cell body in the dorsal root ganglion
Nociceptor
A primary afferent (sensory) neuron that is only activated by a noxious stimulus
Nociception
The process by which a nociceptor detects a noxious stimulus and generates a signal 
(action potentials) that is propagated towards higher centers in the nociceptive pathway
Dorsal root ganglion 
(DRG)
Contains the cell bodies of PANs; proteins, including transmitters, receptors, and structural 
proteins, are synthesized here and transported to peripheral and central terminals
Interneuron
Neuron with its cell body, axon, and dendrites within the spinal cord; can be excitatory 
(e.g., containing glutamate) or inhibitory (e.g., containing GABA)
Projection neurons
Neuron in the dorsal horn that receives input from PANs and/or interneurons, and 
projects up the spinal cord to higher processing centers
Spinothalamic tract
Tract of neurons that project from the spinal cord to the thalmus
Spinobulbar tracts
Several different tracts of neurons that project from the spinal cord to brainstem nuclei
Somatosensory cortex
Region of the cerebral cortex that receives input mainly from cutaneous sensory nerves; 
the cortex is topographically arranged, with adjacent areas receiving input from adjacent 
body areas; stimulation of the somatosensory cortex creates sensations from the body 
part that projects to it

Since pain is clearly associated with some psychiatric 
disorders, and psychotropic drugs that treat various 
psychiatric conditions are also effective for a wide 
variety of pain conditions, the detection, quantification, 
and treatment of pain are rapidly becoming 
standardized parts of a psychiatric evaluation. Modern 
psychopharmacologists increasingly consider pain to be a 
psychiatric “vital sign,” thus requiring routine evaluation 
and symptomatic treatment. In fact, elimination of pain 
is increasingly recognized as necessary in order to have 
full symptomatic remission not only of chronic pain 
conditions, but also of many psychiatric disorders.
“Normal” Pain and the Activation of Nociceptive 
Nerve Fibers
The nociceptive pain pathway is the series of neurons 
that begins with detection of a noxious stimulus and ends 
with the subjective perception of pain. This so-called 
“nociceptive pathway” starts from the periphery, enters 
the spinal cord, and projects to the brain (Figure 9-1). 
It is important to understand the processes by which 
incoming information can be modulated to increase or 
decrease the perception of pain associated with a given 
stimulus because these processes can explain not only 
why maladaptive pain states arise but also why drugs that 
work in psychiatric conditions such as depression and 
anxiety can also be effective in reducing pain.
Nociceptive Pathway to the Spinal Cord
Primary afferent neurons detect sensory inputs 
including pain (Figure 9-1). They have their cell bodies 
in the dorsal root ganglion located along the spinal 
column outside the central nervous system and thus 
are considered peripheral and not central neurons 
primary afferent
dorsal root
periphery
neurons
ganglion
non-noxious 
mechanical stimulus
Aß fiber 
noxious 
mechanical stimulus
PN
dorsal root
projection
neurons
noxious heat
and chemical stimuli
C fiber 
gray matter
white matter
Chapter 9: Chronic Pain and Its Treatment
(Figure 9-1). Nociception begins with transduction – the 
process by which specialized membrane proteins located 
on the peripheral projections of these neurons detect a 
stimulus and generate a voltage change at their peripheral 
neuronal membranes. A sufficiently strong stimulus will 
lower the voltage at the membrane (i.e., depolarize the 
membrane) enough to activate voltage-sensitive sodium 
channels (VSSCs) and trigger an action potential that will 
be propagated along the length of the axon to the central 
terminals of the neuron in the spinal cord (Figure 9-1). 
VSSCs are introduced in Chapter 3 and illustrated in 
Figures 3-19 and 3-20. Nociceptive impulse flow from 
primary afferent neurons into the central nervous system 
can be reduced or stopped when VSSCs are blocked 
by peripherally administered local anesthetics such as 
lidocaine.
The specific response characteristics of primary 
afferent neurons are determined by the specific 
receptors and channels expressed by that neuron in the 
periphery (Figure 9-1). For example, primary afferent 
neurons that express a stretch-activated ion channel are 
mechanosensitive; those that express the vanillinoid 
receptor 1 (VR1) ion channel are activated by capsaicin, 
the pungent ingredient in chili peppers, and also by 
noxious heat, leading to the burning sensation that both 
these stimuli evoke. These functional response properties 
are used to classify primary afferent neurons into three 
types: Aβ-, Aδ-, and C-fiber neurons (Figure 9-1). 
Aβ fibers detect small movements, light touch, hair 
movement, and vibrations; C-fiber peripheral terminals 
are bare nerve endings that are only activated by noxious 
mechanical, thermal, or chemical stimuli; Aδ fibers fall 
somewhere in between, sensing noxious mechanical 
stimuli and sub-noxious thermal stimuli (Figure 9-1). 
Figure 9-1  Activation of nociceptive 
nerve fibers.  Detection of a noxious 
stimulus occurs at the peripheral 
terminals of primary afferent neurons and 
leads to generation of action potentials 
that propagate along the axon to the 
central terminals. Aβ fibers respond only 
to non-noxious stimuli, Aδ fibers respond 
to noxious mechanical stimuli and subnoxious thermal stimuli, and C fibers 
respond only to noxious mechanical, 
heat, and chemical stimuli. Primary 
afferent neurons have their cell bodies 
in the dorsal root ganglion and send 
terminals into that spinal cord segment 
as well as sending less dense collaterals 
up the spinal cord for a short distance. 
Primary afferent neurons synapse onto 
several different classes of dorsal horn 
projection neurons (PN), which project 
via different tracts to higher centers.
spinal cord
to higher 
centers
dorsal 
horn
381

STAHL’S ESSENTIAL PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
Nociceptive input and pain can thus be caused by 
activating primary afferent neurons peripherally, such as 
from a sprained ankle or a tooth extraction. Nonsteroidal 
anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) can reduce painful 
input from these primary afferent neurons, presumably 
via their peripheral actions. Opiates can also reduce such 
pain, but from central actions as explained below.
Nociceptive Pathway from the Spinal Cord to the Brain
The central terminals of peripheral nociceptive 
neurons synapse in the dorsal horn of the spinal 
cord onto the next cells in the pathway – dorsal 
horn neurons, which receive input from many 
primary afferent neurons and then project to higher 
centers (Figures 9-2 and 9-3). For this reason, they 
are sometimes also called dorsal horn projection 
neurons (PN in Figures 9-1 through 9-3). Dorsal horn 
neurons are thus the first neurons of the nociceptive 
pathway that are located entirely within the central 
nervous system and thus a key site for modulation 
of nociceptive neuronal activity as it comes into 
the central nervous system. A vast number of 
neurotransmitters have been identified in the dorsal 
horn, some of which are shown in Figure 9-2.
Neurotransmitters in the dorsal horn are synthesized 
not only by primary afferent neurons, but also by the 
other neurons in the dorsal horn, including descending 
neurons and various interneurons (Figure 9-2). Some 
neurotransmitter systems in the dorsal horn are 
successfully targeted by known pain-relieving drugs, 
especially opiates, serotonin and norepinephrine boosting 
SNRIs, and α2δ ligands acting at VSCCs. All of the 
neurotransmitter systems acting in the dorsal horn are 
potential targets for novel pain-relieving drugs (Figure 
9-2) and a plethora of such novel agents is currently in 
clinical and preclinical development.
There are several classes of dorsal horn neurons: some 
receive input directly from primary sensory neurons, 
some are interneurons, and some project up the spinal 
cord to higher centers (Figure 9-3). There are several 
different tracts in which these projection neurons can 
ascend, which can be crudely divided into two functions: 
the sensory/discriminatory pathway and the emotional/
motivational pathway (Figure 9-3).
In the sensory/discriminatory pathway, dorsal horn 
neurons ascend in the spinothalamic tract; then, thalamic 
neurons project to the primary somatosensory cortex 
(Figure 9-3). This particular pain pathway is thought to 
convey the precise location of the nociceptive stimulus 
and its intensity. In the emotional/motivational pathway, 
other dorsal horn neurons project to brainstem nuclei, 
and from there to limbic regions (Figure 9-3). This 
second pain pathway is thought to convey the affective 
component that nociceptive stimuli evoke. Only when 
these two aspects of sensory discrimination and emotions 
come together and the final, subjective perception of pain 
is created, can we use the word “pain” to describe the 
modality (see “ouch” in Figure 9-3). Before this point, we 
are simply discussing activity in neural pathways, which 
should be described as noxious-evoked or nociceptive 
neuronal activity but not necessarily as pain.
NEUROPATHIC PAIN
The term neuropathic pain describes pain that arises from 
damage to, or dysfunction of, any part of the peripheral 
or central nervous system, whereas “normal” pain 
(so-called nociceptive pain just discussed in the section 
above) is caused by activation of nociceptive nerve fibers.
Peripheral Mechanisms in Neuropathic Pain
Normal transduction and conduction in peripheral 
afferent neurons can be hijacked in certain neuropathic 
pain states to maintain nociceptive signaling in the 
absence of a relevant noxious stimulus. Neuronal 
damage by disease or trauma can alter electrical activity 
of neurons, allow cross-talk between neurons, and 
initiate inflammatory processes to cause “peripheral 
sensitization.” In this chapter, we will not emphasize 
peripheral sensitization disorders and mechanisms, but 
rather central sensitization disorders and mechanisms.
Central Mechanisms in Neuropathic Pain
At each major relay point in the pain pathway 
(Figure 9-3), the nociceptive pain signal is susceptible to 
modulation by endogenous processes to either dampen 
down the signal or to amplify it. This happens not only 
peripherally at primary afferent neurons, as has just been 
discussed, but also at central neurons in the dorsal horn 
of the spinal cord as well as in numerous brain regions. 
The events in the dorsal horn of the spinal cord are better 
understood than those in brain regions of nociceptive 
pathways, but pain processing in the brain may be the 
key to understanding the generation and amplification 
of pain centrally in disorders of chronic peripheral 
pain, such as osteoarthritis, low back pain, and diabetic 
peripheral neuropathic pain, as well as painful physical 
symptoms in affective and anxiety disorders and in 
fibromyalgia.

Chapter 9: Chronic Pain and Its Treatment
to higher 
centers
dorsal horn
projection neuron 
descending
neurons
Multiple Neurotransmitters Modulate Pain Processing 
in the Spinal Cord
5HT
5HT
opioid
opioid
VIP
CGRP
GABA
glu
Sub P
NKA
NKB
somato
statin
NE
VIPR
SR
CGRP-R
AMPA-R
NMDA-R
NK1,2,3
GABAA,B
GABAA,B
CCK-A,B
5HT3
5HT3
5HT
1/B/D
interneuron
primary afferent neuron
2
opioid
glycine
CCK
NO
GABA
PN
Figure 9-2  Multiple neurotransmitters modulate pain processing in the spinal cord.  There are many neurotransmitters and their 
corresponding receptors in the dorsal horn. Neurotransmitters in the dorsal horn may be released by primary afferent neurons, by 
descending regulatory neurons, by dorsal horn projection neurons (PN), and by interneurons. Neurotransmitters present in the dorsal 
horn that have been best studied in terms of pain transmission include substance P (NK1, 2, and 3 receptors), endorphins (μ-opioid 
receptors), norepinephrine (α2 adrenoceptors), and serotonin (5HT1B/D and 5HT3 receptors). Several other neurotransmitters are also 
represented, including vasopressin inhibitory protein (VIP) and its receptor VIPR; somatostatin and its receptor SR; calcitonin G-related 
peptide (CGRP) and its receptors CGRP-R; GABA and its receptors GABAA and GABAB; glutamate and its receptors AMPA-R (α-amino-3hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazole propionic acid receptor) and NMDA-R (N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor); nitric oxide (NO); cholecystokinin 
(CCK) and its receptors CCK-A and CCK-B; and glycine and its receptor NMDA-R.

STAHL’S ESSENTIAL PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
somatosensory 
cortex
somatosensory 
cortex
thalamus
thalamus
PN
PN
limbic 
structures
limbic 
structures
spinothalamic 
tract
spinothalamic 
tract
brainstem
brainstem
spinobulbar 
tract
spinobulbar 
tract
“Segmental” central sensitization is a process 
thought to be caused when plastic changes occur 
in the dorsal horn, classically in conditions such as 
phantom pain after limb amputation. Specifically, 
this type of neuronal plasticity in the dorsal horn is 
called activity-dependent or use-dependent because 
it requires constant firing of the pain pathway in the 
dorsal horn. The consequence of this constant input of 
pain is eventually to cause exaggerated (hyperalgesic) 
or prolonged responses to any noxious input – a 
phenomenon sometimes called “wind-up” – as well as 
painful responses to normally innocuous inputs (called 
allodynia). Phosphorylation of key membrane receptors 
and channels in the dorsal horn appears to increase 
synaptic efficiency and thus to trip a master switch 
opening the gate to the pain pathway and turning on 
central sensitization, which acts to amplify or create 
the perception of pain even if there is no pain input 
actually coming from the periphery. The gate can also 
close, as conceptualized in the classic “gate theory” of 
pain, in order to explain how innocuous stimulation 
(e.g., acupuncture, vibration, rubbing) away from the 
site of an injury can close the pain gate and reduce the 
perception of the injury pain.
In segmental central sensitization, a definite 
peripheral injury (Figure 9-4A) is combined with 
central sensitization at the spinal cord segment receiving 
nociceptive input from the damaged area of the body 
(Figure 9-4B). Segmental central sensitization syndromes 
are thus “mixed” states where the insult of central 
segmental changes (Figure 9-4B) are added to peripheral 
injuries such as low back pain, diabetic peripheral 
Figure 9-3  From nociception 
to pain.  Dorsal horn neurons in 
the spinothalamic tract project 
to the thalamus and then to the 
primary somatosensory cortex. 
This pathway carries information 
about the intensity and location 
of the painful stimuli and is 
termed the sensory/discriminatory 
pathway. Neurons ascending in 
the spinobulbar tract project to 
brainstem nuclei and then to both 
the thalamus and limbic structures. 
These pathways convey the 
emotional and motivational aspects 
of the pain experience. Only when 
information from the sensory/
discriminatory (thalamocortical) 
and emotional/motivational 
(limbic) pathways combine is the 
human subjective experience of 
pain formed (“ouch”).
subjective
experience
of pain
subjective
experience
of pain
OUCH!
OUCH!
neuropathic pain, and painful cutaneous eruptions of 
herpes zoster (shingles) (Figure 9-4A).
“Suprasegmental” central sensitization is hypothesized 
to be linked to plastic changes that occur in brain sites 
within the nociceptive pathway, especially the thalamus 
and cortex, in the presence of known peripheral causes 
(Figure 9-5A) or even in the absence of identifiable 
triggering events (Figure 9-5B). In the case of peripherally 
activated suprasegmental central sensitization, it is as 
though the brain “learns” from its experience of pain, 
and decides not only to keep the process going, but also 
to enhance it and make it permanent. In the case of pain 
that originates centrally without peripheral input, it is as 
though the brain has figured out how to spontaneously 
activate its pain pathways. Interrupting this process of 
sensitized brain pathways for pain and getting the central 
nervous system to “forget” its molecular memories 
may be one of the greatest therapeutic opportunities in 
psychopharmacology today, not only because this may 
be a therapeutic strategy for various chronic neuropathic 
pain conditions as discussed here, but also because it 
may be a viable approach to treating the hypothesized 
molecular changes that may underlie disease progression 
in a wide variety of disorders, from schizophrenia, 
to stress-induced anxiety and affective disorders, 
to addictive disorders. Conditions hypothesized to 
be caused by suprasegmental central sensitization 
syndromes of pain originating in the brain without 
peripheral pain input include fibromyalgia, the syndrome 
of chronic widespread pain, and painful physical 
symptoms of depression and anxiety disorders, especially 
posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (Figure 9-5B).

Onset of Acute Pain from Painful Peripheral Conditions
OUCH!
A
Development of Segmental Central Sensitization and Increased Pain
OUCH!
segmental central
sensitization
low back pain
B
Chapter 9: Chronic Pain and Its Treatment
Figure 9-4  Acute pain and 
development of segmental central 
sensitization.  (A) When peripheral 
injury occurs, nociceptive impulse 
flow from primary afferent neurons is 
transmitted via dorsal horn neurons 
to higher brain centers, where it can 
ultimately be interpreted as pain 
(represented by the “ouch”). (B) In 
some cases, injury or disease directly 
affecting the nervous system may 
result in plastic changes that lead to 
sensitization within the central nervous 
system, such that the experience 
of pain continues even after tissue 
damage is resolved. Impulses may be 
generated at abnormal locations either 
spontaneously or via mechanical forces. 
At the level of the spinal cord, this 
process is termed segmental central 
sensitization. This mechanism underlies 
conditions such as diabetic peripheral 
neuropathic pain and shingles.
joint affected by 
osteoarthritis
diabetic peripheral
neuropathic pain
low back pain
shingles
joint affected by 
osteoarthritis
diabetic peripheral
neuropathic pain
shingles
385

STAHL’S ESSENTIAL PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
Figure 9-5  Suprasegmental central sensitization.  Plastic changes in brain sites within the nociceptive pathway, especially the thalamus 
and cortex, can cause sensitization. This process within the brain is termed suprasegmental central sensitization. This can occur following 
peripheral injury (A) or even in the absence of identifiable triggering events (B). This mechanism is believed to underlie conditions such 
as fibromyalgia, chronic widespread pain, and painful symptoms in depression and anxiety disorders.
OUCH!
joint affected by 
osteoarthritis
diabetic peripheral
neuropathic pain
low back pain
shingles
OUCH!
fibromyalgia
chronic widespread
pain
painful physical symptoms
of depression/anxiety
Chronic Pain with Suprasegmental Central Sensitization
from Peripheral Injury
Suprasegmental Central Sensitization Originating in the Brain
suprasegmental
central sensitization
A
B

Chapter 9: Chronic Pain and Its Treatment
Fibromyalgia
Fibromyalgia has emerged as a diagnosable and treatable 
pain syndrome, with tenderness but no structural 
pathology in muscles, ligaments, or joints. Fibromyalgia 
is recognized as a chronic, widespread pain syndrome 
associated with fatigue and nonrestorative sleep. It is 
diagnosed based on the number of body areas in which 
the patient experiences pain (widespread pain index, or 
WPI) combined with the severity of associated symptoms 
(fatigue, waking unrefreshed, cognitive symptoms, and 
other somatic symptoms) (Figure 9-7). It is the second 
most common diagnosis in rheumatology clinics, and 
may affect 2–4% of the general population. Although 
symptoms of fibromyalgia are chronic and debilitating, 
they are not necessarily progressive. There is no known 
cause and there is no known pathology identifiable in the 
muscles or joints. This syndrome can be deconstructed 
into its component symptoms (Figure 9-8), and then 
matched with hypothetically malfunctioning brain 
circuits (Figure 9-9).
Decreased Gray Matter in Chronic Pain Syndromes?
Some very troubling preliminary reports suggest that 
chronic pain may even “shrink the brain” in the DLPFC 
(dorsolateral prefrontal cortex) (Figure 9-9) and thereby 
The Spectrum of Mood and Anxiety Disorders with 
Pain Disorders
A large group of overlapping disorders can have 
emotional symptoms, painful physical symptoms, 
or both (Figure 9-6). Although pain in the absence 
of emotional symptoms has long been seen as a 
neurological disorder, and pain in the presence of 
emotional symptoms as a psychiatric disorder, it is 
now clear that pain is a symptom that can be mapped 
onto inefficient information processing within the pain 
circuit, and is largely considered the same symptom with 
the same treatments, whether occurring by itself or as 
part of any number of syndromes (Figure 9-6). Thus, 
pain (Figure 9-6, right) can occur not only by itself, 
but also concomitantly with the emotional symptoms 
of depressed mood and anxiety (Figure 9-6, left), and 
with the physical symptoms of fatigue, insomnia, 
and problems concentrating (Figure 9-6, middle). No 
matter whether pain occurs by itself or with additional 
concomitant emotional or physical symptoms, or in the 
presence of full syndromal psychiatric disorders such as 
major depressive disorder, generalized anxiety disorder, 
or PTSD (Figure 9-6, left), it must be treated and the 
treatments are the same across the spectrum (Figure 9-6), 
namely SNRIs and α2δ ligands as will be explained below.
Figure 9-6  The spectrum from mood and anxiety disorders to chronic neuropathic pain syndromes.  Pain, though not a formal 
diagnostic feature of depression or anxiety disorders, is nonetheless frequently present in patients with these disorders. Similarly, 
depressed mood, anxiety, and other symptoms identified as part of depression and anxiety disorders are now recognized as being 
common in pain disorders.
The Spectrum from Mood and Anxiety Disorders to Chronic
Neuropathic Pain Syndromes
major
depressive
disorder
general 
anxiety
disorder
PTSD
anxiety
disorder
subtypes
fatigue
sleep
cognition
anxiety and
mood disorders
mood/anxiety
pain
chronic neuropathic
pain syndromes
mixed
shingles
fibromyalgia
Z
Z
Z
worry
$
chronic widespread
pain
painful physical symptoms
of depression/anxiety
diabetic peripheral
neuropathic pain
osteoarthritis
low back pain

STAHL’S ESSENTIAL PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
Widespread Pain Index (WPI)
for Diagnosis of Fibromyalgia
neck
shoulder
girdle
chest
upper back
upper
arm
lower
arm
lower back
upper
leg
hip (buttock)
lower
leg
ﬁbromyalgia
fatigue
concentration
pain
sleep
depression
contribute to cognitive dysfunction in certain pain states 
such as fibromyalgia (Figure 9-8) and low back pain. 
Brain atrophy is discussed in relationship to stress and 
anxiety disorders in Chapter 6 and illustrated in Figure 
6-30. It would not be surprising if stressful conditions 
that cause pain, as well as pain that causes distress, may 
Figure 9-7  Widespread pain index 
(WPI).  Fibromyalgia is a chronic 
widespread pain syndrome, formerly 
diagnosed based on the number 
of body areas in which the patient 
experiences pain (widespread pain 
index, or WPI) combined with the 
severity of associated symptoms 
(fatigue, waking unrefreshed, cognitive 
symptoms, and other somatic 
symptoms.
jaw
abdomen
Figure 9-8  Symptoms of 
fibromyalgia.  In addition to pain as a 
central feature of fibromyalgia, many 
patients experience fatigue, anxiety, 
depression, disturbed sleep, and 
problems concentrating.
anxiety
all be involved in causing brain atrophy and/or cognitive 
dysfunction in fibromyalgia and other chronic pain states. 
Chronic back pain, for example, has also been reported 
to be associated with decreased prefrontal and thalamic 
gray-matter density (Figure 9-10). Some experts have 
hypothesized that in fibromyalgia and other chronic

Match Each Symptom of Fibromyalgia
to Hypothetically Malfunctioning Brain Circuits
psychomotor 
fatigue (physical)
pleasure
interests
fatigue/
energy
-“fibro-fog”
- problems concentrating
- lack of interest/pleasure
psychomotor
fatigue (mental)
pain
PFC
S
NA
BF
T
Hy
NT
A
H
mood
depressed mood
anxiety
sleep
appetite
Gray-matter loss in chronic pain
DLPFC
thalamus
temporal
cortex
neuropathic pain syndromes, the persistent perception 
of pain could lead to overuse of DLPFC neurons, 
excitotoxic cell death in this brain region, and reduction 
Chapter 9: Chronic Pain and Its Treatment
Figure 9-9  Symptom-based algorithm 
for fibromyalgia.  A symptom-based 
approach to treatment selection for 
fibromyalgia follows the theory that 
each of a patient’s symptoms can 
be matched with malfunctioning 
brain circuits and neurotransmitters 
that hypothetically mediate those 
symptoms; this information is then 
used to select a corresponding 
pharmacological mechanism for 
treatment. Pain is linked to transmission 
of information via the thalamus (T), 
while physical fatigue is linked to 
the striatum (S) and spinal cord (SC). 
Problems concentrating and lack of 
interest (termed “fibro-fog”) as well 
as mental fatigue are linked to the 
prefrontal cortex (PFC), specifically the 
dorsolateral PFC. Fatigue, low energy, 
and lack of interest may all also be 
related to the nucleus accumbens (NA). 
Disturbances in sleep and appetite are 
associated with the hypothalamus (Hy), 
depressed mood with the amygdala (A) 
and orbital frontal cortex, and anxiety 
with the amygdala.
pain
C
SC
fatigue (physical)
pain
Figure 9-10  Gray-matter loss in chronic 
pain.  Research suggests that chronic pain, 
like anxiety and stress-related disorders, 
may lead to brain atrophy. Specifically, there 
are data showing gray-matter loss in the 
dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC), the 
thalamus, and the temporal cortex in patients 
with chronic pain conditions.
of the cortico-thalamic “brake” on nociceptive pathways. 
Such an outcome could cause not only increased pain 
perception, but diminished executive functioning, 
389

STAHL’S ESSENTIAL PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
sometimes called “fibro-fog” in fibromyalgia. In Chapter 
6 we discussed how stress-related HPA (hypothalamicpituitary-adrenal) axis abnormalities in CRF–ACTH–
cortisol regulation may be linked to hippocampal atrophy 
(see Figure 6-32), possibly linked to reduced availability 
of growth factors (Figures 6-27 and 6-29). Alterations in 
growth factors may be linked to the reports of reduction 
in gray-matter volume in chronic pain syndromes 
(fibromyalgia and low back pain), but in different 
brain regions (DLPFC, temporal cortex, and thalamus) 
(Figure 9-10) than reported for depression (Figure 6-30). 
Gray matter may actually be increased in other brain 
regions in chronic pain.
Although still preliminary, these findings suggest 
a possible structural consequence to suprasegmental 
central sensitization (Figure 9-10), not unlike that 
suspected for depression and stress (Figure 6-30). 
Abnormal pain processing, exaggerated pain responses, 
and perpetual pain could hypothetically be linked to 
deficiencies in the DLPFC circuit and its regulation 
by dopamine, and provide a potential explanation 
for the cognitive difficulties associated with chronic 
pain, especially fibro-fog in fibromyalgia (Figure 9-8). 
Thalamic abnormalities could hypothetically be linked 
to problems sleeping as well as nonrestorative sleep seen 
in chronic pain syndromes (Figure 9-8). Thus, chronic 
pain syndromes not only cause pain, but also problems 
with fatigue, mental concentration, sleep, depression, 
and anxiety (Figure 9-8). Structural brain abnormalities 
associated with inefficient information processing in 
brain areas that mediate these symptoms (Figure 9-9) 
may explain why these various symptoms (Figure 9-8) are 
frequently associated with chronic pain syndromes.
DESCENDING SPINAL SYNAPSES 
IN THE DORSAL HORN AND THE 
TREATMENT OF CHRONIC PAIN
The periaqueductal gray is the site of origin and 
regulation of much of the descending inhibition that 
projects down the spinal cord to the dorsal horn 
(Figure 9-2). The periaqueductal gray is discussed in 
relationship to its connections with the amygdala and 
the motor component of the fear response in Chapter 
8 and illustrated in Figure 8-9. The periaqueductal 
gray also integrates inputs from nociceptive pathways 
and limbic structures such as the amygdala and limbic 
cortex, and sends outputs to brainstem nuclei and 
the rostroventromedial medulla to drive descending 
inhibitory pathways. Some of these descending pathways 
release endorphins, which act via mostly presynaptic 
μ-opioid receptors to inhibit neurotransmission from 
nociceptive primary afferent neurons (Figure 9-2). Spinal 
μ-opioid receptors are one target of opioid analgesics; 
so are μ-opioid receptors in the periaqueductal gray 
itself (Figure 9-11). Interestingly, since Aβ fibers (Figure 
9-1) do not express μ-opioid receptors, this may explain 
why opioid analgesics spare normal sensory input. 
Enkephalins, which also act via δ-opioid receptors, are 
also antinociceptive, whereas dynorphins, acting at 
κ-opioid receptors, can be either anti- or pronociceptive. 
It is also interesting that opiates in general are no more 
effective for chronic neuropathic pain states than SNRIs 
or α2δ ligands, but in many cases, such as in fibromyalgia, 
opiates are not proven to be effective at all.
Two other important descending inhibitory pathways 
are also shown in Figure 9-2. One is the descending spinal 
norepinephrine pathway (Figure 9-12A), which originates 
in the locus coeruleus, and especially from noradrenergic 
cell bodies in the lower (caudal) parts of the brainstem 
neurotransmitter center (lateral tegmental norepinephrine 
cell system). The other important descending pathway 
is the descending spinal serotonergic pathway (Figure 
9-13A), which originates in the nucleus raphe magnus of 
the rostroventromedial medulla and especially the lower 
(caudal) serotonin nuclei (raphe magnus, raphe pallidus, 
and raphe obscuris). Descending noradrenergic neurons 
inhibit neurotransmitter release from primary afferents 
directly via inhibitory α2 adrenoceptors (Figure 9-2), 
explaining why direct-acting α2 agonists such as clonidine 
can be useful in relieving pain in some patients. Serotonin 
inhibits primary afferent terminals via postsynaptic 
5HT1B/D receptors (Figure 9-2). These inhibitory receptors 
are G-protein-coupled, and indirectly influence ion 
channels to hyperpolarize the nerve terminal and inhibit 
nociceptive neurotransmitter release. However, serotonin 
is also a major transmitter in descending facilitation 
pathways to the spinal cord. Serotonin released onto some 
primary afferent neuron terminals in certain areas of 
the dorsal horn acts predominantly via excitatory 5HT3 
receptors to enhance neurotransmitter release from these 
primary afferent neurons (Figure 9-2). The combination 
of both inhibitory and facilitatory actions of serotonin 
may explain why SSRIs (selective serotonin reuptake 
inhibitors), with actions that increase only serotonin 
levels, are not consistently useful in the treatment of 
pain, whereas SNRIs, with actions on both serotonin and 
norepinephrine, are now proven to be effective in various 
neuropathic pain states, including diabetic peripheral 
neuropathic pain and fibromyalgia.

Chapter 9: Chronic Pain and Its Treatment
Figure 9-11  Acute nociceptive pain and opioids.  The periaqueductal gray integrates inputs from nociceptive pathways and limbic 
structures and sends outputs to drive descending inhibitory pathways, including descending opioid projections. (A) Shown here is 
nociceptive input from a peripheral injury being transmitted to the brain and interpreted as pain. The descending opioid projection is 
not activated and thus is not inhibiting the nociceptive input. (B) Endogenous opioid release in the descending opioid projection, or 
exogenous administration of an opioid, can cause inhibition of nociceptive neurotransmission in the dorsal horn or in the periaqueductal 
gray and thus prevent or reduce the experience of pain.
A
B
OUCH!
OUCH!
Acute Nociceptive Pain 
descending 
opioid
projections
periaqueductal
gray
sprain
broken bone
dental extraction
sprain
broken bone
dental extraction
opioid
opioid
Anatomic Site of Action of Opioids

STAHL’S ESSENTIAL PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
back
pain
stomach
pain
muscle/
joint
pain
back
pain
stomach
pain
muscle/
joint
pain
A
B
Descending NE Inhibition of Pain
descending 
NE 
projections
normal
NE release
deficient
NE release
Deficient NE Inhibition Leads to Pain
digestion
digestion
back posture
muscle/joint movement
back posture
muscle/joint movement
Figure 9-12A, B  Descending noradrenergic neurons and pain.  (A) The descending spinal norepinephrine (NE) pathway originates 
in the locus coeruleus. Descending NE neurons inhibit neurotransmitter release from primary afferent neurons via presynaptic α2 
adrenoceptors, and inhibit activity of dorsal horn neurons via postsynaptic α2 adrenoceptors. This suppresses bodily input (e.g., 
regarding muscles/joints or digestion) from reaching the brain and thus prevents it from being interpreted as painful. (B) If descending 
NE inhibition is deficient, then it may not be sufficient to mask irrelevant nociceptive input, potentially leading to perception of pain 
from input that is normally ignored. This may be a contributing factor for painful somatic symptoms in fibromyalgia, depression, irritable 
bowel syndrome, and anxiety disorders.

Chapter 9: Chronic Pain and Its Treatment
Descending inhibition is also activated during severe 
injury by incoming nociceptive input, and in dangerous 
“conflict” situations via limbic structures, causing the 
release of endogenous opioid peptides (Figure 9-11B), 
serotonin (Figure 9-13A), and norepinephrine (Figure 
9-12A). When this happens, this reduces not only the 
release of nociceptive neurotransmitters in the dorsal 
horn (Figure 9-2) but also the transmission of nociceptive 
impulses up the spinal cord into the brain (Figure 9-3), 
thereby reducing the perception of pain, dulling it to 
allow escape from the situation without the injury 
compromising physical performance in the short run 
(reduction of “ouch” in Figure 9-3). On return to safety, 
descending facilitation replaces the inhibition to redress 
the balance, increase awareness of the injury, and force 
rest of the injured part (lots of “ouch” in Figure 9-3).
The power of this system can be seen in humans 
persevering through severe injury on the sports 
field and on the battle field. The placebo effect may 
also involve endogenous opioid release from these 
descending inhibitory neurons (Figure 9-11B), since 
activation of a placebo response to pain is reversible by 
the μ-opioid antagonist naloxone. These are adaptive 
Descending inhibition, mostly via serotonin and 
noradrenergic pathways, is normally active at rest and 
is thought to act physiologically to mask perception 
of irrelevant nociceptive input (e.g., from digestion, 
joint movement, etc.) (Figures 9-12A and 9-13A). 
One hypothesis for why patients with depression or 
fibromyalgia or related chronic pain disorders perceive 
pain when there is no obvious sign of peripheral 
trauma is that descending inhibition may not be acting 
adequately to mask irrelevant nociceptive input. This 
leads to the perception of pain from what is actually 
normal input that is ordinarily ignored (Figures 9-12B 
and 9-13B). If this descending monoaminergic inhibition 
is enhanced with an SNRI, irrelevant nociceptive inputs 
from joints, muscles, and the back in fibromyalgia and 
depression, and from digestion and the gastrointestinal 
tract in irritable bowel syndrome, depression, and anxiety 
disorders, are hypothetically once again ignored and 
thus are no longer perceived as painful (Figures 9-12C 
and 9-13C). SNRIs include duloxetine, milnacipran, 
levomilnacipran, venlafaxine, desvenlafaxine, and some 
tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs). SNRIs and TCAs are 
discussed extensively in Chapter 7.
Figure 9-12C  Enhancement of descending noradrenergic inhibition.  A serotonin–norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor (SNRI) can 
increase noradrenergic neurotransmission in the descending spinal pathway to the dorsal horn, and thus may enhance inhibition of 
bodily input so that it does not reach the brain and get interpreted as pain.
C
SNRI Action Boosts NE Inhibition of Pain
descending 
NE 
projections
SNRI
boosts NE
back
pain
stomach
pain
digestion
= SNRI
muscle/
joint
pain
back posture
muscle/joint movement

STAHL’S ESSENTIAL PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
Figure 9-13A, B  Descending serotonergic neurons and pain.  (A) The descending spinal serotonin (5HT) pathway originates in the 
raphe nucleus. Descending serotonergic (5HT) neurons directly inhibit activity of dorsal horn neurons, predominantly via 5HT1B/D 
receptors. This suppresses bodily input (e.g., regarding muscles/joints or digestion) from reaching the brain and thus prevents it from 
being interpreted as painful. (B) If descending 5HT inhibition is deficient, it may not be sufficient to mask irrelevant nociceptive input, 
potentially leading to perception of pain from input that is normally ignored. This may be a contributing factor for painful somatic 
symptoms in fibromyalgia, depression, irritable bowel syndrome, and anxiety disorders.
A
B
Descending 5HT Inhibition of Pain
descending 
5HT
projections
normal
5HT release
deficient
5HT release
Deficient 5HT Inhibition Leads to Pain
back
pain
stomach
pain
muscle/
joint
pain
back
pain
stomach
pain
digestion
muscle/
joint
pain
digestion
back posture
muscle/joint movement
back posture
muscle/joint movement

Chapter 9: Chronic Pain and Its Treatment
voltage-sensitive calcium channels (VSCCs; Figure 9-14), 
which is often coupled to the release of glutamate, but also 
to aspartate, substance P (SP), calcitonin-gene-related 
peptide (CGRP), and other neurotransmitters (Figure 9-2). 
When this occurs at suprasegmental levels in the thalamus 
and cortex, it is likely linked to release mostly of glutamate 
via the same N-type and P/Q-type VSCCs (Figures 9-14 
and 9-15). The idea is that low release of neurotransmitter 
creates no pain response because there is insufficient 
neurotransmitter release to stimulate the postsynaptic 
receptors (Figure 9-14A). However, normal amounts of 
neurotransmitter release cause a full nociceptive pain 
response and acute pain (Figure 9-14B). Hypothetically, 
in states of central sensitization, there is excessive 
and unnecessary ongoing nociceptive activity causing 
neuropathic pain (Figure 9-15A). Blocking VSCCs with the 
α2δ ligands gabapentin or pregabalin (Figures 9-15B and 
9-16) inhibits release of various neurotransmitters in the 
dorsal horn (Figures 9-2, 9-15B, and 9-17A) or in thalamus 
and cortex (Figures 9-15B and 9-17B) and has indeed 
proven to be an effective treatment for various disorders 
causing neuropathic pain. Gabapentin and pregabalin 
changes within the pain pathways that facilitate 
survival and enhance function for the individual. 
However, maladaptive changes can also hijack these 
same mechanisms to inappropriately maintain pain 
without relevant tissue injury, as may occur in various 
forms of neuropathic pain, ranging from diabetes to 
fibromyalgia and beyond.
TARGETING SENSITIZED 
CIRCUITS IN CHRONIC PAIN 
CONDITIONS
Chronic pain perpetuated as a marker of an irreversible 
sensitization process within the central nervous system 
has already been discussed as a disorder triggered by 
progressive molecular changes due to abnormal neuronal 
activity within the pain pathway, sometimes called 
central sensitization. When this occurs at the spinal 
or segmental level, it is likely linked to the multiple 
different neurotransmitters released there, with each 
neurotransmitter’s release mechanism requiring presynaptic 
depolarization and activation of N-type and P/Q-type 
Figure 9-13C  Enhancement of descending serotonergic inhibition.  A serotonin–norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor (SNRI) can increase 
serotonergic neurotransmission in the descending spinal pathway to the dorsal horn, and thus may enhance inhibition of bodily input 
so that it does not reach the brain and get interpreted as pain. However, the noradrenergic effects of SNRIs may be more relevant to 
suppression of nociceptive input.
C
SNRI Action Boosts 5HT Inhibition of Pain
descending 
5HT
projections
SNRI
boosts 5HT 
back
pain
stomach
pain
digestion
= SNRI
muscle/
joint
pain
back posture
muscle/joint movement

STAHL’S ESSENTIAL PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
Figure 9-14  Activity-dependent nociception in pain pathways, part 1: acute pain.  The degree of nociceptive neuronal activity in pain 
pathways determines whether one experiences acute pain. An action potential on a presynaptic neuron triggers sodium influx, which 
in turn leads to calcium influx, and ultimately release of neurotransmitter. (A) In some cases, the action potential generated at the 
presynaptic neuron causes minimal neurotransmitter release; thus the postsynaptic neuron is not notably stimulated and the nociceptive 
input does not reach the brain (in other words, there is no pain). (B) In other cases, a stronger action potential at the presynaptic neuron 
may cause voltage-sensitive calcium channels (VSCCs) to remain open longer, allowing more neurotransmitter release and more 
stimulation of the postsynaptic neuron. Thus, the nociceptive input is transmitted to the brain and acute pain occurs.
A
no pain
Subthreshold Pain Response
Full Nociceptive Activity
B
acute pain
N
P/Q
N
P/Q
N
P/Q
N
P/Q

Chapter 9: Chronic Pain and Its Treatment
Figure 9-15  Activity-dependent nociception in pain pathways, part 2: neuropathic pain.  The degree of nociceptive neuronal activity 
in pain pathways determines whether one experiences acute pain. An action potential on a presynaptic neuron triggers sodium 
influx, which in turn leads to calcium influx, and ultimately release of neurotransmitter. (A) Strong or repetitive action potentials can 
cause prolonged opening of calcium channels, which may lead to excessive release of neurotransmitter into the synaptic cleft, and 
consequently to excessive stimulation of postsynaptic neurons. Ultimately this may induce molecular, synaptic, and structural changes, 
including sprouting, which are the theoretical substrates for central sensitization syndromes. In other words, this can lead to neuropathic 
pain. (B) Alpha-2-delta ligands such as gabapentin or pregabalin bind to the α2δ subunit of voltage-sensitive calcium channels (VSCCs), 
changing their conformation to reduce calcium influx and therefore reduce excessive stimulation of postsynaptic receptors.
A
dorsal horn, thalamus,
or cortex
neuropathic pain
B
neuropathic pain
Central Sensitization and
Excessive Nociceptive Activity
Relief of Painful Excessive Nociceptive 
Activity in Central Sensitization
= alpha-2delta ligand
N
P/Q
N
P/Q
N
P/Q
N
P/Q

STAHL’S ESSENTIAL PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
gabapentin
pregabalin
VSCC
 2 site
VSCC
 2 site
OUCH!
OUCH!
(Figure 9-16) may more selectively bind the “open-channel” 
conformation of VSCCs (Figures 9-17 and 9-18), and thus 
be particularly effective in blocking those channels that are 
the most active, with a “use-dependent” form of inhibition 
Figure 9-16  Gabapentin and 
pregabalin.  Shown here are icons 
of the pharmacological actions of 
gabapentin and pregabalin. These 
agents bind to the α2δ subunit of 
voltage-sensitive calcium channels 
(VSCCs).
Figure 9-17  Anatomic actions of α2δ 
ligands.  (A) Alpha-2-delta ligands 
may bind to voltage-sensitive calcium 
channels in the dorsal horn to reduce 
excitatory neurotransmission and 
alleviate pain. (B) Alpha-2-delta ligands 
may also bind to voltage-sensitive 
calcium channels in the thalamus 
and cortex to reduce excitatory 
neurotransmission and alleviate pain.
(Figures 9-17B and 9-18B). This molecular action predicts 
more affinity for centrally sensitized VSCCs that are actively 
conducting neuronal impulses within the pain pathway. 
Thus, they have a selective action on those VSCCs causing

Molecular Action of Alpha-2-Delta Ligands
A. Open conformation of VSCC
inside the cell
ß
N
P/Q
outside the cell
Ca++
B. Alpha-2-delta ligand binding to open 
conformation and inhibiting VSCC
ß
N
P/Q
C. Closed conformation of VSCC
ß
N
P/Q
Figure 9-18  Binding of α2δ ligands.  (A) Calcium influx occurs 
when voltage-sensitive calcium channels (VSCCs) are in the 
open-channel conformation. (B) Alpha-2-delta ligands such as 
gabapentin and pregabalin have greatest affinity for the openchannel conformation and thus block those channels that are 
most active. (C) When VSCCs are in the closed conformation 
α2δ ligands do not bind and thus do not disrupt normal 
neurotransmission.
neuropathic pain, ignoring other VSCCs that are not open, 
and thus not interfering with normal neurotransmission in 
central neurons uninvolved in mediating the pathological 
pain state.
Treatment of pain, including neuropathic pain 
conditions, may be less costly when you “pay” for it 
Chapter 9: Chronic Pain and Its Treatment
in advance, or at least early in the game. The hope is 
that early treatment of pain could interfere with the 
development of chronic persistent painful conditions 
by blocking the ability of painful experiences to imprint 
themselves upon the central nervous system by not 
allowing triggering of central sensitization. Thus, the 
mechanisms whereby symptomatic suffering of chronic 
neuropathic pain is relieved, such as with SNRIs or α2δ 
ligands, may also be the same mechanisms that could 
prevent disease progression to chronic persistent pain 
states. This notion calls for aggressive treatment of 
painful symptoms in these conditions that theoretically 
have their origin within the central nervous system, thus 
“intercepting” the central sensitization process before 
it is durably imprinted into angry circuits. Thus, major 
depression and anxiety disorders and fibromyalgia can 
all be treated with SNRIs and/or α2δ ligands to eliminate 
painful physical symptoms and thereby improve the 
chances of reaching full symptomatic remission. The 
opportunity to prevent permanent pain syndromes 
or progressive worsening of pain is one reason why 
pain is increasingly being considered a psychiatric 
“vital sign” that must be assessed routinely in the 
evaluation and treatment of psychiatric disorders by 
psychopharmacologists. Future testing of agents capable 
of reducing pain should be done to determine whether 
eliminating painful symptoms early in the course of 
psychiatric and functional somatic illnesses will improve 
outcomes, including preventing symptomatic relapses, 
the development of treatment resistance or even brain 
atrophy from stress in pain states (Figure 9-9), and 
hippocampal atrophy from stress in anxiety and affective 
disorders (Figure 6-30). Pre-emptively treating pain 
before it occurs, or at least rescuing centrally mediated 
and sensitizing pain by intercepting such pain before it 
becomes permanent, may be some of the most promising 
therapeutic applications of dual reuptake inhibitors and 
α2δ ligands and deserves careful clinical evaluation.
TARGETING ANCILLARY 
SYMPTOMS IN FIBROMYALGIA
We have repeatedly mentioned the proven usefulness 
of the α2δ ligands gabapentin and pregabalin and 
the SNRIs duloxetine, milnacipran, venlafaxine, and 
desvenlafaxine for treating the painful symptoms of 
fibromyalgia, yet these two classes have not been studied 
extensively in combination. Nevertheless, they are 
frequently used together in clinical practice on an empiric 
basis and anecdotally have been shown to give additive 
399

STAHL’S ESSENTIAL PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
improvement in relieving pain. Each class of drug may 
also help different ancillary symptoms in fibromyalgia, 
so the combination of α2δ ligands with SNRIs may lead to 
broader symptom relief than using either alone, although 
both are effective for pain in fibromyalgia. That is, α2δ 
ligands may reduce symptoms of anxiety in fibromyalgia 
(see discussion of α2δ ligands in anxiety in Chapter 8 and 
illustrated in Figures 8-17C and 8-18C) and for improving 
the slow-wave sleep disorder of fibromyalgia (sleep 
disorders and their treatment are discussed in further 
detail in Chapter 10). SNRIs can be useful in reducing 
symptoms of depression and anxiety in fibromyalgia 
(see Chapter 7 on treatment for mood disorders) and 
for treating fatigue as well as the cognitive symptoms 
associated with fibromyalgia, sometimes also called fibrofog (see Figures 9-8 and 9-9). Problems with executive 
functioning in a wide variety of clinical conditions are 
generally linked to inefficient information processing 
in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) where 
dopamine neurotransmission is important in regulating 
brain circuits (see Chapter 4 on cognition in schizophrenia 
and Figure 4-17). This concept of dopaminergic 
regulation of cognition in the DLPFC and the role of 
boosting dopamine neurotransmission to improve 
executive dysfunction is also discussed in Chapter 11 
on attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Since SNRIs 
increase dopamine concentrations in the DLPFC (see 
Figure 7-33C), SNRI agents can also potentially improve 
symptoms of fibro-fog in fibromyalgia patients. This 
may be particularly so for the SNRIs milnacipran and 
levomilnacipran, which have potent norepinephrine 
reuptake binding properties at all clinically effective doses 
(Figures 7-30 and 7-31), or for higher doses of the SNRIs 
duloxetine (Figure 7-29), venlafaxine, and desvenlafaxine 
(Figure 7-28), which act to increase norepinephrine 
reuptake blocking properties of these agents and thus act 
to increase concentrations of dopamine in the DLPFC 
(Figure 7-33C). Other strategies for improving fibro-fog 
in fibromyalgia patients include the same ones used to 
treat cognitive dysfunction in depression, and include 
modafinil, armodafinil, selective norepinephrine reuptake 
inhibitors (NRIs) such as atomoxetine, norepinephrine–
dopamine reuptake inhibitors (NDRIs) such as bupropion, 
and with caution, stimulants. SNRIs, sometimes 
augmented with modafinil, stimulants, or bupropion can 
also be useful for symptoms of physical fatigue as well as 
mental fatigue in fibromyalgia patients.
Second-line treatments for pain in fibromyalgia 
can include sedating drugs for depression including 
mirtazapine and tricyclic antidepressants, as well as 
the tricyclic muscle relaxant cyclobenzapine. Other 
sleep aids such as benzodiazepines, hypnotics, and 
trazodone can be helpful in relieving sleep disturbance 
in fibromyalgia. Evidence is also accumulating for the 
efficacy of γ-hydroxybutyrate (GHB or sodium oxybate) 
in fibromyalgia (use with extreme caution because of 
diversion and abuse potential). GHB is approved for 
narcolepsy, enhances slow-wave sleep, and is discussed 
in Chapter 10 on sleep (see Figures 10-67 and 10-68). In 
heroic cases the use of GHB by experts for the treatment 
of severe and treatment-resistant cases of fibromyalgia 
may be justified. A number of anticonvulsants other than 
the α2δ ligands (Figure 9-16) are also used second-line for 
chronic neuropathic pain states, including fibromyalgia. 
These agents are thought to target voltage-gated sodium 
channels rather than voltage-gated calcium channels 
and thus seem to have a different mechanism of action 
than α2δ ligands and may be effective in patients with 
inadequate response to α2δ ligands.
SUMMARY
This chapter has defined pain, and has explained 
the processing of nociceptive neuronal activity into 
the perception of pain by pathways that lead to the 
spinal cord, and then up the spinal cord to the brain. 
Neuropathic pain is discussed extensively, including 
both peripheral and central mechanisms, and the 
concept of central sensitization. The key role of 
descending inhibitory pathways that reduce the activity 
of nociceptive pain neurons with the release of serotonin 
and norepinephrine is explained, and shown to be 
the basis for the actions of serotonin–norepinephrine 
reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs) as agents that reduce the 
perception of pain in conditions ranging from major 
depression to fibromyalgia to diabetic peripheral 
neuropathic pain, low back pain, osteoarthritis, and 
related conditions. The critical role of voltage-sensitive 
calcium channels (VSCCs) is also explained, providing 
the basis for the actions of α2δ ligands as agents that 
also reduce the perception of pain in diabetic peripheral 
neuropathic pain, fibromyalgia, painful physical 
symptoms of depression and anxiety disorders, shingles, 
and other neuropathic pain conditions. Finally, the 
spectrum of conditions from affective disorders to 
chronic neuropathic pain disorders is introduced, with 
emphasis on the condition of fibromyalgia and its newly 
evolving psychopharmacological treatments.