12.12.2 Hereditary periodic fever syndromes 2207
12.12.2 Hereditary periodic fever syndromes 2207
12.12.2 Hereditary periodic fever syndromes
2207
Liuzzo G, et al. (1994). The prognostic value of C-reactive protein and
serum amyloid A protein in severe unstable angina. N Engl J Med,
331, 417–24.
Lowe GDO, Pepys MB (2006). C-reactive protein and cardiovascular
disease: weighing the evidence. Curr Atheroscler Rep, 8, 421–8.
Pepys MB (2005). CRP or not CRP? That is the question. Arterioscler
Thromb Vasc Biol, 25, 1091–4.
Pepys MB, Hirschfield GM (2003). C-reactive protein: a critical up-
date. J Clin Invest, 111, 1805–12.
Pepys MB, Lanham JG, de Beer FC (1982). C-reactive protein in sys-
temic lupus erythematosus. Clin Rheum Dis, 8, 91–103.
Pepys MB, et al. (2005). Proinflammatory effects of bacterial recombinant
human C-reactive protein are caused by contamination with bacterial
products, not by C-reactive protein itself. Circ Res, 97, e97–103.
Pepys MB, et al. (2006). Targeting C-reactive protein for the treatment
of cardiovascular disease. Nature, 440, 1217–21.
Pepys MB (2018).The Pentraxins 1975–2018: Serendipity, Diagnostics
and Drugs. Front Immunol, 9, 2382.
Ridker PM, et al. (1997). Inflammation, aspirin, and the risk of cardio-
vascular disease in apparently healthy men. N Engl J Med, 336, 973–9.
Riess W, et al. (2018). First in man: case report of selective C-reactive pro-
tein apheresis in a patient with acute ST segment elevation myocardial
infarction. https://www.hindawi.com/journals/cric/2018/4767105/
Simons JP, et al. (2014). C-reactive protein is essential for innate resist-
ance to pneumococcal infection. Immunology, 142, 414–20.
Starke ID, et al. (1984). Serum C-reactive protein levels in the man-
agement of infection in acute leukaemia. Eur J Cancer, 20, 319–25.
van Leeuwen MA, et al. (1997). Individual relationship between pro-
gression of radiological damage and the acute phase response in
early rheumatoid arthritis. Towards development of a decision sup-
port system. J Rheumatol, 24, 20–7.
Wasunna A, et al. (1990). C-reactive protein and bacterial infection in
preterm infants. Eur J Pediatr, 149, 424–7.
12.12.2 Hereditary periodic
fever syndromes
Helen J. Lachmann, Stefan Berg,
and Philip N. Hawkins
ESSENTIALS
The hereditary periodic fever syndromes or hereditary auto
inflammatory diseases are disorders of innate immunity that mostly
present in childhood and are characterized by recurrent, self-
limiting, seemingly unprovoked episodes of fever and systemic in-
flammation that occur in the absence of autoantibody production
or identifiable infection.
Disorders include (1) familial Mediterranean fever (FMF), due to
mutations in the gene encoding pyrin; (2) tumour necrosis factor
(TNF) receptor-associated periodic syndrome (TRAPS), due to mu-
tations in a gene for a TNF receptor; (3) mevalonate kinase defi-
ciency (MKD), caused by mutations in the mevalonate kinase gene;
and (4) the cryopyrin-associated periodic syndromes (CAPS), which
include (a) familial cold urticarial syndrome, (b) Muckle–Wells syn-
drome, and (c) chronic infantile neurological, cutaneous, and ar-
ticular syndrome. With advances in genetics, further syndromes are
continually being recognized. These are all extremely rare and in the
majority are only known to affect a handful of kindred or individuals.
Understanding of the molecular pathogenesis of these disorders
provides unique insights into the regulation of innate immunity and
inflammation.
Diagnosis relies on recognition of suggestive clinical features (e.g.
fever with peritonitis and/or pleurisy, arthralgia/arthritis) that are al-
most always accompanied by a substantial acute phase response,
and is supported by genetic testing. With the exception of FMF,
which is a common disease in certain geographic areas, hereditary
periodic fever syndromes are rare and easily overlooked in the differ-
ential diagnosis of recurrent fevers.
Clinical features and management—attacks can be mild to debili-
tating and short to prolonged, while their most feared complication is
AA amyloidosis. Effective therapies are available for some syndromes,
for example: (1) FMF—daily prophylactic colchicine prevents clinical
attacks and susceptibility to AA amyloidosis, (2) CAPS—treatment
with anti-IL-1 agents produces rapid and often complete clinical and
serological remission, and (3) TRAPS—anti-IL therapies are extremely
effective.
Introduction
The hereditary periodic fever syndromes are a group of multisystem
disorders characterized by fluctuating or irregularly recurring epi-
sodes of fever and systemic inflammation, notably affecting the
joints, eyes, skin, and serosal surfaces. More than 30 syndromes
are now recognized; many of these are extremely rare and only af-
fect a handful of individuals. Diseases affecting more than 1 per
million, and therefore likely to be encountered in specialist prac-
tice, include familial Mediterranean fever (FMF), tumour necrosis
factor (TNF) receptor-associated periodic syndrome (TRAPS),
mevalonate kinase deficiency (MKD, previously known as the
hyperimmunoglobulin D and periodic fever syndrome (HIDS)),
and the cryopyrin-associated periodic syndromes (CAPS). The
latter are a spectrum of three hitherto apparently distinct dis-
orders of increasing severity: familial cold urticarial syndrome
(now known as familial cold autoinflammatory syndrome; FCAS),
Muckle–Wells syndrome (MWS), and chronic infantile neuro-
logical, cutaneous, and articular syndrome (CINCA). The latter
is also known in the United States of America as neonatal-onset
multisystem inflammatory disorder (NOMID).
Although many symptoms of these disorders are shared, there
are clear distinctions in the pattern of their inheritance, the dur-
ation and frequency of attacks, and their overall clinical picture
(Table 12.12.2.1). With a few exceptions, these diseases are usu-
ally compatible with normal life expectancy, though with the
ever-looming grave threat of AA amyloidosis. Recent insights
into their molecular pathogenesis have led to enhanced diagnosis
through DNA analysis, the development of rational therapies,
and have shed important new light on regulation of the innate
immune system.
section 12 Metabolic disorders 2208 Table 12.12.2.1 Features of inherited periodic fever syndromes Periodic fever syndrome Gene, chromosome OMIM Mode of inheritance Predominant population Usual age at onset Potential precipitants of attacks Distinctive clinical features Typical duration of attacks Typical frequency of attacks Characteristic laboratory abnormalities Treatment FMF MEFV, chromosome 16 249100 608107 Autosomal recessive (dominant in rare families) Eastern Mediterranean Childhood/ early adulthood Usually none Occasionally menstruation, fasting, stress, or trauma Short severe attacks of peritonitic and/or pleuritic pain, colchicine- responsive, erysipelas-like erythema 1–3 days Variable Marked acute phase response during attacks Colchicine TRAPS TNFRSF1A, chromosome 12 142680 191190 Autosomal dominant (can be de novo) Northern European, but reported in many ethnic groups Childhood/ early adulthood Usually none Prolonged symptoms More than a week (may be very prolonged) Variable (may be continuous) Marked acute phase response during attacks Low levels of soluble TNFR1 when well Anti-IL- 1therapies High-dose corticosteroids MKD MVK, chromosome 12 260920 251170 Autosomal recessive Northern European, but reported in many ethnic groups Infancy Immunizations Diarrhoea and lymphadenopathy. 3–7 days 1–2 monthly Acute phase response, and mevalonate aciduria during attacks, elevated IgD and IgA Anti-IL-1 therapies, anti- TNF therapies, anti-IL-6 therapies FCAS NLRP3, chromosome 1 120100 606416 Autosomal dominant Northern but reported in many ethnic groups European, Neonatal/ infancy Exposure to cold environment Cold-induced fever, arthralgia, rash, and red eye 24–48 h Depends on environmental factors Acute phase response during attacks; to a lesser extent when well Cold avoidance, anti-IL-1 therapies MWS NLRP3, chromosome 1 191900 606416 Autosomal dominant, Northern European, but reported in many ethnic groups Neonatal/ infancy Marked diurnal variation Cold environment, but less marked than in FCAS Urticarial rash, red eye, sensorineural deafness Continuous (often worse in the evenings) Often daily Varying but marked acute phase response most of the time Anti-IL-1 therapies CINCA/ NOMID NLRP3, chromosome 1 607115 606416 Sporadic Northern European, but reported in many ethnic groups Neonatal/ infancy None Urticarial rash, aseptic meningitis, deforming arthropathy, sensorineural deafness, developmental damage Continuous Continuous Varying but marked acute phase response most of the time Anti-IL-1 therapies PAPA PSTPIP1 (CD2BP1), chromosome 15 604416 606347 Autosomal dominant Northern European, but reported in many ethnic groups Childhood None Pyogenic arthritis, pyoderma gangrenosum, and cystic acne Intermittent attacks with migratory arthritis Variable (may be continuous) Acute phase response during attacks Anti-TNF therapies
12.12.2 Hereditary periodic fever syndromes 2209 (continued) Blau’s syndrome NOD2 (CARD15), chromosome 16 605956 186580 Autosomal dominant None Age <5 years None Granulomatous polyarthritis, iritis, and dermatitis Continuous Continuous Sustained modest acute phase response Corticosteroids, some reports of benefit from anti-TNF agents FCAS2 NLRP12, chromosome 19 611762 609648 Autosomal dominant South/Central American, but reported in other ethnic groups Neonatal Sometimes exposure to cold Urticarial rash, fever, arthralgia Intermittent Variable Acute phase response during attacks None know DIRA IL1RN, chromosome 2 612852 147679 Autosomal recessive Northern Europe and Central America Infancy None Pustular rash, sterile osteomyelitis of long bones Continuous Continuous Sustained acute phase response Anakinra (recombinant IL-1 receptor antagonist) Majeed’s syndrome LIPN2, chromosome 18 609628 605519 Autosomal recessive Middle East Infancy None Recurrent multifocal osteomyelitis, congenital dyserythropoietic anaemia, neutrophilic dermatosis 2-7 days Variable Acute phase response during attacks NSAIDs and corticosteroids. Possible benefit from IL-1 blocking agents DITRA IL36RN, chromosome 2 614204 605507 Autosomal recessive None Variable— from infancy onwards Drug initiation or withdrawal, menstrual cycle, pregnancy Recurrent fever, generalized rash, and disseminated pustules often but not always on a background of psoriasis Intermittent Variable Acute phase response during attacks, typical spongiform pustules on skin biopsy Possible benefit from IL-1 blocking agents CANDLE/JMP PSMB8, chromosome 6 256040 177046 Autosomal recessive None Infancy None Lipodystrophy, characteristic rash, swollen lips, violaceous eyelids Continuous Continuous Acute phase response, typical appearances on skin biopsy None established? JAK inhibitors Early-onset inflammatory bowel disease/IL-10R deficiency IL10RA, chromosome 11, IL10RB, chromosome 21, or IL-10, chromosome1 613148 612567 612381 Autosomal recessive None Infancy None Very early- onset severe inflammatory bowel disease with perianal fistulae Continuous Continuous Acute phase response, colitis with granulomas Stem cell transplantation APLAID PLCG2, chromosome 16 614878 600220 Autosomal dominant Single family Infancy Rash worse with heat or sun exposure Recurrent blistering rash and mild humoral immune deficiency with sinopulmonary infections Continuous Continuous Acute phase response, dense inflammatory infiltrate in skin, decreased IgM and IgA, no autoantibodies Partial response to IL-1 blockade and corticosteroids
section 12 Metabolic disorders 2210 Periodic fever syndrome Gene, chromosome OMIM Mode of inheritance Predominant population Usual age at onset Potential precipitants of attacks Distinctive clinical features Typical duration of attacks Typical frequency of attacks Characteristic laboratory abnormalities Treatment HOIL-1 deficiency RBCK1, chromosome 20 615895 Autosomal recessive Two European families Infancy None Polyglucosan myopathy and cardiomyopathy with immunodeficiency and bacterial infection and autoinflammation Intermittent Intermittent Acute phase response, intracellular glycogen inclusions, on muscle biopsy All 4 cases died in childhood— symptomatic improvement with corticosteroids, allogenic stem cell transplantation attempted DADA2 CECR1, chromosome 22 615688 Autosomal recessive None Childhood None Systemic and local polyarteritis nodosa, livedo racemose, and early-onset stroke Intermittent Intermittent Acute phase response during attacks Anti-TNF SAVI TMEM173, chromosome 5 615934 Autosomal dominant None Infancy None Rash on cheeks, ears, nose, and digits with cartilage damage, failure to thrive, interstitial lung disease Continuous Continuous Capillary inflammation, acute phase response None established? JAK inhibitors APLAID, autoinflammation and PLCγ2-assocaited antibody deficiency and immune dysregulation, CINCA/NOMID, chronic infantile neurological, cutaneous, and articular syndrome/neonatal-onset multisystem inflammatory disorder; DADA2, deficiency of adenosine deaminase 2; DIRA, deficiency of the IL-1 receptor antagonist; DITRA, deficiency of the IL-36 receptor antagonist; FCAS, familial cold autoinflammatory syndrome; FMF, familial Mediterranean fever; HOIL-1, haem-oxidized IRP2 ubiquitin ligase 1; IL-1, interleukin 1; MKD, mevalonate kinase deficiency; MWS, Muckle–Wells syndrome; PAPA, pyogenic arthritis, pyoderma gangrenosum, and acne syndrome; SAVI, STING-associated vasculopathy with onset in infancy; TNF, tumour necrosis factor; TNFR1, tumour necrosis factor receptor 1; TRAPS, tumour necrosis factor receptor-associated periodic syndrome. Table 12.12.2.1 Continued
12.12.2 Hereditary periodic fever syndromes 2211 Historical perspective Although the hereditary periodic fever syndromes have only been identified as such during the last few decades, there are various ancient references to them, particularly FMF. Perhaps the earliest extant clinical description is found in William Heberden’s 1802 Commentaries on History and Care of Disease: ‘Pains which are regu- larly intermittent, the fits of which return periodically as those of an ague; such as I have known in the bowels, stomach, breast, loins, arms and hips, though it be but seldom that such parts suffer in such a manner.’ Familial Mediterranean fever Genetics FMF is predominantly inherited in a recessive manner. The gene as- sociated with FMF, MEFV, which encodes a protein called pyrin, was identified through positional cloning in 1997. MEFV is ex- pressed in neutrophils, monocytes, dendritic cells, and fibroblasts. Expression is up-regulated in response to inflammatory activators such as interferon-γ and TNFα. The more than 40 MEFV mutations that are associated with FMF encode either single amino acid substi- tutions or small deletions. The mutations that cause FMF are mostly in exon 10, but also occur elsewhere, particularly in exons 1, 3, 5, and 9. Mutations in each of the two MEFV alleles can be identified in most patients with FMF. Most individuals with a single mutated allele re- main healthy carriers but heterozygote FMF is well recognized and may account for up to 20% of cases. While it is inherently likely that different mutations will affect the function of a protein to differing extents, several findings suggest that the methionine residue at pos- ition 694 is especially important. Five different pathogenic exon 10 mutations involving Met694 have been identified, and individuals homozygous for Met694Val have particularly severe disease. Simple heterozygous deletion of this residue is associated with autosomal dominant FMF of variable penetrance in the British population. More extensive disruption of a single MEFV allele by one or more mutations may account for other rare reports of dominant FMF. Much more commonly, FMF affecting more than one generation of a family is pseudodominantly inherited, reflecting consanguinity or a high local prevalence of the heterozygous carrier state. One particular pyrin variant, E148Q encoded in exon 2, is ex- tremely frequent in Asian populations, with an allele frequency of 10 to 20%, and occurs in other populations at a much lower fre- quency. Although pyrin E148Q can cause typical FMF when coupled with various exon 10 mutations, homozygosity for E148Q alone is thought not to be associated with disease in the vast majority of cases. There is, however, a suggestion that the presence of pyrin E148Q might intensify non-FMF types of inflammation. Pathology Unusually, given the recessive inheritance, the mutations underlying FMF appear to result in gain of function. Pyrin is a key component of an inflammasome which activates caspase-1 by autoproteolysis. Maturation of interleukin (IL)-1β and IL-18 requires cleavage by caspase 1 which also induces macrophage pyroptosis. Assembly of inflammasomes is triggered by recognition of intracellular pathogen or damage-associated molecular patterns. Recent work suggests that pyrin is an indirect sensor of a wide variety of bacterial toxins; pyrin interacts, via its N-terminal death domain, with cytoskeleton microtubules and appears to detect pathological perturbation of actin polymerization dynamics caused by bacterial modification or inactivation of Rho GTPases. More than 20 other proteins that have homology with pyrin’s N-terminal sequence are now classified generically to have a pyrin domain and are members of the death domain superfamily. They play important roles in the assembly and activation of apoptotic and inflammatory complexes through homotypic protein–protein inter- actions. Proteins with pyrin domains are involved in inflammation, apoptosis, and nuclear factor (NF)-κB signalling and have been im- plicated in pathways in CAPS as well. Epidemiology FMF occurs worldwide, though predominantly in populations arising from the eastern Mediterranean basin, particularly non- Ashkenazi Jews, Armenians, Turks, and Levantine Arabs. The prevalence of FMF has been estimated to be 1 in 250 to 1 in 500 among non-Ashkenazi Jews and 1 in 1000 in the Turkish popula- tion. The carrier frequency is as high as one in five among Armenian, Turkish, and North African Jewish populations, fuelling speculation that the FMF trait may have conferred survival benefit, most likely through enhanced resistance to microbial infection mediated by up- regulation of the innate inflammatory response. Males and females are equally affected. FMF usually presents in childhood, in 60% be- fore the age of 10 years and in 90% by 20 years. Clinical features Attacks of FMF occur irregularly at variable frequencies and may be precipitated by physical and emotional stress, menstruation, and diet. The onset is rapid and symptoms resolve spontaneously within 6 to 72 h. Fever with peritonitis and/or pleurisy are the hallmark features, but occur with widely varying intensity from very mild to severely incapacitating. The clinical picture may mimic an acute surgical abdomen with ileus and vomiting, and 40% of patients undergo laparoscopy before the diagnosis is made. Pleuritic attacks occur in 40% of patients, characteristically unilaterally, either alone or in association with peritonitis. Pericarditis is rare and cardiac tamponade extremely rare. Headache with meningism is reported, but generally the nervous system is not involved in attacks. Orchitis occurs in less than 5% of males, most commonly in early childhood, when it can be confused with torsion of the testis. Transient arth- ralgia in lower-limb joints is not infrequent in acute attacks, and usually subsides within 2 to 4 days; dramatic acute oligoarthritis of the large joints of the lower limb can occur but chronic destructive inflammation is rare. There is a rare but genuine association be- tween FMF associated with MEFV M694V and chronic sacroiliitis. A characteristic erysipelas-like erythematous rash occurs in 20% of patients (Fig. 12.12.2.1), usually on the lower extremities. Myalgia can be part of the constitutional upset during acute attacks, but up to one-fifth of patients complain of persistent muscle pain on exer- tion, usually affecting the calves. The rare but distinct syndrome of protracted febrile myalgia presents as severe pain, mainly affecting the lower limbs or abdominal musculature; symptoms may persist for weeks and be accompanied by a vasculitic rash, but usually re- spond to corticosteroids.
section 12 Metabolic disorders 2212 Clinical investigation Acute attacks are accompanied by a number of laboratory abnor- malities including neutrophilia, raised ESR, and a dramatic acute phase response. Investigations may be required to exclude other potential causes of symptoms but, in general, imaging by radiog- raphy, ultrasonography, or echocardiography during acute attacks is unrewarding. The results of genetic testing must be interpreted with care, since some individuals with paired pathogenic MEFV mutations remain completely healthy, and others with apparent carrier status develop classical FMF. Furthermore, MEFV spans 10 exons, and most diag- nostic laboratories offer only limited screening. However, in classical populations, the absence of a mutation in exon 10 makes a diagnosis of FMF unlikely. Treatment Supportive treatment, including analgesia, may be required in acute attacks, but the mainstay of therapy in FMF is prophylaxis with colchicine, a serendipitous discovery made by Goldfinger in 1972. Continuous treatment with colchicine 1 to 2 mg daily prevents or substantially reduces the symptoms of FMF in at least 95% of cases. Recent data also suggest that colchicine acts by a number of mech- anisms including competition with pyrin for cleavage by caspase 1 thereby reducing the effect of N-terminal cleavage pyrin in enhan- cing NF-κB activation in FMF. Long-term use of colchicine is advisable in every patient with FMF and mandatory in those with AA amyloidosis. Although colchicine is extremely toxic in large overdose, the small regular doses required for the treatment of FMF are very well tolerated. Particularly at dose initiation colchicine may cause diarrhoea which often responds to a lactose-free diet. Despite theoretical concerns about antimitotic po- tential, large cohort studies are very reassuring about the use of col- chicine throughout conception and pregnancy. The concentration of colchicine in breast milk is sufficiently low to permit breastfeeding. Acute initiation or increase of the dose of colchicine does not usually ameliorate acute attacks. In the few patients who are genuinely resistant to colchicine, there have been reports of benefit in such patients following treat- ment with IL-1 blocking agents and a number of small trials have confirmed this. Tumour necrosis factor receptor-associated periodic syndrome Genetics TRAPS is an autosomal dominant disease associated with mutations in the 10-exon TNF receptor superfamily 1A gene (TNFRSF1A) on chromosome 12p13. A disproportionate number of the 50 or so as- sociated mutations disrupt the coding of cysteine residues in the first and second extracellular domains. Pathology TNF is a key mediator in the inflammatory response, with several activities including increased expression of adhesion molecules, induction of cytokine secretion, and activation of leucocytes. TNF receptor 1 (TNFR1) is a member of the death domain superfamily and comprises an extracellular region containing four cysteine-rich domains, a transmembrane domain, and an intracellular death do- main. Binding of TNF results in trimerization of the receptor and activation of NF-κB, with downstream induction of inflammation or apoptosis. Under normal circumstances, TNF signalling is ter- minated by cleavage of the extracellular domain; this results in the release of soluble TNFR1 into the plasma, competitively inhibiting the binding of circulating TNF to cell surface receptors. The mechanisms by which heterozygous TRFRSF1A mutations cause TRAPS are still unclear, and may well vary according to the specific mutation. Postulated explanations have included defective TNFR1 shedding from the cell surface, TNF-induced apoptosis, NF- κB activation, aberrant activation of c-Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK) and p38 mitogen-activated protein kinases (MAPK), and mitochon- drial reactive oxygen species inducing proinflammatory cytokine production. Recent work has focused on aberrant trafficking of the variant protein inducing an unfolded protein response and endo- plasmic reticulum stress with production of reactive oxygen species. These intracellular stress responses appear to be mediated by inositol- requiring enzyme 1α (IRE1α), protein kinase-like endoplasmic re- ticulum kinase (PERK), and activating transcription factor 6 (ATF6). Epidemiology TRAPS was first described in 1982, somewhat tongue-in-cheek, as ‘familial Hibernian fever’, reflecting a preponderance of pa- tients from Ireland and Scotland in early reports. It is now clear that TRAPS occurs in diverse populations, including white, Jewish, Arab, and Central American populations, but the disease is rare with an estimated prevalence of 1 to 2 per million. Males and females are affected equally and the median age at presentation is 4 years. Most mutations are associated with high penetrance, but one variant that can be associated with TRAPS (R92Q) is present in approximately 2% of healthy chromosomes, and is thus variously regarded as a low- penetrance mutation or polymorphism. Clinical features Attacks of TRAPS are far less distinct than in FMF, sometimes lasting many weeks, and almost one-third of patients have fairly continuous symptoms. Approximately one-third of patients with pathogenic mutations report no family history. This is the case in more than 80% of patients carrying R92Q which tends to be associated with milder disease and older age at presentation. Symptoms are rather Fig. 12.12.2.1 Typical erythematous erysipelas-like rash in a man with familial Mediterranean fever.
12.12.2 Hereditary periodic fever syndromes 2213 variable: more than 95% of patients experience fever and 80% com- plain of arthralgia or myalgia; abdominal pain occurs in 75%, and a rash (often overlying areas of myalgia) occurs in 50%. Other fea- tures include pleuritic pain, lymphadenopathy, conjunctivitis, and periorbital oedema. There are also reports of central nervous system manifestations resembling multiple sclerosis and TNFRSF1A R92Q confers a weak but significant genetic predisposition to multiple sclerosis. Clinical investigation Symptoms are almost universally accompanied by a very marked acute phase response. Genetic testing is pivotal in establishing the diagnosis. Interpretation of the significance of R92Q remains diffi- cult and depends heavily on the clinical picture. Treatment Despite high hopes for anti-TNF biological agents, their effect in the treatment of TRAPS has proved disappointing in many patients. Acute attacks can be suppressed with corticosteroids, but pro- longed treatment may be required at potentially harmful doses. IL-1 blockade is the most effective current option in severe TRAPS and in the majority of cases induces a complete disease response. Mevalonate kinase deficiency Genetics MKD is an autosomal recessive disease caused by mutations in the mevalonate kinase gene (MVK) on the long arm of chromosome 12. To date, 160 MKD-associated mutations have been described, spanning exons 2 to 11, the most common of which encode MVK variants V377I and I268T. The carriage frequency in the population of the Netherlands, in which MKD is most prevalent, is estimated to be 1 in 65. Pathology The MVK mutations associated with MKD result in 85 to 95% de- ficiency in mevalonate kinase activity. This enzyme is involved in cholesterol, farnesyl, and isoprenoid biosynthesis. It is not yet known how mevalonate kinase deficiency causes recurrent inflammation, although there is speculation that reduced protein isoprenylation causes defective lymphocyte apoptosis. Other mutations in MVK result in even greater reduction in enzyme activity, and cause the much more severe disease known as mevalonic aciduria. Epidemiology MKD is most prevalent in the Netherlands, where it was first de- scribed as HIDS in 1984. It has subsequently been reported in other populations, including Arabs and South-East Asians, though is least rare among northern European white populations. The disease usually presents in the first year of life and occurs equally in both sexes. There are about 200 patients with MKD on the Dutch disease registry, and only some dozens recognized in the United Kingdom. Clinical features Symptoms are episodic and are often well circumscribed. Attacks are irregular, usually last 4 to 6 days, and can be provoked by vaccination, minor trauma, surgery, or stress. Fever, cervical lymphadenopathy, and abdominal pain with vomiting and diarrhoea are typical. Other common symptoms include headache, arthralgia, large joint arth- ritis, erythematous macules and papules, and aphthous ulcers. Rare complications include intellectual impairment, epilepsy, and retin- itis pigmentosa. The disease sometimes ameliorates in early adult life and older patients may remain free of symptoms for years. Clinical investigation Diagnosis is supported by the presence of mevalonic acid in the urine during clinical attacks when there is an elevated acute phase response. Serum immunoglobulin (Ig)-D and IgA concentration are persistently elevated in 80% of patients although, particularly in the very young, this is nondiscriminative with respect to other autoinflammatory diseases. A mutation in both alleles of MVK can be identified in most patients, more than 80% of whom have the most common V337I variant. Treatment Treatment for milder disease remains largely supportive, including nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) and on-demand corticosteroids. Colchicine and thalidomide have no convin- cing benefit. There is no evidence of benefit from treatment with simvastatin, an inhibitor of 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl coenzyme A (HMG-CoA) reductase (the enzyme before MKD in the chol- esterol biosynthetic pathway). There are reports of responses to etanercept, tocilizumab, and anti-IL-1 agents; the latter are currently the most widely used biologics. In severe early-onset disease, bone marrow transplantation can be curative. Cryopyrin-associated periodic syndromes Genetics CAPS comprises a spectrum of disease associated with mutations in the gene NLRP3/CIAS1 on chromosome 1q44 that encodes the death domain protein variously known as NLRP3 (previously NALP3) and cryopyrin. Dominant inheritance is evident in about 75% of patients with MWS and FCAS, whereas CINCA, the most severe phenotype, is usually due to a de novo mutation. More than 140 single amino acid substitutions have been reported; the majority in exon 3. Somatic mosaicism is increasing recognized in both early- and later-onset disease. The relationship between mutation and clin- ical phenotype can differ between individuals, even within a family, although some mutations are associated with a greater risk of neuro- logical damage. Pathology NLRP3 is expressed in peripheral blood leucocytes and chondro- cytes, and encodes a death domain protein that contains a pyrin do- main, a nucleotide-binding site domain, and a leucine-rich repeat motif. Following recognition and binding, via its leucine-rich repeat, of an intracellular pathogen-associated molecular pattern, NLRP3 associates with other members of the death domain superfamily to form a multimeric cytosolic assembly, the inflammasome. This re- sults in activation of caspase 1, which processes pro-IL-1 to produce the active cytokine; it also up-regulates NF-κB expression, resulting
section 12 Metabolic disorders
2214
in increased IL-1 gene expression. IL-1 is a major proinflammatory
cytokine involved in mediating local and systemic responses to in-
fection and tissue injury. The remarkable response to IL-1 receptor
blockade in CAPS confirms that the clinical features are substan-
tially mediated by IL-1.
Epidemiology
So far, most reported patients have European ancestry, but CAPS
occurs worldwide. Onset of disease is in early infancy, and there is
no sex bias.
Clinical features
FCAS was first described in 1940 as recurrent episodes of cold-
induced fever, arthralgia, red eye (with inflammation at multiple
levels), and rash. MWS was described in 1962 as a much more per-
sistent urticaria-like rash, conjunctivitis, arthralgia, and fever, com-
plicated by progressive sensorineural deafness and a high risk of AA
amyloidosis (Fig. 12.12.2.2). CINCA was described as a sporadic se-
vere inflammatory disorder that presents in the neonatal period with
involvement of many organs including the skin, skeletal system, and
central nervous system. Bony overgrowth and premature ossification
may occur, particularly in the skull and knees, and chronic aseptic
meningitis can result in severe developmental delay, optic atrophy,
and deafness. It is now evident that FCAS, MWS (Fig. 12.12.2.3), and
CINCA represent a spectrum of a single disease entity.
Clinical investigation
There is usually an acute phase response, and often leucocytosis and
thrombocytosis that can vary substantially between measurements,
and may not at times be present in some patients at the milder end of
the disease spectrum (i.e. with FCAS and mild MWS). Audiometric
evidence of sensorineural hearing loss should be sought, and charac-
teristic bony abnormalities may be radiologically evident in CINCA.
Features consistent with chronic meningitis may be evident on
lumbar puncture, fundoscopy, and MRI. A mutation in NLRP3 can
be readily identified in most patients with FCAS and MWS, though
about half of those with CINCA are somatic mosaics.
Treatment
Treatment with anti-IL-1 agents produces rapid and often complete
clinical and serological remission of CAPS. Three IL-1 inhibitors,
anakinra, canakinumab and rilonacept, are licensed for the treat-
ment of CAPS. There is hope that early treatment may prevent
neurological and skeletal abnormalities.
Other hereditary periodic fever syndromes
Pyogenic arthritis, pyoderma gangrenosum,
and acne (PAPA) syndrome
This autosomal dominant disease is caused by mutations in
CD2BP1/PTSTPIP1, the gene encoding CD2 binding protein 1. The
underlying pathogenesis remains poorly understood, although
there is evidence that CD2 binding protein 1 interacts with the pyrin
pathway. It is characterized by early-onset recurrent sterile arthritis
typically occurring after minor trauma, severe cystic acne, and pyo-
derma gangrenosum. Penetrance seems variable and asymptomatic
gene carriage is recognized. There is no proven treatment, responses
to steroids are usually partial, and early reports suggest variable re-
sponses to anti-TNF or anti-IL-1 agents. In general, skin disease is
more treatment refractory than the arthritis.
Blau’s syndrome
This was first described in 1985 as an autosomal dominant syn-
drome of sarcoid-like granulomatous infiltration causing a triad of
arthritis, dermatitis, and uveitis. Sporadic disease in the absence
of a family history is sometimes called early-onset sarcoidosis. The
joint involvement is usually synovitis or tenosynovitis, sometimes
causing camptodactyly (fixed flexion deformity of the proximal
interphalangeal joint, usually most marked in the little finger).
The rash is characteristically tan coloured and can be ichthyotic.
Approximately a third of patients develop visual impairment from
panuveitis and its complications. Other recognized features in-
clude fever, erythema nodosum, granulomatous hepatitis, and large
vessel vasculitis.
Fig. 12.12.2.2 Typical rash of mevalonate kinase deficiency. These
lesions appear during febrile attacks.
Fig. 12.12.2.3 Urticarial rash of Muckle–Wells syndrome. These lesions,
accompanied by conjunctivitis, arthralgia, and fever, appeared daily in
the early evenings.
12.12.2 Hereditary periodic fever syndromes
2215
Presentation is usually before the age of 5 years and is caused
by missense mutations in NOD2/CARD15, another member of the
death domain superfamily. NOD2 mutations have also been im-
plicated in familial Crohn’s disease but the gain-of-function mu-
tations in Blau’s syndrome occur in the NACTH domain whereas
in Crohn’s disease, there are loss-of-function mutations in the
LRR region. The NOD2 mutations associated with Blau’s syn-
drome have not been found in adults with sarcoidosis. Most cases
are steroid responsive but steroid-sparing agents and increas-
ingly anti-TNF therapy may be required in more severe disease
(Fig. 12.12.2.4).
NALP12-associated periodic fever syndrome
This autosomal dominant syndrome was described in 2008 in fam-
ilies from the Caribbean. Patients presented in infancy or the neo-
natal period with a syndrome with some features of cold induction,
fever, arthralgia and myalgia, urticarial rash, and sensorineural deaf-
ness. The nonsense and splice site mutations identified in NALP12
appear to reduce its inhibitory effect on NF-κB signalling. There is
no established treatment.
Deficiency of the IL-1 receptor antagonist (DIRA)
This autosomal recessive disease was first described in 2009. It is due
to mutations in the IL1RN gene that result in total deficiency of IL-1
receptor antagonist. The disease has been reported in only a handful
of families of various ethnicities including Northern Europe and
Central America. The disease presents in the immediate neonatal
period with a pustular rash, joint swelling, multifocal osteitis of the
ribs and long bones, heterotopic ossification, and periarticular soft
tissue swelling. Treatment is replacement of the missing protein with
recombinant IL-1Ra (anakinra), and good responses have been re-
ported in all patients treated so far.
Majeed’s syndrome
This autosomal recessive syndrome characterized by chronic
recurrent
multifocal
osteomyelitis
(CRMO),
congenital
dyserythropoietic anaemia, and inflammatory dermatosis was first
described in 1989 in consanguineous Arab kindred. Onset is usu-
ally in the neonatal period and attacks consist of several days of
fever, severe pain, and the appearance of periarticular soft tissue
swelling. Long-term complications of growth retardation and
flexion contractures are well recognized. The disease was found to
be due to mutations in LPIN2, a widely expressed gene thought to
play a role in lipid metabolism, in 2005. NSAIDs and corticoster-
oids can provide symptomatic relief. Recent case reports suggest
IL-1 blockade may be effective although the long-term effect on
dyserythropoiesis is not yet known
Deficiency of interleukin-36 receptor
antagonist (DITRA)
This rare disease is a recessively inherited autoinflammatory disease
due to mutations in IL36RN resulting in unregulated signalling of
IL-36α, -β, and -γ. It is characterized by recurrent episodes of a gen-
eralized sterile pustular psoriasis accompanied with neutrophilia, a
marked acute phase response, and fever. Age at onset varies from
childhood to the sixth decade. Episodes may be precipitated by
stress, pregnancy, or initiation or withdrawal of drugs and can be
life-threatening. There is no established treatment but case reports
suggest anakinra has been beneficial.
Chronic atypical neutrophilic dermatosis
with lipodystrophy and elevated temperature
(CANDLE syndrome) or proteasome-associated
autoinflammatory syndrome (PRAAS), or joint
contractures, muscular atrophy, microcytic anaemia,
and panniculitis-induced lipodystrophy (JMP)
This recessive disease is characterized by a neonatal onset of inter-
mittent fevers, swollen violaceous eyelids, thicken lips, erythema-
tous rash with a mixed myeloid, neutrophilic, and histiocytic
infiltrate on skin biopsy, arthralgia/arthritis, and progressive
lipodystrophy with later-onset joint contractures and raised acute
phase response. Patients have been found to carry PSM8 mutations.
This encodes an inducible subunit of the immune proteosome and
deficiency is postulated to result in failure of proteolysis resulting
in accumulation of damaged protein and intracellular stress. This
appears to result in dysregulation of the interferon signalling
pathway and early reports suggest treatment with Janus kinase in-
hibitors may be useful.
IL-10 receptor deficiency
This is also known as early-onset inflammatory bowel disease and
presents with enterocolitis with perianal fistulae, recurrent fever,
arthritis, and folliculitis in the first 3 months of life. It is a reces-
sive disease caused by mutations in IL10RA, IL10RB, or IL10 re-
sulting in decreased IL-10 signalling and macrophage activation.
Conventional treatment of inflammatory bowel disease is ineffective
and bone marrow transplantation has been curative.
Autoinflammation and PLCγ2-associated antibody
deficiency and immune dysregulation (APLAID)
Only a single kindred is known with this autosomal dominant
disease caused by gain-of-function mutations in PLCG2 which
encodes phospholipase Cγ2 (PLCγ2). This enzyme is involved
in several immunological pathways and in APLAID it may acti-
vate the NLRP3 inflammasome. Patients have low IgA and IgM
and immunodeficiency with recurrent sinopulmonary infections.
Autoinflammatory features include blistering rash, interstitial
pneumonitis, ocular inflammation, and arthralgia. Deletions in
Fig. 12.12.2.4 Camptodactyly due to Blau’s syndrome.
section 12 Metabolic disorders
2216
PLCG2 are known to cause a different syndrome, PLCγ2-associated
antibody deficiency and immune dysregulation (PLAID) with an
autoimmune phenotype.
Haem-oxidized IRP2 ubiquitin ligase 1 deficiency
(HOIL-1 deficiency)
This fatal autosomal recessive disease has been reported in two fam-
ilies and is due to loss-of-function mutations in HOIL1 also known
as RBCK. This encodes a component of the linear ubiquitin chain
assembly complex, which adds polyubiquitin chains to substrate
proteins and plays a role in NF-κB induction. The phenotype is a
combination of severe immunodeficiency and autoimmunity with
recurrent fever, systemic inflammation, hepatosplenomegaly, and
lymphadenopathy. The patients also developed amylopectinosis
resulting in skeletal and cardiac myopathy. All four affected indi-
viduals died in childhood, cortisteroids were reported to be symp-
tomatically helpful.
Deficiency of ADA2 (DADA2)
This was first described in 2014 as a monogenetic form of polyarteritis
nodosa (PAN). It is a recessive disease caused by loss-of-function
mutations in CECR1 encoding adenosine deaminase 2 (ADA2).
ADA2 is thought to be a growth factor for endothelial cells as well
as leucocytes and deficiency appears to induce an inflammatory
vasculopathy. Clinical manifestations include childhood systemic
and local PAN, recurrent fever, mild immunodeficiency, livedo ra-
cemose, and early-onset stroke. Treatment with anti-TNF agents has
been reported to be effective and bone marrow transplantation has
been reported to induce clinical benefit and improve ADA2 levels.
A small study of fresh frozen plasma as a source of replacement
ADA2 in acute attacks was not supportive.
STING-associated vasculopathy with onset
in infancy (SAVI)
This autosomal dominant disease due to gain-of-function muta-
tions in TMEM173 (encoding the stimulator of interferon genes
(STING)) was first described in 2014 and results in increased inter-
feron 1 signalling. Fewer than 20 patients are known and the dis-
ease is characterized by very early-onset facial and digital rash with
scarring, cartilage destruction, and capillaritis on biopsy. Other fea-
tures include failure to thrive, lymphadenopathy, fever, and intersti-
tial lung disease. There is no proven treatment but treatment with
Janus kinase inhibitors seems rational based on the apparent role of
upregulated interferon signalling.
Autoinflammatory diseases of unknown aetiology
Periodic fever, aphthous stomatitis, pharyngitis, and
adenitis (PFAPA)
First described in 1987, the diagnosis is suggested by a recurrent fever
of early onset and one of the following associated symptoms: oral
aphthous ulcers, cervical lymphadenopathy, or pharyngitis, in the
absence of recurrent upper respiratory tract infections or cyclic
neutropenia. Characteristically the children are entirely well be-
tween attacks. In a large case series, median age at presentation was
2.5 years and 83% of children presented before their fifth birthday
with a slight male preponderance of 62%. The ‘acronym symptoms’
of aphthous oral ulcers, pharyngitis, and cervical lymphadenopathy
are frequently not all present during a single attack. During attacks,
the acute phase response is often strikingly elevated. In general the
prognosis is good and most children will outgrow their symptoms
within a decade.
For many clinicians, the strongest diagnostic pointers are the
extreme regularity of attacks (although attacks may be missed
particularly in the summer) and the response to a small dose of cor-
ticosteroids. Before diagnosis, recurrent infections and cyclic neu-
tropenia must be excluded.
The first-line treatment of PFAPA is a single dose of corticosteroid
given at the start of the attack. Padeh et al. suggested that the dra-
matic response to a single oral dose of corticosteroids is sufficiently
unique to PFAPA syndrome that it could be used as a diagnostic
criterion. The H2 receptor antagonist cimetidine and colchicine have
been tried in PFAPA with variable reports of success. Tonsillectomy
is the only treatment for which there is supportive evidence from
clinical studies. Tonsillectomy can be curative in PFAPA; in gen-
eral, more than 50% of children appear to have excellent long-term
results. However, these data may be biased since many centres se-
lectively refer children with persistently enlarged tonsils for surgery,
and it is possible that responses may occur preferentially in this
subgroup.
Schnitzler’s syndrome
This was first reported in 1974 and is characterized by a chronic
urticarial-like rash, a monoclonal IgM (IgM kappa in 85%)
gammopathy, and systemic inflammation usually presenting as
fever. The median age at onset is 51 years and there is a slight
male preponderance. The monoclonal protein appears central
to the pathogenesis although the mechanism remains unclear.
About a fifth of patients eventually progress to overt plasma cell
malignancy. Chemotherapy has been used in the past but does
not appear to relieve the syndrome and should only be used
for conventional haematological indications. The treatment of
choice for Schnitzler’s syndrome is IL-1 blockade which is highly
effective.
Differential diagnosis of the hereditary periodic
fever syndromes
These diseases have a broad differential diagnosis, particularly
at first presentation, which is influenced by age and encompasses
a vast spectrum of infectious, immune, and neoplastic disorders
(Table 12.12.2.2). Conversely, symptoms such as fever, arthralgia,
and rashes in a patient known to have a hereditary periodic fever
syndrome may also result from an alternative intercurrent disorder.
Prognosis and complications
Although CINCA/NOMID can be sufficiently severe to cause death
within the first few decades, life expectancy among most patients
12.12.2 Hereditary periodic fever syndromes
2217
with hereditary recurrent fever syndromes is relatively good, and ex-
cellent in those for whom there is now effective therapy. The most
serious and life-threatening complication of these diseases generally
is AA amyloidosis.
AA amyloidosis
This usually presents with proteinuric kidney dysfunction. AA
amyloid fibrils are derived from the circulating acute phase protein
serum amyloid A protein (SAA), which is synthesized by hepato-
cytes under the transcriptional regulation of IL-1, IL-6, and TNFα.
The terminology is either serum amyloid A protein or SAA. The
circulating concentration of SAA in health is less than approxi-
mately 3 mg/litre, but this can rise by up to 1000-fold in the pres-
ence of inflammation. In chronic inflammatory diseases generally,
AA amyloidosis occurs in up to 5% of patients after a median dur-
ation of about 20 years, but is much more frequent among patients
with untreated inherited periodic fever syndromes. This may reflect
their lifelong nature and their capacity to stimulate remarkably high
plasma concentrations of SAA, even when they seem clinically qui-
escent. Before the widespread introduction of colchicine prophy-
laxis, up to 60% of patients with FMF died of amyloidosis, and even
recently it was reported in 13% of a large Turkish series. The inci-
dence of AA amyloidosis in TRAPS and MWS is approximately 25%,
but is less than 5% in MDK, perhaps because the disease often ameli-
orates in early adulthood.
The natural course of AA amyloidosis is renal failure and early
death, but this can be prevented by treatment of the underlying
inflammatory disorder that substantially suppresses the produc-
tion of serum amyloid A. Indeed, treatment such as colchicine
in FMF and anakinra in CAPS can halt further deposition of AA
amyloid, facilitate gradual regression of existing deposits, and lead
to preservation or even improvement in renal function. Regular
long-term measurement of serum amyloid A is vital in patients
with AA amyloidosis.
Likely future developments
The recent elucidation of the pathogenesis of these diseases has led to
major advances in their treatment, most notably in CAPS. It is likely
that continued studies will shed further light on aspects of the innate
immune system and inflammation generally, and on strategies for the
treatment of TRAPS and MKD in particular. The clinical significance
of low-penetrance mutations and polymorphisms in the genes asso-
ciated with inherited periodic fever syndromes will be sought. CAPS
provides a powerful model of IL-1-driven disease, and a uniquely in-
formative test bed for the early-phase development of novel IL-1 in-
hibitors that may have applications in many common inflammatory
disorders, ranging from gout and rheumatoid arthritis to sepsis.
FURTHER READING
Ben-Chetrit E, Levy M (2003). Reproductive system in familial
Mediterranean fever: an overview. Ann Rheum Dis, 62, 916–19.
Canna SW, Goldbach-Mansky R (2015). New monogenic auto
inflammatory diseases—a clinical overview. Semin Immunol, 37, 387–94.
Cowen EW, Goldbach-Mansky R (2012). DIRA, DITRA, and new in-
sights into pathways of skin inflammation: what’s in a name? Arch
Dermatol, 148, 381–4.
Goldbach-Mansky R, et al. (2006). Neonatal-onset multisystem in-
flammatory disease responsive to interleukin-1beta inhibition.
N Engl J Med, 355, 581–92.
Holzinger D, et al. (2015). From bench to bedside and back again: trans-
lational research in autoinflammation. Nat Rev Rheumatol, 10, 573–85.
Lachmann HJ, et al. (2007). Natural history and outcome in systemic
AA amyloidosis. N Engl J Med, 356, 2361–71.
Lachmann HJ, et al. (2014). The phenotype of TNF receptor-associated
autoinflammatory syndrome (TRAPS) at presentation: a series of
158 cases from the Eurofever/EUROTRAPS international registry.
Arthritis Rheum, 73, 2160–7.
Table 12.12.2.2 Differential diagnosis of inherited periodic fever syndromes
Abdominal pain and fever
Thoracic pain and fever
Arthritis and fever
Fever, rash, and myalgia
Nonhereditary periodic
fever syndromes
Acute surgical abdomen
Myocardial infarction
Septic arthritis
Viral illness
PFAPA (periodic fever,
aphthous stomatitis,
pharyngitis, and adenopathy)
Acute cholecystitis
Pneumonia/pleurisy
Juvenile idiopathic arthritis
Systemic lupus erythematosus
Schnitzler’s syndrome
Pyelonephritis
Pericarditis
Rheumatic fever
Cellulitis/erysipelas
Pelvic inflammatory disease
Pulmonary embolism
Lyme disease
Behçet’s disease
Endometriosis
Palindromic arthritis
Cyclic neutropenia
Mesenteric adenitis
Crystalline arthritis (gout) and
calcium pyrophosphate dihydrate
crystal deposition disease
Malignancy
Systemic vasculitis
Adult-onset Stills disease
and systemic-onset juvenile
idiopathic arthritis
Dermatomyositis
Hereditary or acquired
angio-oedema (not
associated with fever)
Adult-onset Stills disease
and systemic-onset juvenile
idiopathic arthritis
No comments to display
No comments to display